Concerning faith and right action: what God has made one, let no man separate. Yaakov 2:1-26 (Author’s convergent translation from Greek, Aramaic and Hebrew)
1 My brothers and sisters, fellow Jews [see 1:1], do not in partiality, favouritism, respect of persons hold the faith, belief, persuasion, trust in the Lord Yeshua Messiah the glory. 2 For if a person enters your synagogue wearing a gold ring, dressed in white, clean clothes, and a poor person, a beggar in shabby, dirty clothes also comes in, 3 and you gaze at the face of the one who is wearing the white, clean clothes, and say, “You sit here it’s a good spot,” and you say to the poor person, beggar, “You stand over there, or sit down by my footstool,” 4 Are you not then making separations, showing partiality among yourselves, and making yourselves judges with thoughts of evil, intentional harm? 5 Listen, hear, comprehend, understand my completely loved brothers and sisters, fellow Jews: did the God not select the poor, beggar of this world to be rich in faith, trust, persuasion, belief and heirs of the kingdom which He announced, promised to those who love Him completely, fully? 6 But you have despised, dishonoured the poor person. Is it not the rich who oppress, exercise harsh control over you and drag you before judgement seats? 7 Do they not blaspheme, speak evil of the good Name by which you have been called? 8 If, however, you are being filled with, the Kingly Torat/specific law/instruction according to the Writings/Scripture, “You shall love your neighbour as yourself, [Lev. 19:18]” you are doing good. 9 But if you show partiality, favouritism, you are committing sin, missing the mark set by God’s holiness and are rebuked, convicted by the Torah/Law as Torah/law breakers. 10 For whoever keeps, guards the entire Torah[H]/Law, yet stumbles, falls, offends in one, has become guilty, subject of all, individually and collectively. 11 For He who said, “Do not commit adultery,” also said, “Do not murder.” Now if you do not commit adultery, but do murder, you have made yourself a breaker of the Torah[H]/Law. 12 So speak, and so do, as those who are to be judged by the Torah[H]/law of freedom, liberty. 13 For judgment devoid of mercy will be shown to one who has shown no mercy; the mercy rejoices against, is glorious over, triumphs over, perpetually boasts against the judgment. 14 What does it profit, my brothers and sisters, fellow Jews if someone says he has faith, trust, belief, persuasion, but he has no works, actions? Can faith, trust, belief, persuasion save him? 15 If a brother or sister is naked and lacks daily food, bread 16 and any one of you says to them, “Go in peace, wholeness, wellbeing, be warmed and be filled,” yet you don’t give them the things they need for their body, what use is that? 17 In the same way, faith, trust, belief, persuasion also, if it has no works, actions, deeds is dead, necrotic being alone, separate, apart. 18 But someone might say, “You have faith and I have works, actions; show me your faith without the works, actions, and I will show you my faith by my works, actions.” 19 You believe that the God is one, well done; the demons also believe, and shudder, tremble, stiffen, are horrified. 20 Now are you willing to know, act on the knowledge, you vain, empty person, that faith, trust, belief, persuasion without works, actions is barren, dead, necrotic? 21 Was our father Avraham not justified by works, actions when he bore, led, offered up his son Yitzchak (Isaac) on the altar? 22 You see that faith, trust, belief, persuasion together with his works, actions, and as a result of the works, actions, faith, trust, belief, persuasion was made perfect, fully filled, made whole, well-constructed. 23 and the Scripture, TaNaKh, Hebrew Bible was fulfilled which says, “And Avraham believed, agreed with God, and it was counted to him as righteousness, charity, practical love, [Gen. 15:6]” and he was called a friend of God. 24 You see, perceive therefore, now truly that a person is justified by works, actions and not by faith alone. 25 In the same way, was Rachav the prostitute not justified by works, actions also when she allowed entry to the messengers, angels and sent them out by another way? 26 For just as the body without the spirit is dead, so also faith without works, actions is dead. Yaakov 2:1-26 (Line upon line) 1 My brothers and sisters, fellow Jews[see 1:1] (adelphos mou[G], achay[H]), do not (me[G]) in partiality, favouritism, respect of persons (prosōpolēpsias[G]) hold (echo[G]) the faith, belief, persuasion, trust (ho pistis[G], be’emunat[H]) in the Lord (ho kurios[G], Adoneinu[H]) Yeshua[H] (Iesous[G], Joshua, Jesus: YHVH Saves) Messiah (Christos[G], HaMashiyach[H], Anointed One) the glory (ho doxa[G]). 1 My brothers and sisters, fellow Jews [see 1:1], do not in partiality, favouritism, respect of persons hold the faith, belief, persuasion, trust in the Lord Yeshua[H] Messiah the glory. Put simply, “As Jews and followers of Yeshua, Who is God with us (Imanu El), the glory of God in us, don’t practice favouritism. In particular, show no favouritism when new people, Jews and Gentiles alike, come into your Messianic Jewish Synagogue.” (v.2-3) Yaakov continues to address the Messianic Jewish community of the first century Diaspora. He begins this portion with a reminder that halakhah (the way we walk) in Messiah is lit with Yeshua’s Glory. Therefore we are to walk as people who are aware of our own identity. We are Talmidim (students) of our Glorious Messiah, having been shown favour we are to reject the practice of favouritism. The key to right action, that is, present halakhah, is the very nature of Messiah Himself. The Jewish writer of the Book to the Hebrews gives us a beautiful glimpse into the vast glory of the Mashiyach (Messiah) when he writes: “Ha-Ben (the Son) is the radiance of HaShem’s (YHVH’s) glory and the exact representation of His being, sustaining all things by His powerful Davar (Word, Essence, Substance).” – Book to the Hebrews 1:3 (Author’s Translation) We further notice that the previous (1:17-18, 23-25) metaphor promoting reflected glory is alluded to by way of inference in the latter part of the first verse of the present chapter “Messiah the glory”. Yaakov is writing to Messiah following Jews living in Jewish communities throughout the known world. At this time (approx. 40 – 50 C.E.) they continued to worship in synagogues which were attended by a believing Jewish majority and by Gentile God fearers who prior to the coming of Yeshua and the Messianic Jewish faith were allowed to attend synagogue meetings only as standing guests at the open entry way to the synagogue. They could listen to and observe proceedings, but could not enter and sit among Jewish worshippers. Also at this time Jewish believers were still struggling with the idea that Gentiles could be included in the redemptive work of God (Acts 10:28). Therefore, riches and poverty were just one aspect of the problem of partiality (favouritism). In part there was a righteous motivation for excluding Gentiles, who were perceived to be pagans practicing lifestyles contrary to the Torah and therefore were a danger to the spiritual health of the Jewish community. However, Biblical Judaism has always taught Israel not to act with partiality. “17 You are not to recognize faces with partiality in judgment; you shall hear the small and the great alike. You are not to be afraid of any person, for the judgment is God’s…” -D’varim/Deuteronomy 1:17 2 For if a person (anēr[G], iysh[H]) enters your synagogue (synagoge[G], l’veiyt hakeneset[H]) wearing a gold ring (chrusodaktulios[G], zahav al yado[H]), dressed in white, clean (lampros[G]) clothes, and a poor person, a beggar (ptōchos[G]) in shabby, dirty (rhuparos[G]) clothes also comes in, 3 and you gaze at the face of (epiblepō[G], poniym[H]) the one who is wearing the white, clean (lampros[G]) clothes, and say, “You sit here it’s a good (kalōs[G], tava’at[H]) spot,” and you say to the poor person, beggar (ptōchos[G]), “You stand (histēmi[G]) over there, or sit down (kathēmai[G]) by my footstool (hupopodion[G], rag’lay[H]),” 2 For if a person enters your synagogue wearing a gold ring, dressed in white, clean clothes, and a poor person, a beggar in shabby, dirty clothes also comes in, 3 and you gaze at the face of the one who is wearing the white, clean clothes, and say, “You sit here it’s a good spot,” and you say to the poor person, beggar, “You stand over there, or sit down by my footstool,” The Greek synagoge appears 57 times in the HaBriyt HaChadashah “New Testament” and is only once used to describe a non-Jewish assembly (Rev. 2:9). It is therefore unacceptable that the majority of English translations of the present text render synagoge[G] as “assembly, gathering, meeting” etc. This clouds the meaning and is at its core an antisemitic translational choice. Translators have attempted to make this very Jewish book of Yaakov sound more universal by hiding Jewish specific terms beneath generic terminology. It is important to understand that this letter was being written to functioning Messianic synagogues throughout the Diaspora sometime between 40 and 50 C.E. That means that the Messiah following Jewish communities in question were predominantly Messianic Jews joined by a small number of Gentiles (unconverted observers of 1st Century Judaism), and that the Jewish majority continued to worship as Jews in a traditional Jewish way within the revelation of Messiah Yeshua. We note that in this scenario the beggar in shabby clothing is being assigned either a standing position at or outside the door to the synagogue, or a seat on the floor. The former was once reserved for the “God fearing” Gentile (unconverted observer of 1st Century Judaism) and the latter for the lower class of Jew. However, In Messiah not only were the lower class Jews elevated, the Gentiles were now welcome to enter and be seated within the believing Jewish community. Ancient Jewish law concerning the equal treatment of rich and poor alike in judiciary matters is sighted by Maimonides: "Two adversaries (in a dispute with each other), if one of them is clothed with precious garments, goodly apparel, and the other is clothed with, vile clothing, (the judge) says to the honorable (wealthy) person, ‘either clothe him (the poor person) as you are clothed, while you contend with him, or be clothed as he is, so that you may be alike, on an equal footing.’'' -Maimonides on Hilchot Sanhedrin, c. 21. sect. 2. Further, with regard to social position as it applied to matters of law Maimonides sites the Talmud Bavliy: "One shall not sit, and another stand, but both shall stand; but if the Sanhedrin, or court, are pleased to let them sit, they sit; but one does not sit above, and the other below; but one by the side of the other.'' - Maimonides ib. sect. 3. vid. Talmud Bavliy Shebuot, fol. 30. 1. 4 Are you not then making separations, showing partiality (diakrinō[G]) among yourselves, and making (ginomai[G]) yourselves judges (kritēs[G], shoftiym[H]) with thoughts (dialogismos[G]) of evil, intentional harm (ponēros[G], resha[H])? 5 Listen, hear, comprehend, understand (shimu[H]) my completely loved brothers and sisters, fellow Jews (adelphos agapētos[G], achay ahuvay[H]): did the God (ho Theos[G], Elohiym[H]) not select (eklegomai[G]) the poor, beggar (ptōchos[G]) of this world (kosmos toutou[G], haolam[H]) to be rich (plousios[G]) in faith, trust, persuasion, belief (pistis[G], Emunah[H]) and heirs (klēronomos[G]) of the kingdom (ho basileia[G], hamalchut[H]) which He announced, promised (epaggellō[G], hivtiyach[H]) to those who love Him completely, fully (ha agapaō autos[G], leohavayv[H])? 4 Are you not then making separations, showing partiality among yourselves, and making yourselves judges with thoughts of evil, intentional harm? 5 Listen, hear, comprehend, understand my completely loved brothers and sisters, fellow Jews: did the God not select the poor, beggar of this world to be rich in faith, trust, persuasion, belief and heirs of the kingdom which He announced, promised to those who love Him completely, fully? We note that it is not distinctions but separations among the Jewish believing community that are being addressed. The primary issue is wrong motivations (yetzer hara) and the passing of judgement based on outward appearances. Yeshua had commanded His disciples to stop judging by mere appearances and make right judgements (John 7:24). Yaakov is not instructing the Jewish believers not to judge but instead not to make false judgements. When we judge by appearances we are submitting our judgement to the sin affected reality of this temporary world, whereas when we judge according to God’s Spirit we are distinguishing between the temporal and the eternal and choosing the eternal (2 Cor. 4:18). Yaakov is reminding his fellow Messiah following dispersed countrymen that their understanding of what obedience to the Torah (Instruction) requires had always included just treatment of all people within the Jewish community. This is not a foreign practice to his readers, it had simply become a neglected one within the Jewish communities of the Diaspora. Why? Because they had adopted, or syncretised pagan Hellenistic practices. “Do not pervert justice or show partiality—undue favour for one over another. Do not accept a bribe, for a bribe blinds the eyes of the wise and twists the words of the innocent.” -D’varim/Deuteronomy 16:19 The real issue being addressed here is the motive of the human core (heart) that is the point from which all the parts of our being emanate rather than the heart in opposition to the mind. Perhaps money was needed for the running of the synagogue, the purchase of Torah scrolls etc.? Whatever the reason for showing favouritism, the Torah clearly instructs against the practice. “did the God not select the poor, beggar of this world to be rich in faith, trust, persuasion, belief…” We note that the text does not say “God chose the poor to be rich”, but “God chose the poor to be rich in faith.” The false Prosperity Gospel misses the point. What good are temporal riches that dull the faith of a person? God wills prosperity for the believer in Himself, but He does not will our temporal material prosperity except that it be utilised in the furthering of His Kingdom. “What good does it do a person to gain the entire world but loose his soul?” (Mk. 8:36; Matt. 16:26) The materially poor are rich in faith because they are devoid of the distraction of temporal riches. Those who are materially poor are inclined toward trusting God because they have nothing and no one but God to place their trust in. Therefore, material poverty can act as a vehicle for spiritual prosperity. “The meek will inherit the land and enjoy peace and prosperity.” - Tehillim/Psalm 37:11 “Blessing comes from God for the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of Heaven.” – Mattitiyahu/Matthew 5:3 As I have said, Yaakov admonishes his hearers to “Look not to what is seen but to what is unseen, for what is seen is temporary, but what is unseen is everlasting” (2 Cor. 4:18). In particular Yaakov is using phrasing that speaks to the 1st Century Jewish view of the Gentiles. He is employing specific terminology. For example ancient Jewish commentary refers to aniy Yisrael “the poor of Israel” as being distinct from aniy olam “the poor of the world”*. The “world” was seen as synonymous with “goyim” nations, pagans. Therefore, in one sense “the poor of this world” is understood by Yaakov’s hearers as referring to the Gentiles who are both poor in respect to physical wealth and in respect to spiritual health. This makes the teaching somewhat offensive to the early Jewish believers which is why Yaakov has prepared them by saying “Be quick to listen and slow to anger” (1:19-20). *Talmud Bavliy. Gittin, fol. 30. 