contact us at: bethmelekh@gmail.com
בית מלך Beth Melekh
  • Home - דף בית
  • Soundbites with Yaakov
  • Yaakov's Commentary - פירוש יעקב
  • Yeshivah Videos - וִידֵאוֹ
  • This Week at Yeshivah
  • Faith Statement - הצהרת אמונה
  • Worship Songs
  • Yeshivah - ישיבה
  • Weekly Torah - פרשה התורה
  • Yaakov Ben Yehoshua a Concise Life Story
  • Yaakov's BOOKS ספרי שׂל יעקוב
  • Torah Kosher Foods - אוכל כשר
  • Festivals 5780 - 5781 - חגים
  • Affiliate - בית הכנסת שותפים
  • Counting the Omer - ספירת העומר
  • Eliyahu Chris Hennessy

This Jew Boy will be Celebrating Christmas on the 25th of December

19/12/2015

 
I for one will continue to celebrate the birth of the Messiah (on the 25th of December), because if not for His birth I would not have been reborn!
Picture
With so much foolish conjecture over the dating of Christmas—and by conjecture I mean that there is no irrefutable evidence to point to who first decided on the date of Christmas or who first celebrated Messiah’s birth on the 25th of December. We are wise to examine the motivation for the argument against celebrating Christmas.
​
Many so called Messianic Gentiles (Judaizers: not Jews) are asking the question, “Should we celebrate Christmas?” and concluding, “Believers should not celebrate Christmas!” But their conclusions are based on foolish assumption and a revisionist interpretation of history that only leads to needless arguments and the condemnation of others.

“That you may command certain people not to teach false doctrines any longer or to devote themselves to myths and endless genealogies. Such things promote controversial speculations rather than advancing G-d’s work—which is by faith. The goal of this command is love, which comes from a pure heart and a good conscience and a sincere faith. Some have departed from these and have turned to meaningless talk. They want to be teachers of the Torah, but they do not know what they are talking about or what they so confidently affirm.” – 1 Timothy 1:3-7

For an extensive rebuttal of the anti-Christmas movement, please click on the link below:

http://bethmelekh.weebly.com/yaakovs-blog---14991514148914971493-15131500-1497150615111489/christmas-an-open-letter-to-the-haters

If we are asking the question, “Should we celebrate Christmas?” we’re already in error. Why? Because the question itself comes from the yetzer ha-ra (the evil inclination). The motivation behind this question is illuminated when we expand the meaning of the composite title Christmas: Messiah is sent. What we are actually asking is, “Should we celebrate the birth of the Messiah?” The motivation is clearly seen in the fruit of those who refuse the current date for celebration, many of whom cease to celebrate Messiah’s birth altogether.

The question, “Should we celebrate Christmas?” is at best foolishness and at worst Satanic. First, it causes confusion and brings condemnation upon the unlearned, and is itself supported by supposition rather than fact. It is in fact a question asked by the pseudo learned of the unlearned, a prime example of the blind leading the blind. Second, this question gives way to a greater tragedy, which is the deciding against celebrating Messiah’s birth entirely, regardless of when He was born. This in turn eventually breathes doubt into the historical legitimacy of His birth and when that doubt is watered by conspiracy it gives way to disbelief. Third, if Yeshua’s birth is not remembered and celebrated based on the fact that it’s not directly commanded by G-d, there is then no remembrance platform for Messiah’s earthly life and ministry, making the celebration of His resurrection an equally unbiblical practice. After all, if Christmas is unbiblical because it’s not commanded in the Torah, then Messiah’s death, resurrection and ascension are also unbiblical.

As I’ve explained, the root of the problem is the motivation for the question. Contrary to popular belief, there are wrong questions, they’re those questions asked by the evil inclination, born of human folly, and fuelled by satanic delusion. Rather than give in to this darkness, we should allow the Holy Spirit to ignite the yetzer tov (good inclination), and ask a right question.

In the present case the wrong question is, “Should we celebrate Christmas?” Whereas the right question is, “Why shouldn’t we celebrate the birth of the Messiah Yeshua (Jesus the Christ)?” The former begins with an argument over dates and ends by calling into doubt the legitimacy of the celebration of Messiah’s birth, whereas the latter results in the celebration of the greatest new arrival of all time.

In light of the abundant conjecture entered into by so many, may I offer what I believe to be a conjecture that is in the true spirit of the Gospel? We know that Chanukah begins on the 25th of Kislev. Isn’t it possible that early Jewish and Gentile followers of Yeshua saw a correlation between Messiah’s birth and dedication (Chanukah), the celebration of light (the festival of lights), and wanting to secure their belief in the historical fact of Messiah’s birth through a practice of remembrance, decided together, Jew and Gentile, to celebrate the human birth of the light of the world on the 25th of December. And isn’t it further possible, that all this happened long before the second century CE and the politicizing of Christianity, and that the date was maintained rather than usurped from a pagan celebration. Sometimes I think the majority of protestant Christian historians are so enamoured with the word syncretisation that they’ve become unable to see beyond the walls of their own myopic thinking.

Regardless of dating and tradition I am determined not to be swayed by those who argue over the keeping of days, and act in a contrary manner to the Gospel by condemning other believers:

“Therefore do not let anyone judge you by what you eat or drink, or with regard to a religious festival, a New Moon celebration or a Sabbath day. These are a shadow of the things that were to come; the reality, however, is found in Messiah.” –Colossians 2:16-17

Note that the reality of all these occasions is to be found in Messiah.

I for one will continue to celebrate the birth of the Messiah (on the 25th of December), because if not for His birth I would not have been reborn!

© Alastair Yaakov ben Yehoshua Brown, 25 Kislev 5776

A Story of Chanukah

16/12/2015

 
The Menorah continued to burn until finally on the eighth day, after more oil had been consecrated, the miracle gave way to the practice of the priests. 
Picture
It was the winter of 165 BCE and the known world was ruled by an anti-messiah name Antiochus Epiphanes. The darkness of his empire reached its greatest depths in the land of Israel where he had banned all practices associated with the worship of the G-d of Israel. The darkness was not confined to the physical world. Many in Israel, having suffered under relentless persecution, had turned away from worshipping G-d, Israel’s temple had been defiled, and the light of her holy Menorah had been snuffed out.
​
A small army of Jewish warrior priests lead by Judah Maccabee, approached the court of Israel inside the Temple complex in Jerusalem. Despite the size of their army they had defeated the Tyrant Antiochus and his hordes and were now seeking to restore and rededicate the Temple of Israel’s G-d.

As they walked past the altar of sacrifice toward the doorway of the Temple they saw the remnants of burnt pig skin and smelt the foul stench of pigs’ blood. Several of the men buckled at the knees and vomited in disgust at this sacrilege, others hardened their resolve and moved forward toward the entrance of the Holy place.

The Temple was dark, devoid of light, and as they entered the men tripped on debris and slid on pig fat and faeces. One of the soldiers lit a torch, the flame struggled against the cold wind that blew in from behind them. Suddenly, as if by divine edict the wind stopped and the flame grew strong, illuminating the Holy place and revealing the full extent of the desecrations that had been perpetrated there. An Idol of the Greek god Zeus stood in the Holy of Holies and the remnants of pig and fowl carcases littered the floor. The seven branched Menorah, the windowless Temple’s only source of light, lay toppled on the stone floor and the incense altar was overflowing with urine.

Judah and his men fell to their knees, they sobbed like helpless children and in the torch light they cried out to the G-d of Israel, “Hoshiyahna!” Save us now! In the midst of their wailing and hopelessness they heard the voice of a young boy who had followed them into the Temple courts. He yelled out at the top of his lungs, “I’ve found a jug of undefiled oil, the priestly seal is still on it. I discovered it hidden beneath the floor in one of the side rooms”.

The silence that ensued was palpable, something shifted in the atmosphere and the walls of the Temple seemed to radiate heat. As the boy lifted up the jug of oil, it glistened in the torch light. Judah called to his men and had them begin to cleanse the Temple, he collected the oil and used it to light the Menorah, knowing that there was only enough oil to last for one day. As the oil of the sevenfold lamp took fire, the Temple came to life and the hope of G-d filled the hearts of the heroic priestly soldiers of Israel.

Day after day they returned to the Temple, and day after day the Menorah continued to burn until finally on the eighth day, after more oil had been consecrated, the miracle gave way to the practice of the priests. The Temple, once defiled and thrown into darkness was now restored to life with the light of G-d and the symbol of His Spirit and present glory.
On the eighth day as Judah returned to his residence he walked through the section of the Temple complex known as Solomon’s colonnade. Some of the Judeans asked him, “What shall we do with the defiled altar stones? They can’t be used again because we’re unable to purge them of the pigs blood that they’ve absorbed. But at the same time we can’t throw them out because they’ve been part of the Holy Temple service.” Judah responded, “Put them aside in a secure location and when the Messiah comes we will ask Him what we should do about the defiled altar.” And so they did as Judah had instructed, and Israel waited.