1. & Bava Batra, fol. 10. 2. “The Kingdom which He promised to those who love Him fully.” The receiving of the Kingdom is simple, it is given to those who love Him fully. Do you love Him (God) fully, in Messiah? Then the Kingdom is given to you. Devoid of Messiah Yeshua we are all poor, lacking, dressed in filth. 6 But you have despised, dishonoured (atimazō[G]) the poor person (ptōchos[G]). Is it not the rich (plousios[G]) who oppress, exercise harsh control over (katadunasteuō[G]) you and drag (helkuō[G]) you before (eis[G]) judgement seats (kritērion[H], levateiy mishpat[H])? 7 Do they not blaspheme, speak evil of (blasphēmeō[G]) the good (kalos[G], hatovah[H]) name (onoma[G], HaShem[H]) by which you have been called (epikaleomai[G], hanikra aleiychem[H])? 6 But you have despised, dishonoured the poor person. Is it not the rich who oppress, exercise harsh control over you and drag you before judgement seats? 7 Do they not blaspheme, speak evil of the good name by which you have been called? Put concisely, don’t do to fellow believers of any ethnicity what is being done to you by non-believers. The foolish false choice posed by various Christian theologians, Hebrew Roots and Messianic writers asking “To Whom does ‘the good name’ refer?” is ludicrous. First because God is One and second because nothing could be further from Hebraic practice than a refusal to accept both interpretations as valid. Ultimatums are contrary to Biblical Hebrew thought. Scripture shines a light on cause and effect and God speaks clearly concerning action and consequence, practice and outcomes, whereas ultimatums are the domain of fallen humanity. The early Jewish believers were being taken to court on false charges by both rich Gentiles who hated them because of their association to YHVH, El Elohay Yisrael (the God of Israel v.5) and by rich rabbinical Jews who hated them due to their association with Yeshua HaMashiyach (Jesus the King Messiah v.1). So, in response to the false choice posed by Christian and Messianic Scholars alike “Which Name is being referred to, YHVH or Jesus?” we respond, “Yes!” “The good Name” is YHVH (v.5), Yeshua (v.1), Elohiym, El Elyon, El Shaddai, El Gibor, Adonay Yireh, Adonay Shalom, Sar shalom, Imanu-El… Adonay Eloheinu Adonay echad (God is One)! 8 If, however, you are being filled with (teleō[G]), the Kingly (basilikos[G], hamalchut[H]) Torat[H]/specific law/instruction (nomos[G]) according to the Writings/Scripture (graphe[G], Ketuvim/kakatuv[H]), “You shall love your neighbour as yourself, [Lev. 19:18]” you are doing good (kalōs[G], heiytavtem[H]). 9 But if you show partiality, favouritism (prosōpolēpteō[G]), you are committing (ergazomai[G]) sin, missing the mark set by God’s holiness (hamartia[G]) and are rebuked, convicted (elegchō[G]) by the Torah[H]/Law (ho nomos[G], haTorah[H]) as Torah/law breakers (parabatēs[G]). 8 If, however, you are being filled with, the Kingly Torat/specific law/instruction according to the Writings/Scripture, “You shall love your neighbour as yourself, [Lev. 19:18]” you are doing good. 9 But if you show partiality, favouritism, you are committing sin, missing the mark set by God’s holiness and are rebuked, convicted by the Torah/Law as Torah/law breakers. “If, however, you are being filled with, the Kingly Torat/specific law/instruction according to the Writings/Scripture” We must first take note of the specificity of Yaakov’s language regarding “law”. In this verse he speaks of a particular “Kingly” or “Royal” nomos[G]/torat[H] that is found in the fullness of the TaNaKh, or Ketuvim (Writings, Hebrew Bible). By quoting the very specific law (torat, a part of the Torah) “You shall love your neighbour as yourself” (Le. 19:18), Yaakov is passing on the teaching of His brother Yeshua the Messiah, Who summed up the Torah of Moses and the Prophets this way: 36 “Teacher, which is the great commandment in the Torah?” 37 And He said to him, “‘You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind.’ 38 This is the head and great commandment. 39 The second is like it, ‘You shall love your neighbour as yourself.’ 40 Upon these two commandments hang the entire Torah and hanevi’im.” -Mattitiyahu (Matthew) 22:36-40 Yaakov calls the summation of Yeshua’s teaching on the Torah and the Prophets the “Kingly Torah”, as distinct from the Torah of Moses. As I have explained previously, while aspects of the Torah of Moses are present as part of the whole of the “Kingly Torah, Torah Perfected, Torah of Freedom”, the clear distinctions made by both Yaakov and Rav Shaul, based on the teaching of Yeshua, mean that we cannot simplistically understand Torah in these verses to refer to the Torah of Moses except when it is clearly qualified as it is in verse 9 where the Greek reads “ho nomos” the Torah. In verses 8-9 Yaakov speaks to those Jews called in Yeshua to act in accordance with the Kingly Torah of Yeshua and to recognize their hypocrisy in the face of both the Kingly Torah and the Torah of Moses. Parts of the Torah of Moses will pass away, but nothing of the Kingly Torah of Yeshua will ever pass away. Yaakov’s audience is Jewish, when they hear “torat” they understand a singular aspect of the Torah, and when they hear the words “ha Torah” at the end of verse 9 they recognize the Torah of Moses. Yaakov then, is linking the Kingly Torah of God’s Messiah with the Torah of Moses while making a clear distinction between the two. Therefore the Kingly Torah as understood through the lens of the pivotal verse, “Love your neighbour as yourself,” thus creating a unity of belief and action born in the freedom of Messiah’s teaching. The point being that Yaakov is not inventing a new kind of Torah, he is revealing the Torah filled with Messiah and driven by the Ruach ha-Kodesh (Holy Spirit). As I have explained, there are parts of the Torah of Moses which will become obsolete at the point of final judgment and our entry into the Olam Haba (world to come), but as Messiah himself has said, “I tell you truly, until heaven and earth pass away not one minor or major mark will disappear from the Torah until all things are accomplished.” – Mattitiyahu/Matthew 5:18 “Zayit Ra’anan says… ‘The Holy One, blessed be He, says, “you sin in this world because the yetzer hara (evil inclination) governs you; but in the Olam haba (world to come), I will take it (yetzer ha-ra) away from you;” as it is said in Ezekiel 36:26 “I will take away the stony heart out of your flesh and give you a heart of flesh.”’” – Midrash Yalkut Shim’oni (medieval) When we abide in the Kingly Torah within Messiah we do well, recognizing the discipline and instruction of God. On the other hand, when we give in to the yetzer ha-ra “fallen inclination”, we cloud our ability to see the Kingly Torah (which brings liberty). When we wilfully break the Torah we deceive ourselves and are in danger of believing the lie that we are no longer secure. The irony here is that in showing favouritism we are endanger of believing that at some point we could lose God’s favour. Therefore, we must show others the favour that God has shown us in Messiah. “You shalt not avenge, nor bear any grudge against the children of your people (Israel), and you shall love your neighbour as yourself: I am YHVH.” -Leviticus 19:18 We note that “You shall love your neighbour as yourself” is the second clause in the commandment being quoted by Yaakov. The commandment begins by saying “You shalt not avenge, nor bear any grudge against the children of your people (Israel)”. Therefore, Yaakov is addressing the problem of early Jewish believers discriminating not only against the poor and bedraggled but also against Gentile believers. “Owe no person anything, but to love one another: for those who love one another have fully filled the Torah.” -Rav shaul: Letter to the Roman Believers 13:8 Those who are focused on the Messiah and as a result love others as themselves are fully filling the Torah of Moses, whereas those focused on attempting to fully observe the Torah of Moses are continually failing to do so. With regard to Torah there is no “try”, there is only “Do” and “Do not”. How much better then to request that God manifest Himself in me through Yeshua, than to seek to reach Him through the delusional claim of Torah observance. 10 For whoever keeps, guards (tēreō[G]) the entire (holos[G]) Torah[H]/Law (nomos[G]), yet stumbles, falls, offends (ptaiō[G]) in one (heis[G]), has become guilty, subject (enochos[G]) of all, individually and collectively (pas[G]). 11 For He who said, “Do not commit adultery,” also said, “Do not murder.” Now if you do not commit adultery, but do murder, you have made yourself (ginomai[G]) a breaker (parabatēs[G]) of the Torah[H]/Law (nomos[G]). 10 For whoever keeps, guards the entire Torah[H]/Law, yet stumbles, falls, offends in one, has become guilty, subject of all, individually and collectively. 11 For He who said, “Do not commit adultery,” also said, “Do not murder.” Now if you do not commit adultery, but do murder, you have made yourself a breaker of the Torah[H]/Law. Given the context this teaching says, “If you’re keeping most of the laws of the Torah but are breaking the Kingly law to love your neighbour as yourself, then the Torah exposes your guilt and you come under the judgement of the entire Torah.” Those who claim that Yaakov teaches Torah Observance are delusional. He is in fact teaching that Torah Observance (with the exception of Yeshua) is impossible. This is consistent with what Yaakov says in Acts 15. The early Jewish Fathers of the Body of believers agreed that Torah Observance was not incumbent on the Gentile believers. Those demanding that Gentile believers be circumcised were silenced by Rav Shaul (Paul), Yaakov, and Kefa (Peter). It is important to note that the two commandments mentioned here by Yaakov are to do with the love of one’s neighbour. It is often the case that as we journey with God we begin to become complacent. On a historical level the physical separation of the Messianic Jews in the Diaspora from the Jews of Israel was a living metaphor for their journey away from right action. When we become complacent in our faith we can fall into the trap of considering some commandments more important than others, thus we justify sinful action based on a sort of sin hierarchy where murder is bad but lusting after my neighbour’s wife is just what men are prone to do. Yaakov reminds his Jewish brothers and sisters that when we say to God, “I’ll keep most of your commandments but I don’t agree with this one, so I’ll just ignore it,” we are already guilty. As I have already stated, in more general terms Yaakov is teaching the one who says, “I am a Torah keeper” that such a statement is lie and thus breaks Torah. With the exception of Yeshua no one can claim to be a Torah keeper. I am obligated to add a further warning concerning a grave mis-teaching within the modern Messianic movement which makes Torah Observance an object of worship: Those who teach the lie "Obeying Torah is the fruit of salvation" mis-qualify both Torah and salvation. "Messiah is the goal of Torah" unto works of righteousness. Torah observance is not the goal, end, or fruit of Messiah. If it were, Messiah would be subject to Torah, but instead He is the Author and Goal of it. It is not Torah observance that is the fruit of the redeemed but right action. Ezekiel 36:26-27 explains that by the Spirit of Life (Holy Spirit) in Messiah Yeshua (Rom.8:2), we are empowered to act according to His (YHVH) prescribed (בְּקִרְבְּכֶם) way of living and according to His judgements (מִשְׁפָּטַי). Torah is not mentioned. Why? Because observance of the Torah of Moses is not the goal, end, or fruit. Thus we are "set free from the Torah of sin and death (the result of a failure to observe the unkeepable Mosaic Torah)" [Rom.8:2]. Peter (Rav Kefa) explains that no one can "bear" the "burden" of Torah observance (Acts 15:10). Yaakov (James) and the early Jewish Fathers of the body of faith along with Peter, agreed that therefore Gentile believers should not be taught Torah observance but to simply refrain from all forms of idolatry in accordance with the universally moral commandments of God (10 commandments minus Shabbat, which is a sign on ethnic Israel, the Jews [Ex.31:16-17]) Peter said this as a Spirit filled Messiah follower, not as an unsaved pre-Messianic Jew. Therefore, Peter and the early Jewish Fathers of the Body of believers agree that Torah observance is not the fruit of salvation. We add to this the teaching of Yeshua, Rav Shaul, and the Kohen (probably Barnabas) who wrote the Book to the Hebrews: Rom. 3:20; 4:14; 4:15; 5:20; 6:14; 7:1-13; 8:2-3, 1 Cor. 15:56, 2 Cor. 3:7; 3:9; 3:10; 3:12; 3:14-17, Gal. 2:16; 2:19; 2:21; 3:1;3:10; 3:11-12; 3:13; 3:16 & 19, (ref. Matt. 11:12-13, Luke 16:16), Gal. 3:21; 3:23; 4:24; Eph. 2:15, Phlp. 3:4-8; 1 Tim. 1:8 (Torah was made for the unrighteous, not for the righteous.) 1 Tim. 1:9-10; Heb. 7:18-19; 8:7-8; 8:13; 10:1. It is wrong to say that “Torah is done away with”, it is equally wrong to say that “Torah observance is the goal, end, fruit” or otherwise. When using "Torah" as a proper noun we speak in general terms that lack the nuisance of the wider definition. This is why the writers of the HaBrit HaChadashah (NT) often use qualifying terms in relationship to Torah (Instruction). "because through Messiah Yeshua the Torah* of the Spirit of life (Torah of Messiah) has set you free from the Torah* of sin and death. (Result of the failure to keep the unkeepable Torah of Moses)" -Romans 8:2 So called "Messianics" need to stop arguing over the keeping of days and the obeying of laws and return to the Person of Messiah Yeshua in God. No one will stand at the judgement and be able to use Torah observance as a means of redemption. If we claim to be Torah observant we make ourselves to be liars. As I have said, with regard to Torah there is no "try", there is “do” and “do not”. No human being (with the exception of the King Messiah) can keep the Torah perfectly. I do not keep the Torah, rather the Torah perfected of the Spirit of life keeps me in Messiah Yeshua. Those in the so called "Messianic" movement who claim to be Torah observant are lying. They are idolaters of the worst kind because in focusing on Torah they have turned their backs on the Author of it. It is for freedom that Messiah has set us free! *The word Torah must be qualified 12 So speak (laleō[G], davru[H]), and so do (poieō[G]), as those who are to be judged (krino[G]) by the Torah[H]/law (nomos[G], Torah[H]) of freedom, liberty (eleutheria[G], shel cheirut[H]). 13 For judgment (krisis[G], badiyn[H]) devoid of mercy (me eleos[G], eiyn rachamiym[H]) will be shown to one who has shown no mercy (me eleos[G], nahag rachamiym[H]); the mercy (eleos[G], harachamiym[H]) rejoices against, is glorious over, triumphs over, perpetually boasts against (katakauchaomai[G]) the judgment (krisis[G], hadiyn[H]). 14 What does it profit (ophelos[G]), my brothers and sisters, fellow Jews (mou adelphos[G], achay[H]) if someone says he has faith, trust, belief, persuasion (pistis[G], emunah[H]), but he has no works, actions (me ergon[G])? Can faith, trust, belief, persuasion (pistis[G], emunah[H]) save (sōzō[G], lehoshiyo[H]) him? 12 So speak, and so do, as those who are to be judged by the Torah[H]/law of freedom, liberty. 13 For judgment devoid of mercy will be shown to one who has shown no mercy; the mercy rejoices against, is glorious over, triumphs over, perpetually boasts against the judgment. 14 What does it profit, my brothers and sisters, fellow Jews if someone says he has faith, trust, belief, persuasion, but he has no works, actions? Can faith, trust, belief, persuasion save him? Yaakov admonishes his Jewish brothers and sisters who follow Messiah Yeshua to speak and act as those being judged, not by the Torah of Moses but by the Torah of Liberty. The wonderful result of accepting God’s mercy is that we will in turn show mercy to others, thus “Mercy triumphs over judgment” (that is mercy triumphs over a judgment of condemnation). Mercy triumphs in the judgment that brings discipline and freedom, thus we have the Torah of Messiah that brings Liberty. There are those who are uncomfortable with the plain Greek text saying “can faith save him?” They add to it translating “can that faith save him”. There is no need to add “that” to the text. One who is convinced that his faith need not be acted on does not accept the saving faith of Yeshua and therefore cannot be saved by faith. More to the point, faith cannot save, rather the Messiah Yeshua in Whom we place true faith, He is the Saviour. Thus Messiah in us outworks faith through us. We act righteously because we have received the nature of Messiah. Here Yaakov is speaking of a divisive faith, a faith that compartmentalizes life. The action of a pumping heart is the proof that a man is alive, when the heart ceases its action the body is dead. The predisposition of the Holy Spirit Who lives in us, is to help those in need, in order to fail to help the destitute we must first resist the Ruach ha-Kodesh, for a believer this is known as grieving (not blaspheming) the Spirit. The conclusion then is this, isolated faith is dead. In a believer however, the failure to act causes conviction of spirit and therefore revives the body. It is as if the heart has lost its rhythm temporarily for lack of vigour and then the Spirit pulls out the shock panels and gives us a jump start. 15 If a brother (adelphos[G], ach[H]) or sister (adelphē[G], achot[H]) is naked (gumnos[G]) and lacks (leipō[G]) daily (ephēmeros[G]) food, bread (lechem[H]) 16 and any one (tis[G]) of you says to them, “Go (hupagō[G]) in peace, wholeness, wellbeing (eirēnē[G], leshalom[H]), be warmed (thermainō[G]) and be filled (chortazō[G]),” yet you don’t give (didōmi[G]) them the things they need (epitēdeios[G]) for their body (sōma[G]), what use is that (ophelos[G], mah hoaltem[H])? 15 If a brother or sister is naked and lacks daily food, bread 16 and any one of you says to them, “Go in peace, wholeness, wellbeing, be warmed and be filled,” yet you don’t give them the things they need for their body, what use is that? “is naked and lacks daily bread” “Give us today our daily bread” is part of the formula of Tefilat haTalmidim “The Disciples Prayer” taught by Yeshua the King Messiah (Matt. 6:9-13). Here Yaakov reminds his hearers that in relationship through Messiah they are to participate in godly acts of provision. What fool, having prayed “Give us today our daily bread”, then sends his believing brother or sister away without bread for the day? “Go in peace, wholeness, wellbeing, be warmed and be filled,” yet you don’t give them the things they need for their body, what use is that? To wish a fellow believer, in this case a fellow Jewish believer “Peace, wholeness, and wellbeing”, knowing that they are distressed, incomplete, unwell, and having the means to give them peace, wholeness and wellbeing, is an abhorrent act of rebellion against the specific Kingly Torah command “You shall love your neighbour as yourself!” 17 In the same way, faith, trust, belief, persuasion (pistis[G], ha’emunah[H]) also, if it has no works, actions, deeds (ergon[G]) is dead, necrotic (nekros[G], meitah[H]) being alone, separate, apart (kata heautou[G], ). 18 But someone might say, “You have faith (pistis[G], emunah[H]) and I have works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]); show me your faith (pistis[G], emunah[H]) without the works, actions (ergon[G]), and I will show you my faith (pistis[G], emunah[H]) by my works, actions (ergon[G]).” 17 In the same way, faith, trust, belief, persuasion also, if it has no works, actions, deeds is dead, necrotic being alone, separate, apart. 18 But someone might say, “You have faith and I have works, actions; show me your faith without the works, actions and I will show you my faith by my works, actions.” Yaakov is not saying “I will show you my faith by my Torah observance”, a curse on that idea! The works, actions in question are right actions, otherwise known as righteousness. Yaakov is saying “The evidence of my faith is in the right actions that proceed from it”. It is not Torah observance that produces Yaakov’s right actions but faith in Messiah that produces them. This is a foundational doctrine of the Messianic Faith that has been abused by far too many so called “Messianic” teachers who promote the false doctrine of “Torah Observance” in contradiction of the teaching of Yaakov, Yochanan and Rav Shaul. The Hebraic back and forth of Yaakov’s work is a reflection of Yeshua’s teaching style, and is in turn reflected in Rav Shaul’s works. It was and remains a strong rabbinical technique that acts to expose flawed or self-defeating thinking (circular logic). Like a heart that doesn’t pump blood, faith without action is dead. The words, “faith by itself without right action is dead,” are a precursor to the final words of this portion of Yaakov. It is important to note that faith in unity with right action is life. The blood, the heart and the oxygen are all required in order to unify the living body. It’s as if Yaakov were saying “Show me life in a heart that doesn’t beat and I will show you life in my beating heart!” “Really?” Says Yaakov, with incredulity. “You’re able to exhibit faith without acting righteously? Okay, but I will exhibit faith by acting in unity with the Holy Spirit.” Faith, being unseen cannot be seen except in action. Therefore, the one who fails to act proves himself faithless. Faith devoid of right action is not only a corpse, it is a necrotic, stinking corpse. Ironically, faith without the evidence of right action produces a spiritual stench in the nostrils of the faithful. 19 You believe (pisteuō[G]) that the God (ho Theos[G], haElohiym[H]) is one (heis[G], echad[H]) well done (poieō kalōs[G]); the demons (ho daimonion[G], hasheidiym[H]) also believe (pisteuō[G]), and shudder, tremble, stiffen, are horrified (phrissō[G]). 20 Now (de[G]) are you willing to know, act on the knowledge (ginōskō[G]), you vain, empty (kenos[G]) person (anthrōpos[G], iysh[H]), that faith, trust, belief, persuasion (pistis[G], emunah[H]) without works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]) is barren, dead, necrotic (nekros[G], akarah[H])? 19 You believe that the God is one well done; the demons also believe, and shudder, tremble, stiffen, are horrified. 20 Now are you willing to know, act on the knowledge, you vain, empty person, that faith, trust, belief, persuasion without works, actions is barren, dead, necrotic? Many, lacking knowledge of ancient Biblical Jewish practice, and indeed of Jewish practice in general, fail to understand just how harsh these words of Yaakov are, even beyond their apparent abruptness. Yaakov is pulling out the big guns. One can see why prior to this he had instructed his hearers to be quick to listen and slow to anger (1:19-20). Yaakov is quite literally quoting the Shema in the present verse. “You say, ‘Shema (hear, listen, perceive and understand), Oh Israel, the LORD our God, the LORD is Echad (One, a unity).’ Be’seder, okay, good for you, so you recite the Shema three times a day, mazel tov (Congratulations)! The demons know the words of the Shema also, they believe that God is One, and it scares the crap out of them. You see, belief is subject to inclination. If your inclination is evil (yetzer ha-ra) then your belief is redundant. Further to the insult, the Greek kenos (empty, vain) interprets the Hebrew/Aramaic Raka, Reyka used in Matthew 5:22. This is yet another example of how context and motivation affect the interpretation and application of Scripture. Yeshua teaches that no one should call another by the term Raka from a motivation of willing death on them. However, in the context of Yaakov’s writing, describing a foolish person as a fool is a valid application of Biblical doctrine. 21 Was our father (Avinu[H]) Avraham[H] not justified (dikaioō[G]) by works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]) when he bore, lead, offered (anapherō[G]) up his son Yitzchak[H] (Isaac) on the altar (thusiastērion[G], haMizbeach[H])? 22 You see that faith, trust, belief, persuasion (pistis[G], haemunah[H]) together (sunergeō[G]) with his works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]), and as a result of the works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]), faith, trust, belief, persuasion (pistis[G], emunah[H]) was made perfect, fully filled, made whole, well-constructed (teleioō[G], hush’lemah[H]). 21 Was our father Avraham not justified by works, actions when he bore, led, offered up his son Yitzchak (Isaac) on the altar? 22 You see that faith, trust, belief, persuasion together with his works, actions, and as a result of the works, actions, faith, trust, belief, persuasion was made perfect, fully filled, made whole, well-constructed. Yaakov is not saying that Avraham was justified by actions alone but that his right actions were evidence of his faith and thus he was justified. This is affirmed by verse 22. Notice that Avraham’s actions were born of faith. Right action is the fruit of faith, the evidence of healthy roots, and just as a fruit tree is imperfect without fruit, so faith without right action is barren. Yaakov uses the word complete/full/perfect, here in unity with the word One/echad from the previous verses. He is showing that God, Who is One, Completes or makes One, faith and action. “In faith, trust, assurance, belief Avraham, when he was examined, proved, brought up Yitzchak [Isaac], and the one who had received the promises was offering up his only son;” -Hebrews 11:17 (Author’s translation) 23 and the Scripture, TaNaKh (Torah, Prophets, Writings), [Hebrew Bible] (ho graphē[G], hakatuv[H]) was fulfilled (plēroō[G]) which says, “And Avraham believed, agreed with (pisteuō[G], vayamein[H]) God (Theos[G], Elohiym[H]), and it was counted (logizomai[G]) to him as righteousness, charity, practical love (dikaiosunē[G], tzedakah[H]), [Gen. 15:6]” and he was called a friend (philos[G]) of God (Theos[G], Elohiym[H]). 24 You see, perceive (horaō[G]) therefore, now truly (toinun[G]) that a person is justified (dikaioō[G]) by works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]) and not by faith (pistis[G], emunah[H]) alone (monon[G]). 23 and the Scripture, TaNaKh, Hebrew Bible was fulfilled which says, “And Avraham believed, agreed with God, and it was counted to him as righteousness, charity, practical love, [Gen. 15:6]” and he was called a friend of God. 24 You see, perceive therefore, now truly that a person is justified by works, actions and not by faith alone. So, Avraham’s faith/belief/trust, was credited to him as right action. Now we see right action as the recompense/payment/credit/reward of right faith/trust/belief. The declaration of a man’s righteousness is made by those who observe his right action, while the right action itself is the declaration of right faith. 25 In the same way, was Rachav[H] the prostitute (pornē[G]) not justified (dikaioō[G]) by works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]) also when she allowed entry to (hupodechomai[G]) the messengers, angels (aggelos[G], malakhiym[H]) and sent them out by another way? 26 For just as the body (sōma[G], shehaguf[H]) without the spirit (pneuma[G], ruach[H]) is dead (nekros[G], meit[H]), so also faith (pistis[G], emunah[H]) without works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]) is dead (nekros[G], meitah[H]). 