Some 200 years later circa 30 CE it was the time of the Festival of Chanukah in Jerusalem. It was winter, and Yeshua was in the temple courts walking in Solomon’s Colonnade. Some of the Judeans who were there gathered around Him, and asked, “How long will you keep us in suspense? If you are the Messiah, tell us publically.” (Yochanan/John 10:22-24)
Jesus answered them, “I have already told you, and you don’t trust me. The works I do in my Father’s name testify on my behalf, but the reason you don’t trust is that you are not included among my sheep. My sheep listen to my voice, I recognize them, they follow me, and I give them eternal life. They will absolutely never be destroyed, and no one will snatch them from my hands. My Father, who gave them to me, is greater than all; and no one can snatch them from the Father’s hands. I and the Father are one.” (Yochanan/John 10:25-30)

Through His sacrificial death on behalf of Israel and the nations and by His resurrection, Yeshua answered the question of what to do with the defiled altar stones:

“Throw them away, you don’t need them anymore!”

Yeshua had come to set alight a nation of priests (1 Peter 2:9), who would not only light up the physical temple but would become the temple of the living G-d, both individually and corporately.

In Messiah we have become warrior priests like the Maccabees. We have also become the temple of the living God of Israel.

The historical stories we’ve just heard serve as a challenge to us today both as individual believers and as an Ecclesia (Set apart community).

Like the Jews of both 165 BCE and 30 CE, we too are living in a world that is being oppressed by dark empires vying for supremacy. But the similarity doesn’t end there. The Bible says that we have become the Temple of G-d, both individually and corporately (1 Corinthians 3:16; 6:19).

Therefore we must ask ourselves afresh at this time of re-dedication (Chanukah), “Is there darkness in us?” If so, only the light of Yeshua fuelled by the oil of the Holy Spirit can illuminate that darkness.

This is a time when we choose to allow G-d to speak to us concerning that which we have allowed to defile us and respond in repentance asking Him to illuminate our lives afresh both individually and corporately.

The Menorah is a wonderful symbol of G-d’s present glory. It is also a symbol given to the Ecclesia to show us that we are all connected in Messiah, set alight by His Gospel and fuelled by His Holy Spirit.

In response to G-d we light the Chanukah Menorah candles from the central flame, the Shamash, which represents the servant Messiah and as we do, we contemplate the unity of light that we share in Him.

© 2015 Alastair Brown

Isaiah 9:1 (2) – 6 (7): For Unto us a Boy is Born

9/12/2015

 
With the exception of Avi’ad, the names here are not composites like, “Shmuel (Samuel), Avimelech, Avraham etc. To the contrary they are precise descriptions of the very nature of this child. Where the composite names common to the Tanakh (OT) reflect G-d’s functional purpose for the individual, these names describe G-d with us (Emmanuel). Meaning that this child is G-d, Yeshua, the fully G-d and fully man Messiah of Israel.
Picture
An examination of Isaiah 9:1 (2) – 6 (7).

Introduction:

In the Hebrew Tanakh (OT), this passage begins with the verse which describes a specific people (Ha-am: the people) living in darkness. The phrase, “Ha-am” is synonymous with the people of Israel. Making this verse the ultimate verse of this chapter is a correct distribution of contextual markers (chapter & verse) because the prophet Isaiah is recording a new creation in these poetic and prophetic words concerning the Messiah’s entry into time and space as a new born male child, and this new creation correlates to the New Covenant promised to the house of Israel (Yisra: overcome, in El: G-d) and the house of Judah (Praise) [Jeremiah 31:31]. Thus through the boy (Yeshua) we overcome in G-d and are redeemed that we might praise the G-d of love and reconciliation.
​
While the context is understood to be in the wake of the Assyrian invasion of the north (734 and 732 BC, 2 Kings 15:29), which resulted in Naphtali suffering greatly, we are wise to measure our conclusions regarding who this past tense prophecy of Isaiah applies to. While this type of prophecy usually seeks to correlate a future fulfilment with a past persona or event, this particular prophecy is the subject of much futile conjecture. The key to understanding it is in verse 6(7):

“In order to increase the government and bring peace, (wholeness, completion and soundness)
without end to the throne and kingdom of David (Beloved of G-d), to secure it and sustain it
through mishpat
(judgement) and tz’dakah (righteousness) from this time forth and eternally (v’ad) forever (olam).”

What this section of the text makes clear is that the kingdom being spoken of is an eternal one, therefore no kingdom prior to Isaiah’s writing, or any kingdom since (with the exception of the inception of Messiah’s kingdom) qualifies. This text can only be understood in light of future fulfilment. Additionally this kingdom must be connected to the throne of David, which is a figurative form that is synonymous with the Messiah’s reign.

This portion of Isaiah is one of Israel’s oldest Messianic prophecies, much disputed by certain rabbinical scholars and anti-evangelists, but affirmed by both the Messiah Himself and the New Testament writers. It is a glimpse into the wonderful meta-narrative of G-d’s redemptive story, a drawing together of the first creation and the future re-creation. During the festival of lights, we are wise to rededicate (Chanukah) the temples of our bodies, both plural and singular, allowing the Light of the world (Yeshua) to illuminate the darkness that seeks to blind us to the Holy home that the Father and the Son have prepared for each of us.

The Text:

1 (2) The people (ha-am: people of Israel) whose walking's (Haholchim) are in darkness (Choshek: Genesis 1:2)have seen, (perceived and understood) great light (Or gadol: Genesis 1:3-5);
those living (dwelling, remaining) in the land (B’eretz: Land of Israel) that lies
in the shadow of death, light has enlightened (rested upon) them.
 
The Hebrew text opens with, “ha-am”, the people/tribe, and refers, as indicated by the remainder of the text of Isaiah 9, to Israel [verse 2(3) uses ha-goy: the nation, also synonymous with Israel]. It is therefore Israel whose walking’s (way of life, actions) are in darkness and Israel that has seen the great light. This is affirmed by the phrase, “B’eretz” (in the land), which refers specifically to the land of Israel. It is the land (where the Jewish people live), that lies in the shadow of death, meaning that a shadow is being cast over the entire nation by darkness itself. They have been in danger of death both physical and spiritual. However, the light shines in the darkness and the darkness cannot overcome it (John 1:5).
 
We should note that the Hebrew, “Ha-holchim” is from the root, “Halakh”, meaning, “to go, walk”, from which we get the common rabbinical term Halakhah (the way we walk), which in turn refers to the way we live out our theological belief. Remembering of course that in ancient Jewish religious thought there is no separation of theology and action. Therefore we’re able to conclude that Israel (ha-am: the nation) where both living and working out their spirituality in darkness (a metaphor for evil).
 
This prophecy links the creation to the nation of Israel. “Or gadol”, is the great light of Genesis 1:3-5, which is spoken (D’var/Kol) from the mouth of G-d, this light is not subject to the sun or moon, or to the limitation of the 24 hour day, but is the light of G-d’s revelation that illuminates all things.

2 (3) Who (The light) enlarged the nation (ha-goy: singular, meaning Israel) not growing in joy;
they rejoice in (the presence of) your face as if rejoicing at harvest time, the way men rejoice when dividing up plunder (rejoicing over a victory won).
 
It is G-d, as light, Who enlarges the nation of Israel even while she is in darkness. The phrase, “not growing in joy” finds its poetic double in the former phrase, “living in darkness”. Whereas the phrase, “they rejoice at (seeing) Your face” finds its poetic double in the former phrase, “have seen great light”. In other words G-d’s face is a great light to the people of Israel.
 
The people of Israel rejoice over the victory won on their behalf by G-d’s light, like those who understand that the harvest has been secure and that there will be ample food for the coming days. Their enemies have been overcome and all the plunder taken from Israel in the past has been returned to them.
 
This is of course an allegory for the Gospel of Messiah and can be applied as a drash (illuminated spiritual teaching) to both ethnic Israel and those among the nations who have received the light of the Messiah.

3 (4) That the yoke of burden, the rod across their shoulders,
the sceptre of oppression is shattered in the day of Midyan (literally: strife and figuratively: overcoming idolatry and the pollution of a nation, Numbers 31)

The yoke is a Hebrew euphemism meaning both rule and teaching. If the yoke is a burden then it is an oppressive rule, one that emulates Israel’s slavery in Egypt and ultimately represents Israel’s slavery to sin. This oppressive rule over the hearts, minds and souls of Israel has and will yet be shattered.
 
This will be done again at a time in the future when Israel is in strife (Midyan) under an oppressive rule. The joy of deliverance will echo throughout Judea and Israel, just as it echoed throughout the borders of the land when Israel conquered the Midianites (Numbers 31). We can also link the victory over Midyan to Gideon’s victory recorded in Judges 7:22-25, although I believe Isaiah (at the inspiration of G-d) intended the former victory recorded in the book of B’midbar (Numbers: Wilderness).
 