25 In the same way, was Rachav the prostitute not justified by works, actions also when she allowed entry to the messengers, angels and sent them out by another way? 26 For just as the body without the spirit is dead, so also faith without works, actions is dead. “And Joshua the son of Nun sent out of Shittim two men to spy secretly, saying, Go view the land, even Jericho. And they went, and came into an harlot's house, named Rahab, and lodged there.” -Joshua 2:1 “By faith the harlot Rahab perished not with them that believed not, when she had received the spies with peace.” -Hebrews 11:31 It was Rahab’s faith in the God of Israel that motivated her to act to save her children and protect her family. She rightly believed that God was able to destroy the city of Jericho. Therefore her genuine faith bore the fruit of right action. Finally, “Just as the body without the spirit is dead, so to faith without right action is dead.” The spirit and faith correlate to one another and the body and action are also a pair. From this we can conclude that both these combinations (faith and works as well as spirit and body) become unclean when separated. To a Jew a dead body (according to the Torah) is unclean, so Yaakov is making a startling, even defiling insinuation. “If your faith lacks right action you are spiritually unclean and if your actions lack true faith then your actions are unclean. I know you’ve been living in the Diaspora among Greeks for some time now but don’t be misled by Greek philosophy,” says Yaakov, “they seek to divide and conquer, or have you forgotten that we Jews understand life as a unity, a functioning being of many parts, all interconnected. ‘Shema Yisrael, Adonai, Elohaynu, Adonai echad!’” “the body without the spirit is dead.” This is a known Jewish saying, recorded in Ohel Moed, fol. 15. 1. “Therefore we conclude that a person is justified by faith without the works of the Torah.” -Romans 3:28 When we place this teaching of Yaakov alongside that of Rav Shaul we see that Yaakov is emphasising the right action born of faith as being “works”. He is not saying that Torah observance is the right action but that right action is evidence of the Kingly Torah taught by Messiah, which is at work in the believer. Torah observance is motivated by human effort whereas right action results from relationship, that relationship being offered by God and received by the believer. Thus, Avraham first believed God and subsequently offered up his son Isaac. Note that the Torah was yet to be given to Israel at the point of Avraham’s belief and right action. Therefore, Avraham was not seeking to observe Torah but rather to respond to God in righteousness, thus Avraham’s unified faith in action was credited to him as righteousness. In Messiah Yeshua there is no separation of faith and works. There are faith-works and there is working-faith. When Shaul/Paul says, “You are saved by faith alone, and not by works, that no one might boast,” he is rebuking boasting (which is work without faith). We are better to understand Paul this way, “It is by faith unified that you are saved and not by works (deeds devoid of faith) so that no one should boast about having earned their own right standing with God.” Shaul is definitely not contradicting Yaakov, a man whose authority he both submitted to and respected. On the contrary, Shaul affirms Yaakov’s teaching. Of course this should come as no surprise, given that the Ruach ha-Kodesh inspired the words of both men. I will conclude this way, concerning faith and right action: what God has made one, let no man separate. © 2022 Yaakov Brown For the child of Light approval should not be confused with the false desire to earn it. In Messiah Yeshua we have (past tense) been approved. Therefore, we should live from that approval and not for it. Introduction:
Yeshua speaks what follows in Jerusalem prior to (Pesach) Passover. He is among the disciples, and many other devote Jews are overhearing Him. This follows His triumphal entry into the city to the Messianic shouting of tens of thousands of Jewish worshippers and some Greek God fearers. He has just used the mashal (figure) of the wheat falling to the ground in order to produce fruit as a prophetic image pointing to His death and resurrection. Now He expounds on the imagery by explaining that those who follow Him will also suffer with Him, that is, as He has suffered and will be with Him (in a transcendent way) where He is, both in death and in resurrection. 26 If anyone serves, attends, waits on, ministers to (diakoneo[G]) Me, that one must follow Me, become My disciple (akoloutheo[G]); and where I am, in that place (ekei[G]) My servant (diakonos[G]) will also be; if anyone serves (diakoneo[G]) Me (in the future), My Father (Pater[G], Aviy[H]) will fix value upon, revere, venerate, honour (timao[G]), y’chab’denu[H]) that one. If one is determined to attend to Yeshua, serve Him, minister to Him, that one must take a step further, beyond mental assent and into discipleship. Discipleship in this context means sitting at the Rabbi’s feet, staying so close so as to be near Him at all times, and thus the essence of the Rabbi is absorbed by the disciple, talmid shel Yeshua. If one truly enters into this relationship with Yeshua, he or she will, by nature of this relationship, be where Yeshua is. Therefore, given the inseparable nature of God, the Father will honour the true disciple of Yeshua as a son or daughter. 27 “Now, at this present time (nun[G]) My breath/soul (psuche[G], nafshiy[H]) has become agitated, disquieted, anxious, distressed, troubled (tarasso[G]); and what shall I say, ‘My Father (Pater[G], Aviy[H]), save Me, keep Me safe, rescue Me (sozo[G]) from the (ho[G]) certain definite time, fixed season, hour (hora[G])’? Nevertheless, through, by, for (dia[G]) this which is to come (erchomai[G]) I came to the certain definite time, fixed season, hour (hora[G]). Yeshua’s words here are similar to those of His prayer in Gat Sh’maniym (Gethsemane) [Matt. 26:38-39; Mark. 14:34-36; Luke. 22:41-43]. The enormity of the task before Him overwhelms His humanity. He has suffered and been tried in every way as we have and yet remains sinless (Heb. 4:15). There is great comfort here for those suffering mental distress and emotional turmoil. The suffering Messiah walks with us in our suffering, not as a Job’s comforter but as One Who has suffered as we suffer. We note that it is “through, by, for” His coming death and resurrection that Yeshua has come. It is through His death and resurrection that He brings glory to the Father, and by His death and resurrection that He brings freedom to those imprisoned by sin, and it is for the purpose of reconciling the creation to the Creator that He refuses to give in to distress and anxiety. 28 My Father (Pater[G], Aviy[H]), glorify, extol, magnify, celebrate, convey the thoughts of, adorn with lustre, clothe with splendour (doxazo[G]) Your Name (sh’mecha[H]).” Then a voice came from the heavens (kol min-hashamayim[H], Bat Kol [daughter voice]): “I have glorified, extoled, magnified, celebrated, conveyed the thoughts of, adorned with lustre, clothed with splendour (doxazo[G]) My Name (it), and will glorify, extol, magnify, celebrate, convey the thoughts of, adorn with lustre, clothe with splendour (doxazo[G]) My Name (it) again.” Notice that Yeshua does not ask the Father to glorify Yeshua’s Name but to glorify the Father’s Name. Many a human being throughout history has relied on the remembrance of their name and its veneration in the temporal world in order to gain some solace at the point of their martyrdom, but Yeshua thinks not of Himself but of the Father and His eternal redemptive purposes. The primary flaw in much of our fallen human thinking is our inability to see beyond the boundaries of time and space, our inability to perceive of something outside of the temporal created universe. We ask for evidence and proof of intangible things, and when none is given we presume that the intangible simply does not exist. Yeshua shows us that even in our most desperate circumstances we can look to the Father our Creator and be certain that there is a truer reality than the one we perceive with our limited intellect. “Then a voice from the heavens…” In rabbinic tradition this “voice” is known as “Bat Kol” literally “Daughters voice” and is a title given to the voice of an angelic messenger of God. Following the last prophet of the Tanakh it is said that the Ruach HaKodesh (Holy Spirit) did not manifest Himself among the people of Israel but that instead the voice of an angelic messenger would from time to time speak from the heavens. “After the death of Haggai, Zechariah and Malachi, the last of the prophets, the Ruach HaKodesh (Holy Spirit) ceased from Israel; nevertheless they received communications from God through the medium of the Bat Kol.” -Tosefta Sotah 13:2 The rabbis also say that the Bat Kol is: "a voice that comes out of heaven proceeding from the midst of another voice,'' -Piske Tosefot in T. Bab. Sanhedrin, art. 30. One of the rabbis of the Talmud R. Yochanan ben Zaccai, was said to be well versed in the language and speech of angelic beings (Talmud Bavliy Sukkah, fol. 28. 1. & Bava Bathra, fol. 134. 1.). It is impossible to narrow down the many ways God had glorified His Name prior to these words into just one instance. In reality, the Father is referring to all that has gone before that has brought glory to His Name, and to all that is to proceed from the redemptive work of Yeshua, bringing perpetual glory to the Name of YHVH the God of Israel and of all creation. 29 Therefore, the crowd (ochlos[G]) who stood by and heard it were saying that it had thundered; others were saying, “A messenger/angel (aggelos[G], malakh[H]) has spoken to Him.” The first clause emulates the response of Israel to the thundering of God at Sinai (Exodus 19:18-19). The second clause reflects the rabbinic understanding of the Bat Kol (as explained in the previous notation). 30 Yeshua[H A] (YHVH Saves, Joshua) answered and said, “The voice (ha-kol[H]) has not come for My sake, but for your sakes. Yeshua was aware of the tradition among the teachers of Israel who taught that no man (no would be prophet, Messiah etc.) was to be listened to or received, even if he were to do as many great signs and wonders as Moses, unless the people of Israel were to hear the Lord speaking audibly to him as He did to Moses (R. Mosis Kotsensis praefat. ad Mitzvot Torah). 31 Now a separating, judgement, decision (krisis[G], nidin[H]) is upon this world (kosmos[G], ha-olam[H]); the present ruler, first in rank, a prince (archon[G], sar[H]) of this world (kosmos[G], ha-olam[H]) will be violently driven out (ekballo[G]). The driving out of the “ruler of this world” is a reference to the removal of the keys to death and hades from the one who had been given temporal control over them. That one being Satan the adversary and accuser of humanity. Thus, we see Yeshua pictured in the Revelation of John holding the keys to death and Hades as the living One Who was dead but is now alive forever perpetually and is victor over death (Revelation 1:18). The text is not saying that Satan will no longer have any influence in the fallen creation but that he has had the temporal control over death (the fruit of sin) removed from Him even while the present world order remains within the domain of death, which is within time and space. Therefore, Satan’s influence is reduced and He no longer has the ability to hold death over the heads of those who Yeshua will redeem through His death and resurrection. The reference to Satan being violently driven out is intentionally ambiguous. It means that Yeshua’s violent death will result in Satan being violently driven out of his temporal place of rule. One sees here that Satan has never been on equal footing in the battle between good and evil. In fact, as a created being he is subject to the Creator and is nothing more than a footnote in the eternal purposes of God for His creation. Satan has been allowed certain temporal power in order to facilitate the decision required in order to validate love. The so called “problem of evil” is only a problem to those whose vision is limited to time and space (the present world). From the point of view of Yeshua, even when present within time and space, Satan and the problem of evil have already been solved, overcome, done away with, through the sacrificial act of vicarious love that Yeshua has committed Himself to from before the creation of the world (1 Peter 1:19-20; Revelation 13:8). It’s interesting to note that our rabbis use the title “Sar haolam” Prince of the world in reference to the angel of death (Talmud Bavliy Yebamot, fol. 16. 2. & Sanhedrin, fol. 94. 1. & Cholin, fol. 60. 1.). 32 And I, if I am lifted up from the land (ho ge[G], ha-aretz[H]), will draw all individually (pas[G]) near to Myself.” 33 Moreover He was saying this to give a sign (semaino[G]) of the nature of death (thanatos[G]) by which He was to die. In describing the type of death He would die Yeshua also reveals the intrinsic link between glory (being lifted up in exaltation) and sacrifice (being lifted up on a Roman cross of execution). In fact, Yeshua’s vicarious sacrifice is evidence of God’s incomparable love and is therefore a manifestation of His glory. The Talmud Bavliy says that in the Olam Haba (world to come), the days of the Messiah (Messianic age), all the proselytes shall be g’ruriym גרורים, "drawn" to the sign or banner raised up by the Messiah, and will freely join the people of Israel (Talmud Bavliy Avoda Zara, fol. 24. 1. & Gloss. in ib.). 34 The crowd (ochlos[G]) then answered Him, “We have heard out of the Torah (ho nomos[G], ha-Torah[H]) that the Messiah (Christos[G], Mashiyach[H]) is to remain forever in an unbroken age (aion[G]); and how can You say, ‘The Son of Humanity (uihos ho Anthropos[G], Ben ha-Adam[H]) must be lifted up’? Who is this Son of Humanity (uihos ho Anthropos[G], Ben ha-Adam[H])?” “the Messiah is to remain forever in an unbroken age” In this context Torah/Law (nomos[G]) refers to the entirety of Hebrew Scripture (Tanakh). The reference that the crowd makes to the eternal reign of the Messiah can be linked to a number of Scriptures from the Tanakh (OT). “The LORD has sworn and will not change his mind, “You are a priest forever after the order of Melchizedek.” -Psalm 110:4 ESV Our rabbis say the following concerning Zechariah 4:14, relating the two anointed ones, Aaron and the Messiah: "These are Aaron and the Messiah; and it would not be known which of them is (most) beloved, but that he says, Psalm 110:4, ‘the Lord has sworn, and will not repent, you are a priest for ever’; from whence it is manifest that the Messiah is more beloved than Aaron the righteous priest.'' - Avot R. Natan, c. 34. Rabbi Moshe Hadarsan writes: Psalm 45:1-2 is also understood by our ancient writers to be an allusion to the King Messiah. “My heart overflows with a pleasing theme; I address my verses to the king; my tongue is like the pen of a ready scribe. You are the most handsome of the sons of men; grace is poured upon your lips; therefore God has blessed you forever.” -Psalm 45:1-2 ESV The Targum (2nd Century Aramaic paraphrase) renders: "thy beauty, O King Messiah, is more excellent than the children of men.'' Psalm 72:17 is interpreted by numerous rabbinical commentators as referring to the perpetual nature of the Messiah (T. Bab. Pesachim, fol. 54. 