The victory over Midyan (strife) was a victory over Idolatry, sexual immorality and oppression. The Midianites, due to the influence of the false prophet Baalam, had sought to entice Israel into idolatry. The victory over them, commanded by G-d through Moses, included warrior priests, who decimated the Midianite peoples. This is the kind of victory we are reading of here, victory over darkness, idolatry and sin: freedom from slavery to sin and idolatry.
 
The oppressive yoke is spoken of again as being destroyed in Isaiah 10:26-27, where it refers to the defeat of the Assyrians which was to take place in 701 BC. This is yet another reason why we are unwise to make presumptions based on the past tense used in the Hebrew text. With regard to prophecy the past tense is just as likely to strengthen future fulfilment as it is to refer to past events alone.

4 (5) For all the boots of soldiers marching and every cloak rolled in blood is destined for burning,
fuel for the fire (that is the armies who come against G-d and His people).
 
The meaning is clear. All those who had once oppressed and marched against Israel and her G-d, be they physical or spiritual entities, will be destroyed. There are numerous correlations to this throughout the Bible as a whole.
 
5 (6) For a boy (yeled) is born to us, a son (ben) is given to us;
all government (Misra: not just earthly government but all forms of government) will rest on His shoulders, and He will be called by the name (Shem: not just a proper noun but an indication of the functional nature of soul or character), Pele-Yo‘etz El Gibbor Avi-‘Ad Sar-Shalom (Wonderful Counsellor, Mighty G-d, Father of Eternity, Prince of Peace),
 
Where there was once a burden of oppression on Israel, the boy that is born as a gift to Israel will rest all government on His shoulders. This is the counterpoint to the doublet of verses 3 & 4.
 
In Hebrew a person’s name usually describes G-d’s prophetic purpose for their lives. This text follows the same understanding. However, with the exception of Avi’ad, the names here are not composites like, “Shmuel (Samuel), Avimelech, Avraham etc. To the contrary they are precise descriptions of the very nature of this child. Where the composite names common to the Tanakh (OT) reflect G-d’s functional purpose for the individual, these names describe G-d with us (Emmanuel). Meaning that this child is G-d, Yeshua, the fully G-d and fully man Messiah of Israel.
 
The names are in fact one long description of the attributes of G-d with us (Yeshua). “Pele-Yo‘etz El Gibbor Avi-‘Ad Sar-Shalom (Wonderful Counsellor, Mighty G-d, Father of Eternity, Prince of Peace),
 
Some Anti-evangelists, using Targums (ancient commentaries on the Scriptural texts), claim that the names listed describing the child belong to G-d rather than to the Child, and yet G-d is not mentioned in the context of this passage until He is mentioned as being the boy born to us. Even a simple general understanding of grammar tells us that the subject must be presented in the text in order to be named. The subject of these names is the boy. The irony of the anti-evangelist argument is that they have a portion but not all of the truth: the names belong to both G-d and the child, Who is G-d with us (Emmanuel), Yeshua the Mashiyach.
 
In order to pursue the false reading of the anti-evangelists, one must ignore basic Hebrew grammar. The Hebrew “Sh’mo” (his name) indicates that the names that follow belong to the boy described in the preceding verses. Any other reading is at very least dishonest and at worst, worthy of curse, a defiling of the Scripture. The motivation for this is desperate and contrary to Messiah, it is also misspent energy given that there are numerous other passages in the Tanakh that reveal the deity of the coming Messiah (Yeshua), not to mention the literal claims made by Yeshua Himself as to His deity.
 
As followers of Yeshua we understand that anyone who denies that Yeshua is G-d with us is speaking from a spirit of anti-Messiah (anti-Christ).
 
The Rav Shaul/Paul says:
 
“But even if we or an angel (messenger) from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to the one we preached to you, let him be accursed. As we have said before, so now I say again: If anyone is preaching to you a gospel contrary to the one you received, let him be accursed.” –Galatians 1:8-9

6 (7) In order to increase the government and bring peace, (wholeness, completion and soundness)
without end to the throne and kingdom of David (Beloved of G-d), to secure it and sustain it
through mishpat
(judgement) and tz’dakah (righteousness) from this time forth and forever.

Following the couplet of verses 3 & 5, the opening phrase here confirms Israel’s journey from oppression to the Messianic rule of freedom under G-d. While the Hebrew text is in the past tense, it is a known prophetic form that notes certain past events and places a future fulfilment upon them. We know this because it speaks of David’s kingdom as being an eternal one as a result of the boy Who would become king. In order for this kingdom to have been established already, Israel would need to have a current Davidic king ruling over it, a king born thousands of years ago. Therefore we know that the prophet intended a future fulfilment, one that will happen in stages:
 
1.) A child will be born to rule Israel
2.) He will break the oppression of the yoke that is on Israel’s back
3.) He will establish the kingdom of the beloved of G-d (David) as an eternal kingdom and will rule over it

  1. Yeshua was born to be a light to Israel
  2. He broke the yoke of sin off of Israel’s back through His death and resurrection
  3. He is coming again to complete and reign over the eternal kingdom of G-d, which is both physically and metaphorically represented in David’s earthly dynasty (the Beloved of G-d)
 
Yeshua will secure His kingdom through mishpat (Judgement: The Day of The L-rd) and tz’dakah (righteousness: the redeemed of the L-rd).
 
The zeal (like that of a jealous husband) of Adonai-Tzva’ot (YHVH of heavens armies) will accomplish this.
 
It is not just zeal, but the zeal of a jealous husband, that HaShem exhibits in accomplishing these things. G-d is jealous for those He has chosen, both Jew and Gentile. He will not allow idolatrous spiritual adultery to stain His bride.

A Brief Word on Christmas:

This passage from Isaiah prophecies the birth of our Messiah, sent into time and space to redeem us from sin and death. Therefore I feel compelled to speak briefly on the subject of Christmas (Messiah is sent) celebration.
For many and varied illegitimate reasons, a number of modern Christians (Hebrew Roots movement) and Messianics (a term that is now so loosely applied that it has become unable to properly identify any group), have decided not to celebrate Christ-mas (Messiah is sent). This on its own would be of no consequence if they had chosen to celebrate His birth at another time, however in the aftermath of this foolish pseudo-learned decision, they have ceased celebrating the birth of our Messiah altogether. Like the Separatists of the late 19th century, they have become so convinced of their own separation from the Ecclesia (Viewing themselves as the so called “called out” pure Church/Bride), that they have, in seeking purity through their own actions, become subject again to bondage; forgetting that in Messiah we are not keepers of the Torah but rather we are kept by the Living Torah, Ha-d’var Emet (The Word of Truth) Yeshua, Who, if not for His birth into time and space, could not have been crucified and resurrected, thus leaving us without hope. Therefore, let us celebrate His birth, which illuminates His purpose in being sent, that we might also hope in the future glory purchased for us in His death and resurrection.

This year (5776: 2015) our congregation will once again delight ourselves in remembering the birth of our Messiah Yeshua, each one practicing the Biblical remembrance of Christmas (Messiah is sent)  utilizing the symbolism and positive traditions that affirm their own convictions regarding this celebration. We are reminded that every Shabbat we light the candles of Sh’mor (Observance) and Zakhor (Remembrance), therefore we observe the holy day, remembering that Yeshua was born for the purpose of our Salvation (yeshua). We remember what G-d has done, what He is doing and what He has promised to do, in Messiah, The Hope of Glory.

My prayer is that the illumination of the text of Isaiah 9 will aid our joy (Simchataynu) during this season of Chanukah (dedication) and Mashiyach Neshlach (Messiah is sent).

In combination with this study please also consider the articles I’ve written on Luke chapters 1 and 2:

Luke 1:1-38: Choosing Between Disbelief and Wonder
http://bethmelekh.weebly.com/yaakovs-blog---14991514148914971493-15131500-1497150615111489/luke-11-38-choosing-between-disbelief-wonder
Luke 1:39-80: From Generation to Generation
http://bethmelekh.weebly.com/yaakovs-blog---14991514148914971493-15131500-1497150615111489/luke-139-80-ldor-vdor-from-generation-to-generation
Luke 2:1-24: G-d’s Plan is not World Peace, it is Peace for the World
http://bethmelekh.weebly.com/yaakovs-blog---14991514148914971493-15131500-1497150615111489/luke-21-24-g-ds-plan-is-not-world-peace-its-peace-for-the-world
Luke 2:25-52: Hearing About Grace and Favour
http://bethmelekh.weebly.com/yaakovs-blog---14991514148914971493-15131500-1497150615111489/luke-225-52-hearing-about-grace-favour
​

© Alastair Brown

1 Samuel 28:3-21: Saul and the Witch of Eyn-dor

3/12/2015

 
If it seems that G-d is silent in our suffering, it is because He sees a better outcome for us in His stillness than we’re able to see in our turmoil.
Picture
An examination of 1 Samuel 28:3-21.