1. Nedarim, fol. 39. 2. Bereshit Rabba, fol. 1, 2. Echa Rabbati, fol. 50. 2. Pirke Eliezer, c. 32.): “May his name endure forever, his fame continue as long as the sun! May people be blessed in him, all nations call him blessed!” -Psalm 72:17 ESV “how can You say, ‘The Son of Humanity (Ben ha-Adam) must be lifted up’?” They are not saying that they don’t know what the Messianic title “Son of Man” (taken from the prophet Daniel 7:13) means, rather they are asking to whom it applies. We know this because they link the title “Son of Man” to their question regarding the Torah, showing that they see the Messiah and the Son of Man as being synonymous titles. Both ancient and modern Jewish scholars alike agree that Daniel 7:13 is a reference to the Messiah (Zohar in Gen. fol. 85. 4. Bemidbar Rabba, sect. 13. fol. 209. 4. Yarchi & Sandiah Gaon in Dan. vii. 13. & R. Yeshua in Iben Ezra in ib.). 35 Therefore, Yeshua[H A] (YHVH Saves, Joshua) said to them, “For a little while longer the all existing Light [not created] (ho phos[G], ha-Or[H]) is among you. Walk halachically (hit’hal’chu[H]) while you have the all existing Light [not created] (ho phos[G], ha-Or[H]), so that darkness [created] (skotia[G], choshekh[H]) will not take hold of (katalambano[G]) you; he who walks his halacha (ha-holeich[H]) in the darkness [created] (bachoshekh[H]) does not see, perceive (eido[G]) where he goes. Messiah Yeshua is the all existing Light that walks among them and will soon ascend to the Father. Therefore, while He is among them they are to “walk”, that is practice faith according to the Light of the King Messiah. Their halakhah (applied faith) must reflect Yeshua’s teaching and practice. The counterpoint to this is the consequence of darkness taking hold of those who fail to walk according to the Light of Yeshua. We note that the Light of Yeshua is not created but all existing, while the darkness is a created thing that is subject to the Creator, to Yeshua. Thus, the one who “walks” practices faith in darkness, practices vain faith and is unable to see (perceive) even the direction he is heading in. 36 While you have the all existing Light [not created] (ho phos[G], ha-Or[H]), believe, be persuaded, trust (pisteuo[G], ha-amiynu[H]) in the all existing Light [not created] (ho phos[G], ha-Or[H]), so that you may become children of the all existing Light (b’neiy ha-Or[H]).” These things Yeshua[H A] (YHVH Saves, Joshua) spoke, and He went away and hid Himself from them. We note that only those who trust in the all existing Light of Yeshua will become children of Light. All human beings are children of creation and therefore in one sense children of God. However, throughout Scripture a distinction is made between B’nai ha-Adam (children of fallen humanity) and B’nai Elohiym (children of God). Therefore, in another sense only those who receive the Light of God are truly children of God. “Children of Light” is synonymous with “B’nai Elohiym” children of God. “Children of Light” is not as some suppose an allusion to Essene theology. In fact, Yeshua’s teaching could not have been further from the esoteric teaching of the Essenes. So much so that Yeshua never addressed the Essenes or acknowledged them as part of God’s continued plan for the ethnic, religious, empirical, chosen people of Israel. Far too much conjecture has been entered into by so called “Messianic” Bible teachers, who make erroneous claims concerning the Essene sect, linking Yeshua to the cult using nothing more than conjecture and supposition. In fact the teaching of the Essenes has more in common with the false belief of Gnosticism than it does with Judeo-Messianic thought. 37 But though He had made (asah[H]) so many miraculous signs (otot[H]) before them, they were not believing, being persuaded, trusting (pisteuo[G], he’emiynu[H]) in Him. In spite of the many signs Yeshua performed and the audible voice from the heavens, there were still many who didn’t trust in Him as the promised King Messiah. 38 Fully filling the word, essence, substance (ho logos[G], ha-Davar[H]) of Yishayahu[H] (Isaiah: Salvation He is YHVH[H]) the prophet (ha-naviy[H]) which he spoke: “Lord (YHVH[H]: Mercy), who has trusted (he’emiyn[H]) our report? And upon whom has the arm (zeroah[H]) of the Lord been uncovered, revealed, made naked (nig’latah[H])?[Isaiah 53:1]” The author of John’s Gospel quotes the prophet Isaiah intending the full context of Isaiah 53:1-12 to be considered. We note that a connection is made between the present verse and the beginning of the Gospel linking the Davar, word essence of God to both Yeshua and the words of Isaiah made manifest. This tragic indictment observes the public revelation of Messiah to the people of Israel and our inability to comprehend Him. So obvious is His person among us that it is as if He were made naked before us. And yet, we failed to receive Him corporately at His first coming, though many believed individually. 39 For this reason they could not believe, trust (pisteuo[G], l’ha’amiyn[H]), for Yishayahu[H] (Isaiah: Salvation He is YHVH[H]) said again, 40 “He has shut (hasha[H]) their eyes and He made their heart (leiv[H]) fat (hash’mein[H]), otherwise they would not see (yir’eh[H]) with their eyes and understand, consider, discern (yaviyn[H]) with their heart (leiv[H]), and return (vashav[H]) and I heal (v’rafa[H]) them. [Isaiah 6:10]” Once again the context of Isaiah 6 is intended. The reality was that we had allowed ourselves to become numb to God’s voice and under Roman oppression had become preoccupied with the temporal goal of freedom from servitude to a foreign power rather than concerning ourselves with our nation’s need for freedom from idolatry and godlessness. The poetic imagery of the prophet Isaiah likens the clogging of the arteries to the spiritual condition of the inner being. We note that our return as a people needs to begin in our willingness to be discerning with our vision: only then can we return to be healed, made whole. This is a poignant reminder for the present age where the media seeks to cloud our vision with false reports and immoral agendas. We are challenged as followers of Messiah to be discerning, listening to the voice of the Ruach HaKodesh rather than the voice (spirit) of the air (Satan). Sadly, many so called “believers” today have fallen victim to spiritual fatness of heart (core being) and have been taken hold of by the darkness of the age. 41 These things Yishayahu[H] (Isaiah: Salvation He is YHVH[H]) said because he saw His (Yeshua/YHVH[H]) opinion, judgement, view, glory and he spoke of Him (Yeshua/YHVH[H]). Yochanan the author once more makes the connection between Yeshua and Deity. The glory Yeshua spoke of in the previous verses was that of the Father, now the author of the Gospel notes that Isaiah said these things as a result of seeing the glory of the Son. It seems likely that Yochanan is referring to Isaiah 6:1-3: “In the year of King Uzziah’s death, I saw Adonai sitting on a throne, high and lifted up,[a] and the train of His robe filled the Temple. 2 Seraphim were standing above Him. Each had six wings: with two he covered his face and with two he covered his feet, and with two he flew. 3 One called out to another, and said: ‘Holy, holy, holy, is Adonai-Tzva’ot! The whole earth is full of His glory.’” -Isaiah 6:1-3 TLV Therefore, John’s Gospel makes the glory of God the Father and the glory of God the Son echad (One, a complex unity). Keep in mind that part of Yeshua’s glory is His death and the resulting resurrection and assent. We need also understand that this means that Isaiah saw and received the Messiah Yeshua some 700 years before Yeshua was born into time and space. So much for “progressive revelation”. 42 Nevertheless many even of the rulers, princes, leaders [both religious and secular] (archon[G], ha-shariym[H]) believed, trusted (he’emiynu[H]) in Him (Yeshua), but because of the P’rushiym[H] (Pharisees, chaste ones) they were not confessing Him, for fear that they would be put out of the synagogue (aposunagogos[G]); “many even of the rulers, princes, leaders [both religious and secular] (archon[G], ha-shariym[H]) believed, trusted (he’emiynu[H]) in Him (Yeshua)” Many among the ruling religious class believed. This means Pharisees, Priests, secular rulers, and yes, even some Sadducees. “but because of the P’rushiym[H] (Pharisees, chaste ones) they were not confessing Him, for fear that they would be put out of the synagogue (aposunagogos[G]);” Retrospectively the author of the Gospel would have loved for his fellow Jews to step up and have the godly chutzpah to profess their faith at this time, but having lived to see the outworking of God’s redemptive purpose he also knew that Yeshua had to enter death and resurrection as the King Messiah. Therefore, we should not stand passing judgement against those among the rulers who believed. They were in an extremely difficult position and would later become emboldened following Shavuot (Pentecost), spreading the Good News by the Spirit of God in them. “put out of the synagogue (aposunagogos[G])” [John 9:22] In the first century it was more common to refer to being cast out of the “Congregation of Israel” when referring to full excommunication from the people and religion of Judaism. The rabbinical equivalent exercised against the messianic Jewish community of the early body of believers was called “cherem” (lit. devote to destruction) The threat of the present text does not necessarily refer to cherem, a form of complete excommunication from the congregation of Israel, meaning they would shunned by the community but not refused entry to the Temple precinct (there was no Great Synagogue at the time because the Temple was the central place of Jewish Worship until 70 CE). However, regardless of the specific intent, it was a significant threat, given that the local synagogue acted as a type of community centre, as well as a subsidiary place of worship and Torah study, and that those who were “cherem” (if this was the implied threat) were only to enter through the mourners (and the excommunicated) gate of the Temple and move to the left contrary to the practice of others, proclaiming the state of their excommunication. "all that go into the temple, go in, in the right hand way, and go round, and come out in the left, except such an one to whom anything has befallen him, and he goes about to the left; (and when asked) why dost thou go to the left? (he answers) because I am a mourner; (to whom it is replied) he that dwells in this house comfort thee: (or) שאני מנודה, "because I am excommunicated"; (to whom they say) he that dwells in this house put it into thy heart (that thou mayest hearken to the words of thy friends, as it is afterwards explained) and they may receive thee.'' -Mishnah. Middot, c. 2. sect. 2. 43 for they loved the glory, judgement, approval, opinion, view (doxa[G], kevod[H]) of human beings (agappao[G], anashiym[H]) rather than the glory, approval (doxa[G], kevod[H]) of the God (ho-Theos[G], ha-Elohiym[H]). This is a sad indictment on us all. It is not that we don’t love the glory and approval of God, rather it is that we have compromised ourselves in order to receive the glory and approval of human beings. In doing so we show that we do not properly understand the fruit of either. The glory and approval of human beings may reap temporal comfort but it will inevitably reap eternal destruction whereas the glory and approval of God may reap temporary discomfort but will ultimately reap eternal life. For the child of Light approval should not be confused with the false desire to earn it. In Messiah Yeshua we have (past tense) been approved. Therefore, we should live from that approval and not for it. 44 And Yeshua[H A] (YHVH Saves, Joshua) cried out like a raven (krazo[G]) and said, “He who believes, trusts (pisteuo[G], hama’amiyn[H]) in Me, does not believe, trust (pisteuo[G], ma’amiyn[H]) in Me but in Him who sent Me. Yeshua screams this truth above the crowd of Passover worshippers. Ref. “If you have seen Me you have seen the Father” (John 14:7, 9). “Seen” meaning, “perceived, received, understood, accepted etc.” 45 He who sees Me observes, looks attentively to (theoreo[G]) the One who sent Me. 46 I have come, all existing Light [not created] (ho phos[G], ha-Or[H]) into the world (kosmos[G], ha-olam[H]), so that everyone who believes, trusts ((pisteuo[G], hamamiyn[H]) in Me will not remain in darkness [created] (ba-choshekh[H]). The Greek theoreo further affirms the depth of sight (spiritual) required in a person’s seeking out God the Father. “I have come, all existing Light [not created] (ho phos[G], ha-Or[H]) into the world” This statement makes a clear distinction between the created light of the fallen world (Sun, moon etc.) and the all existing Light of the King Messiah. The Light of Messiah has entered the world and has eclipsed the created light of the sin affected days of the present creation. Therefore, the created darkness is removed from those who receive Yeshua’s all existing Light. 47 If anyone hears (akouo[G], v’hashomeia[H]) My spoken words (rhema[G], d’variy[H]) and does not keep, guard (phulasso[G], yish’mereim[H]) them, I do not separate, pronounce judgement on (krino[G]) him; for I did not come to separate, pronounce judgement on (krino[G], eshpot[H]) the world (kosmos[G], ha-olam[H]), but to save (sozo[G], l’hoshiya[H]) the world (kosmos[G], ha-olam[H]). The Greek rhema refers to spoken word, whereas the Hebrew davar is the sum of all aspects of word, substance. Yeshua is calling attention to His public teaching, after all, who can hear that which they haven’t had the opportunity to listen to. “for I did not come to separate, pronounce judgement on the world, but to save the world…” This applies to Yeshua’s first coming. He has come the first time in order to give Himself as the substitutionary sacrifice that enables others to come to salvation. However, He will return to Judge (Matt. 25:31-46; John 5:22, 27; 2 Cor. 5:10; ). In fact the following verse tells us that the very word that issues from the mouth of Yeshua will judge humanity in the last day, that being Yom HaDin (Day of the Judgement). 48 He who disregards, rejects, does away with (atheteo[G]) Me and does not receive, take hold of (lambano[G]) My spoken words (rhema[G], d’variy[H]) has one who separates, pronounces judgement on (krino[G], yadiyn[H]) him; the word, essence, substance (ho logos[G], ha-Davar[H]) I spoke is what will separate, pronounce judgement on (krino[G], yadiyn[H]) him at the extreme last day (eschatos hemera[G], bayom ha’achron[H]). The “One” Who passes judgement on the last day is both the Father and the word of Yeshua. 49 For I did not speak on My own initiative, but My Father (ho Pater[G], Aviy[H]) Himself who sent Me has given Me a command, charge, injunction (entole[G]) to be spoken (epo[G]) and to be uttered (laleo[G]). The commandment given to Yeshua is not, as some foolish so called Messianics’ teach, the Torah. Those who insist that the Torah is the centre of faith are idolaters and false guides. Rather the commandment given of the Father specifically to and through Yeshua is the sum of the Torah and the eternal application of that part of the Torah which remains (not all of the Torah is necessary in the Olam Haba. There will be no need for “Thou shalt not…” in a world devoid of sin). The “command, charge, injunction” given to Yeshua by the Father concerns the freeing of those made captive to sin and its fruit death. The resulting command, injunction, bearing the fruit of eternal life. 50 And I see, perceive (eido[G], yodatiy[H]) that His command, charge, injunction (entole[G], mitzvato[H]) is eternal life (zoe aionios[G], chayeiy olam[H]); therefore the things I speak, I speak in the same manner as My Father (ho Pater[G], Aviy[H]) has told Me.” The Greek word entole is best translated “injunction” here. In the usual English sense and within the limitations of time and space eternal life is not a command but an injunction that puts an end to the fruit of sin and is an ongoing charge to those who are being sanctified within time and space until that point in time when eternity and the temporal world converge at the second coming of the resurrected King Messiah Yeshua. The manner of the Father is manifest in the Son as the outworking of His redemptive purpose for humanity. © Yaakov Brown 2020 To be known by Him means to receive His knowing of us... The knowledge of God is not the accumulation of information, rather it is the receiving of His Spirit, Who produces in us the fruit of “Love, joy, peace, patience, gentleness, integrity, trust, goodness, and self-control.” (Gal. 5:22), and equips us with the gifts of “Wisdom, knowledge, trust, healing, miracles, prophecy, discernment, and language”(I Corinthians 12:8-10). Introduction:
The prophet has just introduced Tzemakh (The Branch) and spoken of a future where Hashem would presence Himself as He once had following Israel’s escape from Egypt (Cloud & Fire), finally covering her with a chuppah (wedding canopy) of His glory, shielding her and dwelling with her perpetually. These certain events are spoken of as if they had already happened because from God’s point of view, they have. The prophet speaks certain hope to a people who have made certain their own suffering through their sin against, and rejection of God. Now the prophet recites a song about his beloved God and His vineyard (Israel). It is no coincidence that the figurative use of the Branch in the previous chapter matches perfectly the analogy of the vineyard in the present text. In fact, the Branch will come forth from this same vineyard, being both born of it and the root that supports it. The prophet’s song employs the couplets and rhythms of Hebrew poetry, emphasizing the profound anguish of God over His people and their choice to break relationship with Him. The song quickly turns from the third person to the first person. It opens as a narrative expressed by the prophet but soon progresses to become a direct challenge spoken by God Himself. It reads like the broken cry of a jilted lover, and reflects the deep heart ache experienced by one who has given everything of himself and has been repaid with scorn. The use of the vineyard as an allegory or living parable (mashal) concerning the people of Israel is a strong theme of Isaiah. The vineyard is seen throughout Scripture as a symbol of provision, abundance, sweetness and celebration. Upon leaving the ark the first thing Noach (comfort) does is to plant a vineyard. The Torah gives numerous instructions regarding the conduct of those who own vineyards (Ex. 22:5, 23:11; Lev. 19:10, 25:3 etc.). The Torah also observes the practices of those who own vineyards (Deut. 6:11, 20:6, 22:9, 23:24, 24:21 etc.). Throughout the books of the Nevi’im (Prophets) and Ketuvim (Writings) the vineyard is observed and commented on in regard to its general nature and its correlation with the people of Israel. Finally Yeshua our King Messiah, alluding to Isaiah, employs the vineyard allegory in order to warn the Jews of the first century CE (AD) that they are living in days like those of Isaiah and the prophets, and that unless they repent they too will suffer the consequences of their wicked and hypocritical actions (Matt. 20, 21; Mark. 12; Luke. 13, 20). There is both great joy and deep despair in the story of the vineyard of HaShem. However, “Those who go out weeping with seed to sow will return with rejoicing and an abundant harvest will be theirs.” (Psalm 126:6). The Text Isaiah 5 Isa 5:1 Entreating I will sing to my sole beloved a song of my beloved concerning His vineyard. My sole beloved has a kerem vineyard b’keren in the horn (strength, flask), ben-shemen son of oil: Who is the prophet entreating? It seems that he is singing his song in the hearing of the people of Israel, entreating them as he sings first to his one true love, Hashem, and then conveying the words of HaShem’s response. This is a beautiful picture of what it means to pray. Prayer is the conversation that God began with humanity at the inception of creation. A conversation that we are invited to join. All prayer is a response to a relationship and conversation that God initiated from before we were born. The same is true of the prophet Isaiah’s song. The spirit of son-ship cries out to the Father from deep within the believer: “You have not received the spirit of bondage again to fear; but you have received the Spirit of adoption, whereby we cry, ‘Abba, Father.’” –Romans 8:15 Who does the song concern? It concern’s the vineyard, planted by the One Whom the prophet is entreating, Hashem. The second sentence could be read, “My one true love has a vineyard growing in the strong son of oil”. The traditional English translation, “My well beloved has a vineyard in a very fruitful hill:” finds its dynamic equivalent inspiration in the Targum: "the prophet said, I will sing now to Israel, who is like unto a vineyard, the seed of Abraham, my beloved, a song of my beloved, concerning his vineyard. My people, my beloved Israel, I gave to them an inheritance in a high mountain, in a fat land.'' In light of this others have suggested that the land of Israel is shaped like a horn and that, as a son born of God’s design, Israel is rich with oil (shemen), a land of fruitfulness. However, the plain meaning simply conveys strength and the progeny of oil. Thus this section of the text is open to interpretation. The vineyard is Israel (v.7), therefore, one must conclude that the horn and son of oil are either the foundation of the vineyard or the location of the vineyard, or, both. Surely the strength (keren, horn) of Israel is her redeemer, the Tzemakh Branch, the son (ben) who pours out oil (shemen), a symbol of the Holy Spirit (Ruach Ha-Kodesh). He Who was sacrificed before Israel’s creation and who was destined to enter time and space as the Branch (Messiah King), is also the vine, the very root and foundation of the nation. Therefore, the second clause of the second verse is intentionally ambiguous for the purpose of revealing both a description of the land of Israel and an allusion to the Branch of the previous chapter, who is the Messiah King Yeshua. Isa 5:2 Vayazkeihu And He dug (fenced) it, gathered and removed the stones, and planted it with the choicest vines, and built a tower in the middle of it, and also made a winepress there: and He looked for it to bring forth anaviym grapes, and it brought forth b’ushiym (stinking, worthless things) wild grapes. The ancient paraphrase Targum Yonatan has inspired the early rabbis to interpret an allegorical meaning in the poetic mashal (parable) of the Beloved’s vineyard. Given that the plain meaning itself intendeds to convey an allegorical picture of the establishment of Israel in the land, it seems reasonable to extrapolate in the manner of the rabbis. The text itself explains that, “The vineyard of HaShem Tze’vaot of heavens armies, is Beit the House of Yisrael” (v.7). “I sanctified them, and I made them glorious, I propped them up as a precious vine; and I built My sanctuary in the midst of them; and I gave also my altar to make an atonement for their sins; and I thought that they should do good works before Me, but they did evil works.” –Targum Yonatan (Isaiah 2) The Psalmist writes: “You have brought a vine out of Mitzrayim (Egypt, Double distress): You have cast out the heathen, and planted it.” –Psalm 80:8 The allegorical meaning seems to be best explained as follows:
Each element that makes up the vineyard has a practical application. The Sole Beloved is the vinedresser, the One Who takes care of the vineyard. The vines are said to be the choicest of plants. In order for a vineyard to have good fruit it must be planted with choice vines. The removal of stones from the vineyard means that the vineyard can be easily tended and that the collection of grapes is not impaired by obstacles. The fence helps to protect the vineyard from intruders and wild animals. The tower acts as a means of keeping an eye on the vineyard in case of intruders. The winepress allows the wine maker to produce quality wine from fresh grapes rather than lose quality by having to transport the grapes elsewhere in order to have them pressed. Isa 5:3 And now, inhabitants of Yerushalayim (Downpour of peace, Jerusalem), and men of Yehudah (Praise, Judah), judge, I plead with you, between Me and My vineyard. The prophet is not the one who planted the vineyard, nor does the vineyard belong to him. Therefore, it is Hashem Who now speaks directly to Israel, asking her to judge for herself. The prophet Nathan employs a similar tactic when he uses the mashal (parable) of the poor man’s lamb to rebuke king David (2 Sam. 12). The people of Jerusalem bare the name that says they have been offered the certain peace of God. The inhabitants of Judah owe their praise to the One Who brought them into the good land. Therefore, even their names testify against them. Isa 5:4 What could have been done more to My vineyard, that I have not done in it? Why therefore, when I looked for it to bring forth anaviym grapes, did it bring forth b’ushiym (stinking, worthless things) wild grapes? God ends the debate of nature verses nurture, thousands of years before the so called enlightenment. If the nurture of the perfect parent, HaShem, is shunned by His children so that they produce rotten fruit, then the conclusion is this: human nature is flawed, fallen, decaying, and neither nurture nor nature will save us. Our only hope is to turn to God and accept the nature of His perfect Son our Messiah King Yeshua. The distinction made between the hoped for choice grapes and the wild grapes is a harsh one. The choice grapes are the righteous, God fearing children of Israel. Whereas the wild grapes are symbolic of the heathen nations in the same way that wild olives are symbolic of the Gentile nations (Romans 11). Therefore, the Lord is saying that Israel has produced Godless heathens for progeny. The Torah commands that those who fail to keep the core observances of worship be removed from Israel as if they were heathens (Ex. 31:14). Thus the observation made by the vineyard owner exposes the faithless actions of those Who have been born of His vineyard. Isa 5:5 And now I’ll give you knowledge of what I’ll do to My vineyard: I will take away the mesukah hedge there, and it shall be eaten up; and break down the gader wall there, and it shall be trodden down: The mesukah (hedge, natural protection) symbolizes the Torah and the natural protections afforded Israel from God’s creation: rainfall, crops, terrain etc. The gader (wall, stone, built, manmade) is the protection God has provided through the right actions of former generations, and the practical skills to build walls and strengthen Israel’s economy. God is about to take away the provision of His creation, meaning that He will withhold the rains for the crops and allow invaders to eat what’s left of the produce of the land. He is also about to use invaders to tear down what Israel’s forebears have built so that both her spiritual and physical protection are removed. Isa 5:6 And I will lay it waste: it shall not be zamar pruned, nor dug over; but there briers and thorns will come up: I will also command the clouds that they should rain no rain upon it. The Hebrew zamar meaning pruned, also means, to make music by striking strings. HaShem will remove His fingers from the strings of Israel, her song will not be heard. There is tragic irony in this allusion to song given that this is a song of the Sole Beloved’s vineyard. This verse makes a correlation between the removal of the wall (physical care and protection) and the pruning, digging and wedding of the vineyard. It also makes a correlation between the hedge (natural, creation, protection) and the command to the clouds not to provide rain. This type of emphasis through couplets is a mainstay of Hebrew poetry, allegory and mashlim (parables). Isa 5:7 For the vineyard of HaShem (YHVH: Mercy) Tze’vaot (Who goes to war) of heavens armies, is Beit the House of Yisrael (Overcomes in God), and the men of Yehudah (Praise, Judah) are His plantation of delight: and he looked for mishpat judgment (right judgement, discernment), but behold mispach bloodshed; for tzedakah righteousness, but behold tze’akah an out-cry. The Hebrew word play in these verses places great emphasise on the ironic wickedness of those who make up the vineyard. Hashem looks for mishpat but finds mispach, He looks for tzedakah but finds tze’akah. These Hebrew words with similar sounds are none the less conveying opposing motivations. Each word is altered only slightly, either by adding a consonant or replacing one. This teaches us that it is often in the subtleties that we need to discern our path. After all, the distance between judgement (mishpat) and bloodshed (mispach) is determined by the replacement of a single character. Isa 5:8 Alas, because of those that join house to house, that add field to field, until there is no place (for others), that they may be the only ones with a place in the midst of Ha-aretz the land! From verses 8-23 Isaiah denounces six types of evil doers. His