Introduction:
This has been a passage of Scripture that has confused and mislead many. In English it appears to give foundation to the idea of the disquieted, disembodied spirits of human beings returning to earth. In fact the English text (with the exception of the KJV, NKJV and selected literal translations) is sometimes guilty of hiding specific contextual indicators, like the Hebrew, “elohim” and through the theologically selective use of the Hebrew, “yada”, found in the text in the form, “vayda”.

Much is presumed by the English reader through no fault of his or her own, however this balloon of presumption is easily deflated by the pin prick of Hebrew simplicity. There are of course Hebrew rabbis and scholars who have made similar errors in understanding this text, therefore we must navigate it carefully and succinctly.
The English translations of this text usually leave the reader with some of the following questions:
  • Do ghosts (disembodied human spirits) roam the earth?
  • Is fortune telling based on a genuine spiritual ability to tell the future?
  • Was Saul actually speaking with the disembodied spirit of Samuel?
  • Are human beings conscious in Sheol (the place of the dead, which is divided up into the Bosom of Abraham and Gehinom)?
  • If Saul wasn’t speaking to Samuel why does the text say he was?
  • What part did G-d play in this encounter?

The serious student will have a wealth of other questions, however the few listed above are sufficient for this study.
As we approach this period in Israel’s history and in particular with regard to Saul’s kingship (Israel’s first human king), a number of pivotal events have already taken place:
  • Samuel had died some time ago (1 Samuel 25:1)
  • Saul had removed (cut off/killed) from the land of Israel those who had Familiar (demonic) spirits and practised witchcraft (1 Samuel 28:3, 9; Exodus 22:18)
  • The Kingdom had been torn from Saul’s grasp (1 Samuel 15:26-28; 28:17) and given to David
  • G-d had rejected Saul and departed from him, and was no longer answering Saul’s enquiries (1 Samuel 15:26-28; 28:15)

Each of these foundational elements have worked together to forge Saul’s path to Eyn-dor (Eye of generation). The sum of his sinful decision making processes is the seeking of guidance from Satan (knowingly or unknowingly), via his medium (the witch, necromancer) of Eyn-dor.

Text: 1 Samuel 28:3-21.
1Sa 28:3 Now Sh’muel (Hears from G-d, Named by G-d) was dead, and all Israel had lamented him, and buried him in Ramah (High place), even in his own city. And Shaul (asked) had put away those that had familiar spirits, and the magicians, out of the land (ha-aretz: Eretz /Israel).
 
This account begins by reminding the reader that Sh’muel (Samuel), the one who hears from G-d, is dead. Why? As the narrative continues we see that the common theme is Shaul’s (Saul: meaning to asks, inquire) inability to hear from G-d. In the past Sh’muel (Hears from G-d) had been the prophet through whom Shaul had heard G-d’s instructions, now the asking one (Shaul) was unable to hear from the hearing one (Sh’muel).
 
Sh’muel was dead, had been buried and according to Jewish understanding was in Sheol in the Bosom of Avraham. Both Sheol and Shaul (Saul) come from the same Hebrew root word, Sha’al which means, to ask. Sheol, the place of the dead, is never satisfied; therefore it is continually asking for more. Israel had asked for a king in place of G-d (The Sustainer of life) and had received a disobedient man as ruler over them. A man who would bring only death. In this account Shaul, asks in vain for the council of G-d and in the end Sheol asks for Shaul and G-d grants its request.
 
We’re told that Shaul had removed (cut off/killed) from the land of Israel those who had Familiar spirits (demonic forces) and practiced witchcraft (1 Samuel 28:9; Exodus 22:18; Lev. 19:31; 20:6, 27; Deut. 18:10-12). Why are we told this? The text is stressing the fact that Shaul (the enquirer) would have a difficult task searching out someone who practised witchcraft, meaning that he was going to great lengths to pursue practices he knew to be contrary to G-d’s instruction in order to receive direction. In fact he would go to Eyn-dor, a town that Israel did not control, hence he would find himself outside of both personal redemption and national redemption. Shaul was warned against this very thing when Sh’muel rebuked him saying:

“For rebellion is as the sin of witchcraft, and stubbornness is as iniquity and idolatry. Because you have rejected the Word (D’var) of HaShem, He has also rejected your kingship.” –1 Samuel 15:23
 
In fact this passage is illuminated by the person of Yeshua, the Word (John 1) of G-d. When we reject Yeshua we reject G-d. In doing so, as the Scripture says, we stand, “condemned already” (John 3:18).
​
Familiar spirits are demonic entities that roam and gather information in order to deceive people and gain glory for themselves and the darkness they serve. They are known to select hosts, convincing that person that they are controlling the spirit through witchcraft when in fact it is the spirit that is controlling them. These spirits (Hebrew: shad) are synonymous with false deities sometimes called elohim, the same generic term used for G-d, gods, rulers, angels, judges etc.
 
“They sacrificed unto demons (Hebrew: shade), not to G-d; to gods (elohim) whom they knew not, to new gods (elohim)  that came newly up, whom your fathers feared not.” –Deuteronomy 32:17
 
“But I say, that the things which the Gentiles sacrifice, they sacrifice to demons, and not to G-d: and I don’t want you fellowshipping with demons.” –1 Corinthians 10:20
 
These Familiar spirits/gods are trapped within time and space, having been cast out of the third heaven along with Satan (Isaiah 14:12-14; Ezekiel 28:16-17; Luke 10:18). Therefore unless G-d uses them for His purposes, allowing them to know some future event, they have no ability within themselves to tell the future. As a result of this they often use deception so that those who seek them are fooled into believing that these spirits have G-d-like knowledge. This is simply not the case, in fact their power is very limited. Like their ruler Satan, they must ask G-d’s permission in order to act (Job 1:9-12; 1 Kings 22:221-23; 2 Chronicles 18:21-22).
 
1Sa 28:4 And the Philistines gathered themselves together, and came and pitched in Shunem (quietly resting): and Shaul gathered all Israel together, and they pitched in Gilboa (Boiling Spring). 1Sa 28:5 And when Shaul saw the host of the Philistines, he was afraid, and his heart greatly trembled.
 
This was a great Philistine army, gathered from all over the region in order to defeat Shaul’s army. Notice that the enemies of Israel pitch their tents at a place called, “Quietness, resting”, they are confident (G-d has allowed it). This is a stark contrast to the countenance of Shaul, in whom fear “springs up and boils over” (Gilboa).
 
1Sa 28:6 And when Shaul enquired of HaShem, HaShem answered him not, neither by dreams, nor by Urim (lights), nor by prophets.
 
Dreams: intimate and direct personal revelation
Urim: impersonal public revelation by chance object
Prophets: public revelation via an intermediary
 
G-d had so completely rejected Shaul as king (shepherd) of His people Israel, that He would give him no guidance whatsoever. All forms of Divine revelation are covered by these three symbols of the prophetic means of conversation with G-d.
 
It is worth noting that up until Sh’muel’s death (1 Samuel 25:1) Shaul had almost exclusively sought Sh’muel’s council. After killing the priests of G-d (1 Samuel 22:17-23) by the hand of an Edomite (an enemy of G-d and Israel), Shaul lost access to the Urim (lights) and Tumim (completions), which had been carried away with Avi-atar (My Father of Abundance) the son of Achi-melech (My Brother is King). The true Urim and Tumim were now available to David (Beloved of G-d) but not to Shaul. Therefore the Urim in question here are false Urim (lights), however, these false lights could not direct Shaul because they were incomplete (Tumim). Also, the Torah required that the Tumim and Urim be used by a priest, therefore Shaul was not qualified to use them.

Picture
​Notice that Shaul had, by his own hand, sought to symbolically end the possibility of David being King, by murdering Achi-melech (My Brother is King). This was an act of rebellion against G-d Who had chosen David (Beloved of G-d) over Shaul (asks). Shaul asked of G-d but was not in a love relationship with G-d.
 
As a result of Shaul’s murderous rebellion, G-d removed His abundant provision (Avi-atar) from Shaul, and in turn Shaul lost any sense of relationship to G-d as Father. David on the other hand became king and enjoyed an abundant relationship with G-d his Father (Avi-atar).
 
1Sa 28:7 Then Shaul said to his servants, “Seek me a woman that has a familiar spirit that I may go to her, and enquire of her.” And his servants said to him, “Behold, there is a woman that has a familiar spirit at Eyn-dor (Eye of generations).”
 
Shaul does what his name suggests, he enquires, but not of G-d. The servants of Shaul have apparently heard of a woman who practices witchcraft and has a familiar spirit. She lives in Eyn-dor, which means, “Eye of generations”, a name that denotes a stronghold for those who pretended to talk to the dead. The modern term for this woman would be, medium.
 