words read like observations as much as divine illuminations. He has witnessed the wickedness of his own people first hand. The Hebrew Hoy, “Alas” usually translated as “Woe”, is an impassioned proclamation of warning and incredulity. It almost always begins a denunciation of some form of evil. Yeshua Himself employed this phrase on many occasions, in some cases referring both explicitly and implicitly to the prophet Isaiah (Matt. 11:21, 23:13-20; Luke. 6:24-26, etc.). The Hebrew “Ha-aretz” should be rendered “The land”. It is a specific reference to the land of Israel, the Promised Land. It does not refer to the entire earth in this context, as some English translations suggest. This rebuke is in response to the rich ignoring the Torah instruction to ensure that the tribal lands remain in the hands of the tribes and in the possession of the families that they had been assigned to throughout the generations (Jos. 14:9). It seems that rather than returning rented land during the jubilee year (Lev 27:24), the rich had been taking the land of other Israelites as a permanent possession, thus leaving many in poverty, unable to provide for their families. A classic example of this type of sin can be seen in the actions of the wicked king Ahab of Israel (1 Kings 21). Throughout Scripture Hashem is seen to punish His people most severely for the crimes committed against the poor, the widow and the orphan. Isaiah is not alone in his description of the conditions experienced by the poor: contemporary prophets like Amos, Hosea and Micah reflect the same terrible conditions in their historical writings. Isa 5:9 In my ears, HaShem (YHVH: Mercy) Tze’vaot (Who goes to war) of heaven’s armies says, “Oaths notwithstanding, many houses shall become desolate, even in great and toviym pleasant (places), nothing will dwell. “In my ears” refers to the ears of the prophet. HaShem is speaking these words to Isaiah in order that he might convey them to the people. “Oaths not withstanding” means HaShem will keep His eternal promises (of land, priesthood and redemption etc.) to ethnic Israel in spite of the temporary need for His disciplining of them. The events described here have taken place many times throughout the course of Israel’s history. One such event is recorded in 2 Chronicles 28:5-8. During the days of Ahaz 120,000 men were killed in one day by Pekah of Samaria, and 200,000 people were carried off into captivity. Isa 5:10 For, ten acres (4 Hectares) of vineyard will yield one bat (22 litres), and the seed of an homer (220 litres) shall yield an ephah (22 litres). In simplified terms the harvest will produce only a tenth of the seed sown. This means that not only will there be little food, there will also be no provision made for saving seed to plant for the following year. This is a description of famine, starvation, desolation. Isa 5:11 Alas, because of those who rise up early in the morning, pursuing liquor; that continue until night, wine inflames them! Isa 5:12 And it has come to pass that harp, and the guitar, the tambourine, and flute, and wine, are in their feasts: but they regard not the work of HaShem (YHVH: Mercy), neither consider the work of His hands. They fail to consider that the very vineyard they are feasting in and the produce they are enjoying is the work of HaShem’s hands. The holy convocations of HaShem are being celebrated as drunken parties rather than as opportunities to commune with God as a nation. Isa 5:13 Therefore my people are gone into captivity, because they have no da’at knowledge: and their honourable men are starving, and their multitude dried up with thirst. Captivity results from a lack of knowledge. Not the knowledge of humanity but the knowing of God. To be known by Him means to receive His knowing of us. The Hebrew da’at means: knowledge, perception, skill, discernment, understanding, wisdom. The knowledge of God is not the accumulation of information, rather it is the receiving of His Spirit, Who produces in us the fruit of “Love, joy, peace, patience, gentleness, integrity, trust, goodness, and self-control.” (Gal. 5:22), and equips us with the gifts of “Wisdom, knowledge, trust, healing, miracles, prophecy, discernment, and language”(I Corinthians 12:8-10). Isa 5:14 Therefore sheol (holding place of the dead, divided into Gan-Eden [Paradise] and Gehinnom [Torment]) has enlarged herself, and opened her mouth without measure: and descending into it will be their splendour, and their abundance, and their uproar, and he who rejoices. Isa 5:15 Adam humanity will be brought down, and the mighty man will be humbled, and the eyes of the lofty will be brought low: “Sheol” should be transliterated in this context. It is at best misleading and at worst deception to translate the place of the dead as “Hell”. Sheol is divided into two and is the temporal holding place of the departed spirits of humanity. All those departed enter either Paradise or Gehinnom based on their standing before God. At the end of days the dead will rise and the righteous will enter the Olam Haba (World to come) and eternal life but the unrighteous will be thrown into the lake of fire (eternal torment) along with Satan and his spiritual allies (Rev. 20:10, 14-15). Neither the Greek “Hades” nor the English “Hell” properly convey the ancient Jewish understanding of the holding place of the dead known to Hebrews as Sheol. Hell should also not be used synonymously with eternal punishment or the lake of fire, as these are descriptions of the eternal torment that awaits the wicked following the judgement, whereas Gehinnom, which is within sheol, is a temporary place of punishment. The personification of Sheol and her widening mouth is meant to denote a great increase in deaths. The uproar of the wicked, the vain revelry of Israel will be consumed by Sheol. Those rejoicing in their wickedness will be silenced by her. Humanity, used here to indicate the pride of human knowledge, will be brought down into Sheol, all who are wise in their own eyes and take pride in their wickedness. The juxtaposition of the highs and lows will meet its crescendo in the following chapter where the One Who is High above all and Who created the depths of all things is revealed seated on His throne. Isa 5:16 But HaShem (YHVH: Mercy) Tze’vaot (Who goes to war) of heaven’s armies, shall be exalted in judgment (justice, right judgement), and Ha-Elohim (The Judge) The God Ha-Kadosh The Holy One, will prepare tzedakah righteousness. God is named here for mercy, war and judgement. He is The God (Ha-Elohim), The Holy One (Ha-Kadosh). He alone is worthy to judge. And yet, His warring and judgement are born of love and mercy. He has prepared righteousness (The Branch), He has intended salvation from the beginning. All this judgement is the discipline that precedes redemption. Isa 5:17 Then the lambs will feed in the pastures, and the waste places of the fat ones will be consumed by strangers. Wild sheep will feed on what remains of the crops and the lands and left over produce and riches of the wealthy will be consumed by foreigners. This is a tragic picture of Israel’s temporary loss of her inheritance. Isa 5:18 Alas, because of those that drag avon perversity with strands of falsehood, and sin like a rope drawn cart: Isa 5:19 Who say, “Let Him make speed, and hasten His work, that we may see it: and let the counsel of the Holy One of Yisrael (Israel) draw near and come, that we may know it! The “Woes” increase and the charges grow greater. Each subsequent act of evil is worse than the last. While the ignorant sin without a care for God, the truly wicked either abuse Him or renounce Him altogether. The words of these people are a direct challenge to God. They either don’t believe He exists or they consider Him powerless to resist them. Self-worship is perhaps the ultimate form of Idolatry. These wicked ones even employ the prophet’s own description of God as “Holy One of Israel”. In doing this they insult both God and the Patriarchs of Israel from whom they are descended. Isa 5:20 Alas, because of those that call rah evil tov good, and tov good rah evil; appointing choshek darkness for Or light, and Or light for choshek darkness; designating mar bitterness for matok sweet, and matok sweet for mar bitter! Those spoken of here are seeking to tear away at the very fabric of morality. God had seen in His creation from the beginning, that it was good. And following the creation of humanity He saw that it was “Very good”. This people, by changing the meaning of good and evil have pronounced judgement against their own sinful nature, for God had called humanity good but humanity had chosen information (Fruit of the tree of knowledge of good and evil) over relationship. Again they knock down the very fence that protected them (Torah) by saying that choshek darkness (a symbol for the evil one) is Or light. The Hebrew word Or (Light) is used of the light that predated the creation of the lights of the heavens. This is a direct insult to the pre-existent redeemer, the Light of the world, the King Messiah Yeshua. Ironically in calling bitter sweet and sweet bitter, they describe their own descent into bitterness and suffering. They had once tasted the sweet provision of God and now in calling God’s provision bitter they have pursued their own inability to provide for themselves, seeing their own bitter character as something sweet. All these perversions of truth are equally applicable to the post-modern hang over we are experiencing in today’s western culture. What we are reading here in Isaiah, a book written over two and a half thousand years ago, is a description of Relative truth, a so called new concept, concieved during the modern historical period of the enlightenment. Isa 5:21 Alas, because of those that are wise in their own eyes, and prudent in their own sight! Isa 5:22 Alas, because of those that are great at drinking wine, and men of strength who mix strong drink: Isa 5:23 Who justify the wicked for reward, and take away the righteousness of the righteous from him! Idolatry, self-worship and delusions of grandeur bear the fruit of arrogance, delusion, decadence, and injustice. Our modern media is full of stories that applaud the wicked and decry the righteous. Like the prophet Isaiah, we live in a society that detests those who walk rightly with God. Isa 5:24 Therefore as the fire devours the stubble, and the flame consumes the chaff, so their root will be as decay, and their blossom will rise as dust: because they have cast away the Torat HaShem Instruction of HaShem (YHVH: Mercy) Tze’vaot (Who goes to war) of heaven’s armies, and despised emrat the word of the Holy One of Yisrael (Israel). Because of all that the prophet has observed God has firmly established the complete burning off of the land both physically and figuratively. Fire is a symbol of judgement and power. It is judgement and torment to the wicked but it is power and light to the righteous. The reason given for this fire of judgement is that the people of Israel have cast off the loving instruction of God’s written word (Torah Emet) and have despised the spoken word (Emrat) of God. Israel had the Torah but had rejected its teaching, they had the prophets speaking the word (Emrat) but despised and mistreated them. Therefore, the only form of guidance left to them was discipline. It is true to say that it is the rejection of both the written and living word of God that continues to alienate people today from right relationship with Him. The written word (Bible) and the living Word (Yeshua, D’var, Memra, Emra) are gifted to humanity through the Jewish people, and yet humanity continues to resist relationship with her loving Creator and Father. Therefore, it would be unwise for anyone to point a finger at Israel: we are all guilty. Isa 5:25 Therefore the anger of HaShem (YHVH: Mercy) is kindled against His people, and He has stretched forth His hand against them, and has struck them: and the mountains tremble, and their carcases are torn in the midst of the streets. In spite of all this His anger is not turned away, but His hand is stretched out still. Notice the past tense, “He has stretched forth His hand against them”. Although the prophet is speaking of future events, from God’s perspective outside of time and space they have already taken place. The phrase “His hand is stretched out still” affirms the continued outworking of these things throughout Israel’s history of disobedience. This is not a case of God withholding mercy, rather it is a case of His dispensing justice. A Father who disciplines the children of others without first disciplining his own children is a fool. God is no fool, He has chosen Israel to be a light to the nations, and the light that comes forth from her will not abide darkness. Therefore, she is disciplined for the sake of redemption. Isa 5:26 And He will lift up a banner to the nations from far off, and will whistle to them from the end of the earth: and, behold, now, with haste they will swiftly come: Isa 5:27 None will become weary or stumble among them; none will slumber or sleep; neither will their loin clothes be loosed, or the straps of their sandals be broken: The banner or signal that HaShem lifts up will inform the nations of Israel’s weak position and invite them to invade her. He will strengthen their armies and ensure that they don’t grow weary or lack provision. All these privileges were once provided for Israel His chosen, now, in order to discipline Israel He has given their food to the dogs (Heathen nations). Isa 5:28 Whose arrows are sharp, and all their bows bent, their horses' hoofs will bring distress, making judgement, and their wheels will be like a whirlwind: Isa 5:29 Their roaring shall be like a lion, they shall roar like young lions: Yes, they will roar, and lay hold of the prey, and will carry it away safe, and nothing will be able to deliver it. The sharp arrows and flexible bows speak of strength of arms and the thundering horses and whirling wheels speak of fear and awe. The Lion is the symbol of Judah (Gen. 49:9) and her Messiah King. Therefore, the allusion to the nations being like lions is an affront to Judah’s identity and an ironic metaphor for the taking away of her strength. Isa 5:30 And growling on the ground in that day they shall roar against them like the roaring of the sea: and if one looks to the land, behold choshek darkness and tzar distress, and Or the light chashak grows dark in the clouds. Just as they have called darkness light and light darkness, so Hashem will turn the natural light that they rely on to darkness and keep from them the spiritual light that they have rejected, leaving them in physical distress and spiritual darkness. Introduction to Isaiah 6: Isaiah 6 begins with the end of Uzziah’s reign (approx. 