It’s significant that Eyn-dor was located in the Canaanite territory to the north and was one of the cities Israel had failed to conquer (Joshua 17:11), which means that it had been rooted in idolatry and pagan worship from ancient times. It would also become part of the apostate kingdom of the north when Israel and Judah later become separate kingdoms. 
Picture
Picture
​Shaul would have had to travel past the Philistine position (only 10km to the north-west) in order to go north to Eyn-dor, this would add to his fear and desperation. However, such was his need to get direction and affirmation, that he was willing to take this risk to seek the council of demonic spirits/false gods via a medium.
 
1Sa 28:8 And Shaul disguised himself, and put on other raiment, and journeyed together with the two men and they came to the woman by night: and he said, “Please, divine unto me by the familiar spirit, and bring me up, the one whose name I tell you.”
 
Given that Shaul was about to travel past an enemy encampment and to a medium who he knew would have heard of his past treatment of those who practiced dark arts, it’s natural that he would take off his kingly garments and travel as a civilian. In addition to this, by arriving at night he was limiting the possibility that anyone would recognize him.
 
Metaphorically speaking Shaul has taken off the garments of his kingship, symbolically ending his reign and is hiding himself behind a disguise in order to seek one who attempts to hide from G-d in the darkness. The night symbolizes darkness and the works of the Evil One.
 
“The one whose name I tell you”.  A medium is always able to call up the person requested because her customer is entirely reliant on her vision. When you make a request of someone who practices deception they will always tell you what your itching ears want to hear. This is how they make their living.
 
1Sa 28:9  And the woman said unto him, “Behold, you know what Shaul has done, how he has cut off (killed) those that have familiar spirits, and the magicians, from the land (Eretz Israel): why then do you lay a snare for my life, to cause me to die?” 
 
The medium lived in comparative safety in Eyn-dor because it was not controlled by Israel at the time. Although she clearly still prefers to remain anonymous so as not to invoke the wrath of king Shaul, who she has heard has killed almost all those who have practiced dark arts in opposition to G-d.
 
The woman tests Shaul with this statement, hoping to discern whether he is genuine or just trying to trap her.
 
1Sa 28:10 And Shaul swore to her by HaShem, saying, “As HaShem lives, you shall not receive any punishment for this thing.” 1Sa 28:11 Then the woman said, “Whom shall I bring up unto you?” And he said, “Bring me up Sh’muel (Hears G-d).” 
 
The fact that Shaul swore by HaShem is ironic. By doing so he cursed himself because no man can promise a person who rebels against G-d, that they will not be punished. While Shaul meant that no one in his kingdom would punish her, he fails to realise the weight of his words and their spiritual ramifications.
 
The woman is brazen in her question, insinuating that there is no one whose spirit she could not bring up from the dead. Of course, her patrons can’t see what she claims to see, therefore she has free reign to communicate to them whatever they are asking for.
 
Up until now Sh’muel had not been mentioned in the woman’s presence. He had been known throughout Israel and in the surrounding lands as a powerful prophet of G-d and would have been known as the direct prophetic counsellor to Shaul, Israel’s king. This could not have escaped the hearing of the witch of Eyn-dor.
 
What follows is therefore easily explained:
 
1Sa 28:12 And when the woman considered (saw, envisioned) Sh’muel, she cried with a loud voice: and the woman spoke to Shaul, saying, “Why have you deceived me? For you are Shaul.”
 
The women, “v’teyre” perceives, considers, (knows, sees or envisions) Sh’muel. I believe she has simply made the logical connection between Shaul and Sh’muel and is terrified at the possibility of her own imminent death at the hands of Shaul and his men, whom she believes have tricked her. Thus she cries out in fear and challenges Shaul, accusing him of deceit. The deceiver accusing her client of deceit.
 
1Sa 28:13 And the king said unto her, “Don’t be afraid: now, what do you see?” And the woman said unto Shaul, I see elohim (plural form from the root eloah: gods, rulers, angels, shades, evil spirits) ascending out of the land (ha-aretz). 
 
Shaul quiets her by telling her not to be afraid and then presses her to tell him what she sees via the familiar spirit. Her answer is the key to understanding what follows. What the woman sees is not Shaul or his ghost or his angel or any other part of him: rather what she sees are elohim, gods, coming up from the land (ha-aretz).
 
While elohim is sometimes (rarely) used in the Tanakh (OT) to describe living human rulers or judges, it is never used to describe deceased human beings. Had the writer intended the reader to understand Shaul’s disembodied spirit he would have used the Hebrew word ruach.
 
As stated in the introduction, false gods and demonic forces (Heb: shad) are synonymous.
 
“They sacrificed unto demons (Hebrew: shade), not to G-d; to gods (elohim) whom they knew not, to new gods that came newly up, whom your fathers feared not.” –Deuteronomy 32:17
 
“But I say, that the things which the Gentiles sacrifice, they sacrifice to demons, and not to G-d: and I don’t want you fellowshipping with demons.” –1 Corinthians 10:20
 
These gods are not able to tell the future of their own accord, nor do they have anything to do with the human spirit. They are fallen angels, demonic entities and rulers of the darkness that seek only to satisfy their own evil and idolatrous purposes in keeping with their ruler Satan.
 
These elohim are ascending up from the land (aretz) and not Sheol. This is because the abode of the demonic is either earthly (within the first and second heaven prior to Messiah’s death and resurrection) or the abyss (a deep holding place/prison for evil forces, which separate from Sheol/Gehinom: Rev. 9:11; 11:7; 17:8; 20:1-3). Only human spirits are kept in Sheol until judgement.
 
However because these elohim will masquerade as a human spirit, they’re pretending to have come from Sheol and therefore present a metaphor that illuminates Shaul’s current circumstances. Sheol (always asking, never sated) will answer Shaul (asks, enquires) with doom. Just as Shaul asks and is not satisfied, so too Sheol asks and is never satisfied.
 
“There are three things that are never satisfied, four that never say, ‘Enough!’: Sheol, the barren womb, land, which is never satisfied with water, and fire, which never says, ‘Enough!’” –Proverbs 30:15-16
 
1Sa 28:14 And he (Shaul) said to her, “What form is it (are they) taking?” And she said, “An old man comes up; and he is covered with a mantle.” And Shaul perceived that it was Sh’muel, and he stooped with his face to the ground, and bowed himself. 
 
Notice that Shaul cannot see the elohim/gods, he is entirely reliant on what the woman tells him that she sees. The woman, who most likely knew that Sh’muel had died an old man, simply describes the entity (gods) in a similar way. Additionally, she knew that Sh’muel was a prophet of G-d and adds that the elohim are wearing a prophet’s mantle. Or on the other hand, the demonic gods are indeed taking the form of Sh’muel. Either way, what the woman sees is not Sh’muel.
 
Shaul, upon hearing the generic description that the woman gives, perceives, or decides (vayda), that this must be Sh’muel (Whom he has longed to receive counsel from) coming up from Sheol. As a result of both the elohim and the woman’s deceit and through his own self-delusion Shaul becomes convinced that it is Sh’muel, G-d’s prophet and lays prostrate with his face to the ground in reverence. Little does he know that he is paying homage to false gods.
 
How can we be so sure that this entity (elohim) is not Sh’muel’s disembodied human spirit risen from Sheol?
 
First, the only examples of people coming up from the dead elsewhere in the Scriptures are accounts of full bodily resurrections (1 Kings 17:17-24; 2 Kings 13:21; Matthew 17:1-8; Mark 9:1-8; Luke 7:12-26; John 11), meaning that the entire being, heart, mind, body and soul are resurrected. There are no instances where the human spirit is resurrected. We are also told that, “It is appointed unto human beings once to die and then the judgement” (Hebrews 9:27). In other words, even in the case of a resurrection miracle like that of Lazarus, he eventually died (once) in a final sense and awaits the judgement. He will not be given opportunity to return in any form until the Day of the L-rd. This understanding supports the holistic Hebrew view of the intrinsically linked soul, made up of emotion, mind, spirit and body, all converging at the core (lev), the heart (centre of the being). The Hebrew nefesh (soul) is indivisible.
 
Some suggest that the Transfiguration, which included Moses, who had previously died, is proof of the fact that disembodied human spirits return from the dead; however, a closer look at the text describing the Transfiguration reveals that all three persons involved were present in bodily form, not merely as spirits but as transfigured bodily beings (Matthew 17:1-8; Mark 9:1-8).
 
There are a number of clear differences between the account of Saul and the witch and the account of the Transfiguration:
  • Elijah and Moses appear, they are not summoned or conjured up (Mark 9:4; Matthew 17:3)
  • The Transfiguration was witnessed by three disciples who saw the physical reality of the event unfold before their eyes, whereas Saul neither saw nor heard anything but was reliant on what the medium conveyed to him (Mark 9:2; Matthew 17:1)
  • Disembodied spirits don’t require shelter (Mark 9:5; Matthew 17:4)
  • The Transfiguration was a glimpse into the future kingdom and is therefore a picture of the post resurrection kingdom of G-d which takes place after Moses is resurrected in the last day, hence the term transfiguration. Messiah had to be temporarily transfigured in that moment because He was stepping outside of time and space in order to participate in a sign G-d was giving to the select group of disciples who were present. This means that rather than invoking the disembodied spirits of the dead who are dead and spoken of in the past tense, the transfiguration was revealing the transformed embodied souls of the living, who are alive in the future kingdom (Mark 9:1)
 
We must conclude that while unique, the Transfiguration supports only full bodily resurrection and does not in any way support the idea of disembodied human spirits.
 
Second, Yeshua confirms through His mashal (parable) of Lazarus and the Rich man (Luke 16:19-31), that while the dead are conscious in Sheol, they’re not able to traverse, either from one part (Abraham’s bosom) to another (Gehinom) or from Sheol to life, once they have died one final death (Hebrews 9:27). This teaching parable of Yeshua is in the unique form of a true story that teaches spiritual truth. It is the only mashal Yeshua tells that uses the proper names of characters. This is an indication of the factual reality of the story. Where Yeshua’s other mashlim (parables) use earthly circumstances to convey unseen spiritual things, the mashal of Lazarus and the Rich man use spiritual circumstances to illuminate physical things.
 
Third, the Scriptures speak of the deceased as being completely removed from what goes on in this world. The dead are said to be unable to return after their one final death. Where the soul is redeemed from death in the psalms, the psalmist is describing a near death experience that he has escaped from at the hand of G-d, or he is prophesying the physical resurrection of the Messiah, he never intends these turns of phrase to indicate the disembodiment of the human spirit.
 
“As the cloud is consumed and vanishes away: so he that goes down to Sheol shall come up no more.” –Job 7:9
 
“Yet shall he be brought to the khever (grave), and shall remain in the tomb.” –Job 21:32
 
“Whatsoever your hand finds to do, do it with all your might; for there is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in the Sheol, where you are going.” –Ecclesiastes 9:10
 
1Sa 28:15 And Sh’muel said to Shaul, “Why have you provoked me, to bring me up?” And Shaul answered, “I am extremely distressed; for the Philistines make war against me, and G-d is departed from me, and no longer answers me, neither by prophets, nor by dreams: therefore I have called you, that you might make known to me what I should do.” 
 
This is not Sh’muel speaking but the elohim (demonic spirits). We know this because in the Chronicler’s concise summation of these events he records that Shaul sought the advice, not of Sh’muel or a medium but of a Familiar spirit (Ov: demonic force):
 
“So Saul died for his transgression which he committed against HaShem, even against the Word (D’var) of HaShem, which he kept not, and also for asking counsel of one that had a familiar spirit, to enquire of it;” –1 Chronicles 10:13
 
The bold parts of this text from 1st Chronicles have been added by the translators, they are not present in the Hebrew text. In fact the Hebrew text reads:
 
“And also for consulting a familiar spirit, to enquire.”
 
The Chronicler, inspired by G-d’s Spirit, makes clear that Shaul was speaking to a Familiar spirit (Ov: demonic) and not to Sh’muel.
 
Therefore, we should read “The gods/demons/familiar spirit whom Shaul had decided was Sh’muel based on the medium’s generic description, said to Shaul.”
 
Remember that Shaul is having the words of the demonic spirit conveyed to him by the medium. This is indicated by the Hebrew “Ov” which means, “to mumble like the hollow gurgling sound of water pouring from a hardened water skin”. This in turn is a Hebrew euphemism used to describe ventriloquism. This entire conversation is being facilitated by the medium as alluded to by Shaul’s having previously asked the medium what she sees (28:13-14).
 
The words of the elohim spoken to Shaul through the medium, indicate its origin. It attempts to convey they idea (Contrary to the teaching of Scripture) that human beings can bring disembodied human spirits up from the grave through the practice of witchcraft. This spirit is a deceiving (lying) spirit sent to torment, like those sent out by G-d to achieve His purposes in several other Biblical accounts.
 
“Then G-d sent an evil spirit between Abimelech and the men of Shechem; and the men of Shechem dealt treacherously with Abimelech:” –Judges 9:23
 
“But the Spirit of HaShem departed from Saul, and an evil spirit from HaShem troubled him. And 
Saul's servants said unto him, Behold now, an evil spirit of gods (elohim) troubles you.” 
–1 Samuel 16:14-15
 
“And there came forth a spirit, and stood before HaShem, and said, I will persuade him.  And HaShem said to it, ‘How will you do it?’ And it said, ‘I will go forth, and I will be a lying spirit in the mouth of all his prophets.’ And G-d said, ‘You have permission to persuade him, and prevail also: go forth, and do so.’ Now therefore, behold, HaShem sent out a lying spirit in the mouth of all these your prophets, and HaShem has spoken evil concerning you.” –1 Kings 22:221-23 (2 Chronicles 18:21-22)
 
“Now the Spirit speaks expressly, that in the latter times some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits, and doctrines of demons;” –1 Timothy 4:1
 
Although G-d has made it abundantly clear to Shaul that He will not speak to him, and although Sh’muel himself had refused to give Shaul guidance in his latter days, and despite the fact that Shaul knew that what he was doing through witchcraft could not possibly result in him receiving G-d’s guidance; Shaul in his desperation convinces himself that this false deity is Sh’muel and that he will receive a truthful answer to his question.
 
1Sa 28:16 Then Sh’muel said, “Why then do you ask me, seeing HaShem is departed from you, and is become your enemy?” 
 
“Then the false gods/demons/familiar spirit whom Shaul had decided were Sh’muel spoke through the medium to Shaul saying.”
 
The demonic force continues to play with Shaul, mimicking what it thinks Sh’muel might say, however there is also some truth in its lie: “Why are you asking a demon for guidance now that G-d has departed from you?”
 
1Sa 28:17 “And HaShem has done to him (David), according to the word in my hand: for HaShem has rent the kingdom out of your hand, and given it to your neighbour, even to David:” 
 
Either the demonic force had observed or the woman knew of the story of the kingdom being torn out of Shaul’s hand. This was an easy deception to make on the part of the medium and the elohim. Or G-d had given the deceiving entities this knowledge.
 
1Sa 28:18 “Because you did not listen to the voice of HaShem, nor execute His fierce wrath upon Amalek, therefore HaShem has done this thing unto you this day.”
 
Here the medium and demon are used to speak the truth according to HaShem’s purpose. G-d will have His way regardless of whose council Shaul seeks. What the Familiar spirit does not do is offer Shaul the solution of repentance and reconciliation to G-d, this is something the real Sh’muel might have done had he been the one Shaul was talking with. After all it is the role of the true prophet to offer Israel an opportunity to repent, it is the false prophet that gives Israel no means of reconciliation.
 
When a true prophet looks at the people of G-d he sees family. When a false prophet looks at the people of G-d he sees an audience.
 
1Sa 28:19 “Moreover HaShem will also deliver Israel with you into the hand of the Philistines: and tomorrow (literally the next day or some time hereafter) both you and your sons will be with me: HaShem also shall deliver the host of Israel into the hand of the Philistines.”
 
This is not an indication of the demonic force or the woman having foreknowledge. In fact these words could not be more generic. The Hebrew makhar can either mean, the very next day or at some point in the future. Shaul and his sons died several days after this meeting, therefore tomorrow is inaccurate (not a prophecy of G-d), leaving the vague, “at some point in the future” being the winner of this ludicrously vague prediction. Additionally the allusion to the death of Shaul’s sons is equally vague given the number of Son’s Shaul had and that not all of Shaul’s sons died in the proceeding battle. The façade is kept up by the demonic spirit and the medium, with the words “you’ll be with me”.
 
1Sa 28:20 Then Shaul immediately fell face down on the earth, and was terrified, because of the words of Sh’muel: and there was no strength in him; for he had eaten no bread all that day and night. 
 
Again, not Sh’muel but the false gods/elohim whom Shaul perceived to be Sh’muel.
 
1Sa 28:21  And the woman came to Shaul, and saw that he was greatly troubled, and said to him, Behold, your handmaid has obeyed your voice, and I have taken my life in my hands, and have hearkened unto your words which you spoke to me. 
 
The fact that the woman/medium came to Shaul indicates that she was performing her service at a distance from him or in the tradition of other ancient soothsayers, from behind a dimly lit curtain.

Conclusion:

There are no disembodied human spirits roaming the earth, they are simply demonic Familiar spirits or gods masquerading as human spirits. To seek guidance from the dead is to reject guidance from the Living One. When we engage in magic arts we are deluding and imprisoning ourselves and worse still we are allowing evil spiritual entities to take up residence in our lives.

When, like Shaul, we are unable to hear G-d our response should be one of repentance and trust. We do well to remember that all things are in G-ds hands and that we are His precious children in Messiah.
​

If it seems that G-d is silent in our suffering, it is because He sees a better outcome for us in His stillness than we’re able to see in our turmoil.
 
© Alastair Brown 2015
    Picture

     כתביו של יעקב
    Yaakov Brown

    Spiritual leader of Beth Melekh Community, Auckland, N.Z.

    Yaakov Brown BOOKS
    Picture

    Archives

    February 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013

    Categories

    All
    2019
    5778
    666
    Aaron
    Abba
    Abimelech
    Able
    Abraham
    Abram
    A Child Is Born
    Acts
    Adam
    Adam And Eve
    Adonai Roi
    Adonai Tzevaot
    Adultery
    Adversity
    Affliction
    Ahaz
    Ahsur
    Al Chet
    Aleph
    Aliens
    Aliyah
    Aliyot
    Allah
    All Tribes
    Almah
    Altar
    Amalek
    Ancient Hebrew
    Andrew
    Angel Of The Lord
    Angels
    Annas
    Annul
    Anointed
    Anointing Oil
    Anti-Christmas
    Antonia
    Anxiety
    Approval
    Arabic
    Aramaic
    Ariel
    Ark
    Ashamnu
    Ashteret
    Ashterot
    Ashur
    Ask
    Ask The Rebbe
    Asneth
    Assyria
    Atonement
    Aviyad
    Avram
    Azariah
    Babel
    Babylon
    Baker
    Baladan
    Baptism
    Bavel
    Bedikat Chametz
    Beersheba
    Beersheva
    Beggar
    Begin Again
    Beginning
    Behjamin
    Beit Chasda
    Beit Tzaida
    Bel
    Belly
    Beloved
    Benjamin
    Bereishit
    Besorah
    Bethany
    Bethesda
    Bethlehem
    Beth Melekh
    Bethsaida
    Betrayal
    Betrothal
    Betulah
    Bilhah
    Birth
    Birthdays
    Birthright
    Blasphemy
    Blessing
    Blessing For The Season
    Blind
    Blood
    Boat
    Body
    Bondage
    Book Of Life
    Books
    Books Of Moses
    Booths
    Branch
    Branches
    Bread
    Bread From Heaven
    Bread Of Life
    Brit HaChadashah
    Brother
    Brothers
    Burden
    Caiaphas
    Cain
    Camping
    Cana
    Capernaum
    Capital Crime
    Capstone
    Carry
    Caught In Adultery
    Celebration
    Challah
    Challot
    Channukah
    Chanukah
    Chanukiyah
    Chanukkah
    Chasidiym
    Chatan Bereishit
    Chatan Torah
    Chavah
    Chesed
    Chief Priests
    Children
    Children Of Light
    Chosen
    Chosen One
    Christian
    Christmas
    Chuppah
    Circumcision
    City
    Civil New Year
    Clay
    Clean
    Cloud Of Witnesses
    Clouds
    Coal Fire
    Coals
    Cohen Hagadol
    Comfort
    Comforter
    Command
    Commandments
    Compass
    Confusion
    Construct
    Contemplative Worship
    Context
    Contextual Fallacy
    Cornerstone
    Corner Stone
    Cosplay
    Courage
    Court Of Women
    Covenant
    Covenants
    Creation
    Creator
    Crescent
    Cross
    Crown Of Thorns
    Crucifixion
    Crushed
    Crying
    Cults
    Culture
    Cup
    Cupbearer
    Curse
    Cyrus
    Darkness
    Daughters Of Men
    Daughters Of Zion
    Davar
    David
    Day
    Day Of Atonement
    Day Of Coverings
    Day Of Soundings
    Death
    Dedication
    Deliver
    Demons
    Depression
    Desert
    Desolate
    Deuteronomy
    Devar
    Difficult
    Dinah
    Dionysus
    Dipped
    Disciple
    Disciples
    Discipline
    Disembodied Spirits
    Disputes
    Distinction
    Diversity
    Doctrine
    Dominion
    Dragon
    Dreams
    Drink
    Drunk
    Eat
    Echad
    Edom
    Egypt
    Eighth Day
    Elazar
    El Gibor
    Elieizer
    Eliphaz
    Elohim
    Elohiym
    Emmanuel
    Emotion
    Empirical
    Emunah
    Endor
    End Times
    Enemies
    Envoys
    Ephraim
    Error
    Esau
    Escaping Goat
    Eschatology
    Esther
    Eternal Life
    Eternal Priesthood
    Eternal Punishment
    Eternal Security
    Ethnic
    Etrog
    Eunuchs
    Eve
    Even
    Even Ha Shetiyah
    Everlasting
    Everlasting Father
    Evidence
    Evil
    Exodus
    Eye
    Eyes
    Faith
    Faithfulness
    False Gods
    Family
    Famine
    Farmer
    Fasting
    Father
    Fear
    Fear Not
    Fear Of Death
    Feast Of Trumpets
    Feet
    Fence
    Festival
    Festival Of Shelters
    Festival Of Tabernacles
    Festivals
    Filthy Rags
    Fire
    First Century
    First Century CE
    Fish
    Fishes
    Flagrum
    Flesh
    Foreigners
    Forsaken
    Foundation Stone
    Free
    Freeborn
    Freedom
    Free From Fear
    Freewill
    Fullness
    Gabbatha
    Galilee
    Galilee Of The Nations
    Gates
    Gathered
    Gat Sheminim
    G-d With Us
    Genealogy
    Generations
    Genesis
    Gentile
    Gethsemane
    Ghosts
    Gift
    Giving
    Glory
    Goal
    Goal Of Torah
    God
    Godhead
    Gods
    God With Us
    Golgotha
    Gomer
    Good
    Good News
    Goshem
    Goshen
    Gospel
    Gospel According To John
    Gospel Of John
    Government
    Goy
    Goyim
    Grain
    Grapes
    Grave
    Greek
    Groom
    Ha Akedah
    Ha Akeidah
    Haaretz
    Ha Aretz
    Ha Beit
    Ha Besorah Al Piy Yochanan
    HaBrit HaChadashah
    Ha Davar
    Ha Devar Emet
    Ha Din
    Ha-D'var Emet
    Haf Tarah
    Hagar
    Hail
    Ha Kotel
    Halakhah
    Haman
    Hannukah
    Haran
    Har Beit
    Harvest
    HaShem
    Hassidim
    Healing
    Heaven
    Heavens
    Hebrew
    Hebrews
    Hebron
    Hermon
    Herod Antipas
    Hezekiah
    Hidden Meaning
    Hidden Messiah
    High Holy Days
    High Priest
    High Shabbat
    Historical
    History
    Holy
    Holy Of Holies
    Holy One Of Israel
    Holy Spirit
    Homosexuality
    Horus
    Hosea
    Hosheia
    House
    House Of Prayer
    Humanity
    Humility
    Husband
    Hyper-grace
    I AM
    Identity
    Idolatry
    Idols
    Images
    Imannuel
    Imanuel
    Imanu El
    Immanuel
    Immature
    Immersion
    Inerpretation
    Instruction
    Isaac
    Isaiah
    Isaiah 10
    Isaiah 12
    Isaiah 14
    Isaiah 30
    Isaiah 38
    Isaiah 47
    Isaiah 8
    Isaiah 9
    Ishmael
    Islands
    Israe
    Israel
    Israelite
    Israelites
    Jabok
    Jacob
    Jacob's Ladder
    Jacob's Well
    Jeremiah
    Jerusalem
    Jesse
    Jesus
    Jew
    Jewish
    Jewish Wedding
    Jews
    Jezreel
    John
    John 1
    John's Gospel
    Jonah
    Jordan
    Joseph
    Joseph Of Arimathea
    Josephus
    Jotham
    Judah
    Judaism
    Judas
    Judea
    Judean
    Judeans
    Judge
    Judgement
    Judges
    Justice
    Kadesh
    Kadosh
    Kashrut
    Keeping The Sabbath
    Kefa
    Kerosh
    Ketonet
    Keturah
    K'fa
    K'far Nachum
    Kfar Nachum
    Kinetic Worship
    King
    King David
    Kingdom
    King Messiah
    King Of Glory
    King Of The Jews
    Kinneret
    Kinsman Redeemer
    Kiriat Arba
    Kislev
    Know
    Kohen HaGadol
    Kol Nidrey
    Koresh
    Kosher
    Kosmos
    Laban
    Lake
    Lamb
    Lame
    Land Of Israel
    Last Days
    Law
    Lazarus
    Leah
    Levi
    Leviathan
    Levites
    Levitical
    Levitical Priesthood
    Leviticus
    Life
    Life In The Blood
    Lifted Up
    Light
    Light Of The World
    Light To The Nations
    Lion
    Lion Of God
    Lion Of Judah
    Lions' Gate
    Live
    Living
    Living Water
    Living Waters
    Loaves
    Locusts
    Logos
    Lord
    Lost Tribes Myth
    Lot
    Love
    Love One Another
    Love Your Neighbour
    Lulav
    Maccabees
    Machpelah
    Magen David
    Malchus
    Man
    Manasseh
    Mangal
    Manna
    Mansions
    Marduk
    Mark Of The Beast
    Marriage
    Marta
    Martha
    Mary
    Mashal
    Mashalim
    Mashiach
    Mashiyach
    Mashiyach Neshlach
    Mashlim
    Matriarchs
    Matzah
    Matzot
    Mayim Chayim
    Meaning In Names
    Medium
    Meggilat
    Megiddo
    Megillah Ruth
    Melki Tzedek
    Memra
    Menachiym
    Mene
    Menorah
    Menstrual Cloth
    Meradoch
    Mercy
    Merodach-Baladan
    Messenger
    Messengers
    Messiah
    Messianic
    Messianic Age
    Messianic Gentiles
    Messianic Judaism
    Messianic Judaism 101
    Mighty God
    Mikdash
    Mikvah
    Mikveh
    Millennium
    Miltha
    Miracle
    Miracles
    Miriam
    Miriyam
    Mishnah
    Missing The Mark
    Mithra
    Mitzvah
    Mitzvot
    Moadim
    Molech
    Moloch
    Moral Law
    Mordechai
    Moriah
    Mosaic Penmanship
    Moses
    Moshe
    Mountain House
    Mountain Of HaShem
    Mount Zion
    Mourning
    Mt Gerizim
    Mt Moriah
    Mt Seir
    Mt Sinai
    Mud
    Murder
    Na'arah
    Nablus
    Nahor
    Nakdimon
    Nakdiymon Ben Gorion
    Names
    Naphtali
    Naqdimon
    Nation
    Nations
    Nativity
    Nebo
    Nefesh
    Negev
    Nephilim
    New Beginning
    New Commandment
    New Earth
    New Heavens
    New Jerusalem
    New Land
    New Testament
    New Year
    Nicodemus
    Night
    Nikodemos
    Nisan
    Noah
    No Fear
    Northern Kingdom
    Not Of This World
    Oaths
    Oath Taking
    Officer Of The King
    Oil
    Olam Haba
    Olam Hazeh
    Olive Press
    Olives
    One
    Pagan
    Paid Servant
    Paleo Hebrew
    Parables
    Pardes
    Parousia
    Passover
    Patriarchs
    Paul
    Paul The Apostle
    Pele Yoeitz
    Pentecost
    People
    Peoples
    Perez
    Perushim
    Pesach
    Peter
    Pharaoh
    Pharisees
    Philip
    Philistia
    Pictographic Hebrew
    Pilate
    Plagues
    Pool
    Pool Of Siloam
    Potiphar
    Potiphera
    Potter
    Powerpoint
    Practice
    Praetorium
    Prayer
    Prayer Shawl
    Pre-Trial
    Priest
    Priesthood
    Priestly Under Garment
    Prince Of Peace
    Princes
    Promised Land
    Promised Messiah
    Promises
    Prophecy
    Prophet
    Prophets
    Prosper
    Protection
    Proverbs
    Provide
    Prune
    P'rushiym
    Psalm
    Psalmist
    Purim
    Purple
    Questions
    Rabbi
    Rabbinical
    Rabbis
    Rabboniy
    Rachel
    Rainbow
    Ram
    Ram's Horn
    Rape
    Rapture
    Rashi
    Rav Shakeih
    Rav Shaul
    Reason
    Rebecca
    Rebeeca
    Redeemed
    Redeemer
    Redemption
    Red Sea
    Refute
    Regalim
    Rejoicing
    Rejoicing In The Torah
    Religious
    Religious Leaders
    Remnant
    Rend
    Repairing The World
    Ressurection
    Rest
    Resurrection
    Return
    Returning
    Reuben
    Revelation
    Righteousness
    Rites
    Ritual Purity
    Ritual Washing
    Rivkah
    Robe
    Rod
    Roman
    Romans
    Romans 14
    Rome
    Room
    Rooster
    Root
    Rosh Hashanah
    Ruach
    Ruach HaKodesh
    Ruach Ha-Kodesh
    Rule
    Ruth
    Sabbath
    Sacrifice
    Sadducees
    Sages
    Salem
    Salim
    Salvation
    Samaritan
    Samaritan Woman
    Sanctify
    Sanhedrin
    Sarah
    Sarai
    Sar Shalom
    Satan
    Saturday
    Saturnalia
    Saul & The Witch
    Saved
    Savior
    Saviour
    Scapegoat
    Scourge
    Scribes
    Scripture
    Scroll
    Seamless
    Second
    Second Coming
    Sect
    See
    Selichah
    Selichot
    Sennachereb
    Sennacherib
    Sent
    Sepulchre
    Seraphim
    Serpent
    Serpents
    Servant
    Servants
    Service
    Servitude
    Session
    Set You Free
    Sexual Sin
    Shabbat
    Shabbat Bread
    Shabbats
    Shaliach
    Shamash
    Shavuot
    Shechem
    Sheep
    Sheep Gate
    Sheep & Goats
    Shelters
    Shem
    Shemini Atzeret
    Shemot
    Shepherd
    Shiloach
    Shiloh
    Shimon
    Shimon Kefa
    Shivah
    Shmini Atzeret
    Shofar
    Shofrot
    Shomeir Shabbat
    Shomron
    Shomroniym
    Shomroniyt
    Shoot
    Shuvah
    Sickness
    Sight
    Sign
    Signs
    Silent
    Siloam
    Simchat Torah
    Simeon
    Simon Peter
    Sin
    Sinai
    Sisters
    Sitting Shivah
    Sixth Day
    Slave
    Slavery
    Slave To Sin
    Smoke And Fire
    Snake
    Sodom
    Sol Invictus
    Solomons Colonnade
    Solomons Porch
    Son
    Song Of The Lamb
    Sons Of God
    Sorceress
    Soul
    Speckled
    Spirit
    Spotted
    Star Of David
    Steps
    Stock
    Stomach
    Stone
    Story In Genealogy
    Streaked
    Streaming
    Strength
    Stump
    Substitution
    Success
    Sukkah
    Sukkot
    Sunday
    Superstition
    Swear
    Sychar
    Synagogue
    Tables
    Taken Away
    Tallit
    Talmidim
    Talmud
    Tamar
    Tammuz
    Tanakh
    Targum
    Tav
    Tear
    Teffilot
    Tefillah
    Tefillin
    Tehilim
    Temple
    Temple Mount
    Temple Rites
    Teshuva
    Testimony
    Tevilah
    That Day
    The Beast
    The Binding Of Isaac
    The Branch
    The Bride
    The Day
    The Exodus
    The Fall
    The Festival
    The Good Samaritan
    The Hebrew Text
    The Holy Name
    The Lamb
    The Land
    The Land Of Israel
    Theology
    The Pavement
    The Seventh Shofar
    The Third Temple
    The Two Olive Trees
    The Word
    Thirst
    Thomas
    Throne
    Tikun Olam
    Tishrei
    Tishri
    Tithing
    Toledot
    T'oma
    Tomb
    Torah
    Tower Of Babel
    Town Of David
    Tradition
    Transgression
    Translation
    Treasury
    Trial
    Tribe
    Tribes
    Trust
    Truth
    Turning
    Twins
    Tzemakh David
    Tzemakh Hashem
    Tzitzit
    Tziyon
    Uncreated
    Under Garment
    Unity
    Unleavened Bread
    Unquenchable Fire
    Uriah
    Uzziah
    Vayikra
    Vengeance
    Vicarious
    Village
    Vine
    Vinedresser
    Vineyard
    Violation
    Virgin Birth
    Voice
    Voice Of Annulment
    Voices
    Vow
    Vows
    Wait
    Waiting
    Walls
    Warning
    Washing
    Washing Feet
    Watchers
    Watchmen
    Water
    Water Of Life
    Water Ritual
    Waters
    Wave Offering
    Way
    Weak
    Weapon
    Wedding
    Well
    Wells
    Western Wall
    Whip
    Wine
    Wine Press
    Witchcraft
    Witness
    Woman
    Woman At The Well
    Wonderful Counsellor
    Word
    Work
    World
    World To Come
    Wrath
    Wrestles
    Write
    Xmas
    Yaakov
    Yaakov Ben Yehoshua
    Yaakov Brown
    Yahashua
    Yahshua
    Yam
    Yarden
    Yehoshua
    Yehudah
    Yehudi
    Yehudiym
    Yeshayah
    Yeshayahu
    Yeshivah
    Yeshua
    Yeshua In The Feasts
    Yeshua's Birth
    YHVH
    Yishaiyahu
    Yishay
    Yishayahu
    Yisrael
    Yizreel
    Yochanan
    Yom Ha Teruah
    Yom Ha-Zikharon
    Yom Kippur
    Yom Shishi
    Yom Teruah
    Yom T'ruah
    Yoseph
    Yoseph Ben Gorion
    Zebulun
    Ziggurat
    Zion

    RSS Feed

May the present peace of Messiah Yeshua reconcile you to the eternal rest of HaShem!


Meeting times

Friday evening: 6:30pm - 10pm

Telephone

64 212709933

Email

bethmelekh@gmail.com