740 BCE/BC) and the ordination of his son Jotham who had already been co-regent for some time due to Uzziah’s sinning against the Lord by desecrating the Temple rite (2 Chronicles 26:16-21). While it may seem odd to place the vision and calling of Isaiah here rather than at the beginning of the book, there is a certain sense of continuity about it. The opening chapter of Isaiah gives an overview of the message of the entire book, and chapters 2-5 offer prophecies that pertain specifically to Uzziah’s reign, notwithstanding the cyclical nature of Hebrew prophecy. Thus, at the death of the reasonably godly but somewhat flawed king Uzziah, at a time when Israel was teetering on the edge of complete moral corruption, the prophet’s calling is affirmed in the vision of HaShem. This is why the prophet is told that the people will be “Ever hearing but not understanding, ever seeing but not perceiving” (v.10). Sadly, Isaiah’s calling, like that of the Messiah he foretells (Chpt. 53), will be the calling of a suffering servant who is deeply grieved by the sin of his people. Five years prior to the death of Uzziah, Tigalatpileser III (745-727 BCE/BC) the warring king of Asyria came to power, and with him a vision to build an empire that encompassed the known world (Between the Euphrates and the Nile). Thus the kingdoms of Samaria and Judah were about to meet their doom. And yet, rather than repent, they continued to pursue moral decay. “Let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we shall die.” –Isaiah 22:13 The Text of Isaiah 6 Isa 6:1 In the year that king Uziyah (My strength is YHVH) died I saw Adonai my Lord sitting upon a throne, high and lifted up, and the hem of His robe filled Ha-heiycal the temple, palace. The Scriptures teach that a human being cannot see God in His full glory (the face of God) and live (Ex. 33:20; John 1:18). This does not however prevent God from revealing Himself in other ways. The rabbis agree that while God is echad, yet He has many emanations. We know that the Patriarch’s met God face to face in human form. Abraham called one of the three messengers that met him at Mamre, “Adonai, My Lord” (Gen. 18:1-3) and the text shows us by using the first and third person interchangeably that this was in fact God Himself revealed as a messenger. Likewise Jacob wrestled with a “Man” Who was also God (Gen. 32:24-30). Jacob understood this mysterious man to be God, exclaiming, “I have seen God face to face and am preserved”. Thus we understand that God is echad but reveals Himself in many ways. Speaking of the Messiah Yeshua the letter to the Philippians reads: “He made Himself of no reputation and took upon Him the form of a servant and was made in the likeness of man.” (Phil. 2:7) Again, speaking of the Messiah Yeshua the letter to the Colossians reads: “For in Him dwells all the fullness of the Godhead bodily.” (Col. 2:9) It is noteworthy that Isaiah saw Adonai (My lord) and not HaShem (YHVH). The hem of the robe is an allusion to the High Priest’s garment. With both these things in mind and given that Hashem is invisible, the Lord Whom Isaiah is referring to is a representation of Hashem in human form, wearing a robe (priestly, royal). The symbolic use of the robe unites the Kingship and Priesthood of Israel in the Ministry of the Great High Priest and King Messiah. John’s Gospel affirms the identity of the Lord of Isaiah’s vision when, speaking of Yeshua he writes: “Therefore they could not believe, because as Isaiah also said, ‘He has blinded their eyes, and hardened their heart; that they should not see with their eyes, nor understand with their heart, and be converted, and I should heal them. These things said Isaiah, when he saw his glory, and spoke of him.” – John 12:39-41 Ha-heiycal can mean both Temple and Palace. It can be understood to refer to both the earthly Temple in Jerusalem and the heavenly Temple. There is little point arguing over which is meant because the glory of God is over all the earth. The throne is that of the King of Mercy (YHVH denotes mercy). It is in fact the mercy seat and He Who sits on it defines mercy. Isa 6:2 Seraphim (Burning Angelic beings) stood above it: each one had six wings; with two covering the face, and two covering the feet, and two being used to fly. Our rabbis generally agree that these are the same beings as those who appear in Ezekiel's vision of the living creatures (Ezekiel 1:5); their name Seraphim, means burning, and Ezekiel's living creatures are said to be "like burning coals of fire"(Ezekiel 1:13). God’s messengers are like flames of fire (Ps. 104:4). Specifically Seraphim. The plural form Seraphim probably also alludes to the four angelic beings who proclaim the holiness of God in the Revelation (Rev. 4:8). The Seraphim cannot be the two guardians of the Ark of the Covenant because those guardians are Cherubim (Ex. 25:22). The wings covering the face show reverence for the manifest glory of God and the wings covering the feet are a sign of humility. The fact that these particular messengers are messengers of fire (Seraphim) correlates to the fire of judgement, refining and empowering that HaShem is bringing upon Israel. “Who makes His malakhim messengers ruachot spirits and His shartayn servants eish loheit fiery flames.” –Psalm 104:4 Isa 6:3 And one cried to another, and said, “Holy, holy, holy, is HaShem (YHVH: Mercy) Tze’vaot (Who goes to war) of heaven’s armies: kol ha-aretz the whole land/earth is full of His glory. When something is repeated it is firmly established within time and space, and when something is said three times it is an eternal and immutable truth. Thus the Seraphim cry “Kadosh, kadosh, kadosh!” They are speaking of the perfection, purity and absolute otherness of God. Yes, He is also Father, Son and Spirit, and He is echad (A complex unity). “And the four beasts had each of them six wings about him; and they were full of eyes within: and they rest not day and night, saying, ‘Holy, holy, holy’, HaShem Lord Elohim God Shaddai Almighty, who was, and is, and is to come.” –Revelation 4:8 This revelation of God’s holiness correlates to the prophet’s repeated use of the title “Holy One of Israel”. Isaiah uses this title twelve times between chapters 1-39, and seventeen times between chapters 40-66. This is yet another reason to affirm the united view of the book of Isaiah. There is far too much continuity of language for the book to have been written by multiple authors. Outside of Isaiah the title “Holy One of Israel” occurs infrequently (Psalms 71:22, 78:41, 89:19; Jeremiah 50:29, 51:5). Isa 6:4 And the threshold shook at the voice of him that cried, and Ha-Beit the house was filled with smoke/cloud/vapour. Ha-Beit is another name for the Temple in Jerusalem. For the prophet Isaiah and for the people of Israel the manifestation of smoke, cloud and fire recalls the presence of God’s angel with the people following their escape from Egypt. It is a reminder that God Himself is Israel’s hope and freedom. At a time when the Temple service is being dishonoured through syncretism and idolatry, God is showing the prophet a manifestation of hope for the future. Isaiah is witnessing the manifest Messiah, God with us, seated on the throne of mercy and offering Israel hope and a future. Isaiah is gazing, not into a dream or an open vision but through a temporal rupture that allows him to look through the skin of time and space and into the Olam Haba (World to come), the eternal now. Isa 6:5 Then I said, “Alas for me! for I am undone; because I am a man of unclean lips, and I dwell in the midst of a people of unclean lips: for my eyes have seen the King, HaShem (YHVH: Mercy) Tze’vaot (Who goes to war) of heaven’s armies. Why “Unclean lips”, why not “Unclean lev (heart, inner person)”? “A good man, out of the good treasure of his lev (heart, inner person) brings forth that which is good; and an evil man out of the evil treasure of his lev (heart, inner person) brings forth that which is evil: for of the abundance of the lev (heart, inner person) his mouth speaks.” –Luke 6:45 Like every righteous person before him and every righteous person after him, Isaiah, when standing in the presence of the revelation of God, becomes profoundly aware of his own sinful state and the greater sin of his people. It is a great indictment against the wicked in Israel that their prophet Isaiah, who is walking in right relationship with Hashem, none the less confesses that he is a man of unclean lips. Isaiah shows contrite humility in owning his sinful nature. No one can come to God without humility. Isa 6:6 Then one of the Seraphim (Burning Angelic Messenger) flew to me, having a live coal in his hand, which he had taken with the tongs from off Ha-misbeach the altar: The altar is the altar of blood sacrifice. The Hebrew root zabach means to shed blood, slaughter. Whenever the word mizbeach is used without a qualifying term such as “incense”, it refers to the altar of blood sacrifice. This is important because remission of sin comes only through the shedding of blood (Lev 17:11; Hebrews 9:22). One need not ask how a burning being can hold a hot coal in its hand. Isa 6:7 And touched it upon my mouth, and said, “Hinei, Now, this has touched sephateycha your lips, language, speech; and avoncha your perversity is taken away, and chatat’cha your sinful condition t’kupar purged. The messenger says “Your sinful actions are taken away and your sinful nature is purged”. The Hebrew avon denotes sinful action that perverts and the Hebrew chata denotes the sinful nature or yetzer ha-ra (evil inclination). This is a theophany of redemption. Isaiah is receiving the gift of eternal salvation through Yeshua Whose blood has been shed on the altar and Whose fire of judgement has purged Isaiah and reconciled him to God in perfect love. This is a revelation of the resurrected and transcendent Messiah, made to a prophet who lived some 600 years prior to the Messiah’s being born into time and space. Isa 6:8 Vaesh’ma and I heard, listened to, received et kol the voice of Adonai (My Lord), saying, “Who shall I send, and who will go for us?” Then I said, “Hineini (Here am I, ready, willing, trusting, certain); send me”. Notice again that it is Adonai (My Lord) and not HaShem (YHVH) Who asks the question, “Who shall I send”. This is in fact that person of God with us, the Messiah, the Branch, Who is speaking to His prophet Yishaiyahu (My Salvation is YHVH). Isaiah answers with the voice of a willing servant (Yeshua), “Here I am ready, willing, trusting, certain, send Me!” Isaiah is acting here as a prefigure for the Messiah, Who willingly answered God’s call to go to the people of Israel for the sake of their salvation. The person of God is echad (a complex unity). This manifestation of the Lord and the plural language lanu (for us) is a revelation of the complex unity of the Godhead. Isa 6:9 And He said, “Go, and tell this people, indeed you hear, but you don’t understand; and indeed you see, but you don’t perceive.” HaShem now speaks in a voice of judgement, temporarily preferring the title “This people” over the former “My people”. Yeshua refers to those who reject God as children of Satan, thus they are no longer children of God (John 8:44). However, in repentance they may become children of God again, and with regard to the ethnic people of Israel, they are loved for the sake of the Patriarchs and continue to play an intrinsic role in the salvation of humanity. God has not forsaken the Jewish people whom He foreknew(Romans 11:2). These words are spoken by the Lord Adonai to Isaiah. They are also spoken by Hashem to Yeshua. In fact, Isaiah, whose name means “My Salvation is YHVH”, is a type for the Messiah, whose name means “YHVH is Salvation”. Isa 6:10 “The lev inner person (heart) of this people has become fat, and their ears heavy, and their eyes shut; lest they see with their eyes, and hear with their ears, and understand with their lev (inner person, heart), and turn back, and be healed.” The lev (inner person) is often misunderstood. The English word heart can mislead the reader because it is regularly used in western culture to speak of the seat of emotion. To the Hebrew the lev is the place where all other elements of the person converge: mind, emotion, physiology, soul, senses etc. By calling the lev fat the prophet is saying that like the arrogant rich who are violating the poor, the fat lev is headed toward destruction. “Heavy ears” is a Hebrew idiom that denotes dullness, an inability to receive godly council. The “shut eyes” are a wilful refusal to acknowledge the destructive consequences of sin. If the people were to see their actions and the resulting suffering they have caused, hear the cries of the poor and allow the Spirit of God to convict their inner person, they would turn back to Hashem and be saved. However, like many during the time of Messiah, they were so intent on pursuing destruction that they refused to turn back. The phrase “Lest they see…etc.” is a mournful note in a tragic song. HaShem knows they will not see. It is not a case of HaShem forcing His people to become blind but rather giving them the freedom to choose their own destruction. Without freewill love cannot exist. How HaShem and His prophet long for the people of Israel to turn back to Him. However, HaShem has already seen the decision of His people. Thus He speaks this mournful outcome into time and space via His prophet Isaiah. Isa 6:11 Then I said, “Adonai (My Lord), how long?” And He answered, “Until the cities be wasted without inhabitant, and the houses without persons, and the land becomes utterly desolate, Isa 6:12 And Hashem will have removed Ha-adam the humanity far away, and there is great desolation in the midst of Ha-aretz the land. The prophet is overwhelmed with grief for the plight of his people. In his role as an intermediary he calls on God, “My Lord, how long?” HaShem answers by describing a time yet future when the cities and houses of Judah and Jerusalem will be devoid of inhabitants (Probably a description of the Roman destruction of Judah and Jerusalem in 70 CE/AD). A time when the land too will be laid waste and all human interaction with it will cease. Isa 6:13 But perpetually in it will be a tenth, and will return, and start burning (or, will eat of the land, consume): they will be as a terebinth tree, and as an oak, whose felling is in them, a stump, memorial, pillar: the holy seed will be a pillar, memorial, stump. “Holy seed” or “Seed that is holy” is a reference to the remnant of Israel. The tenth is an allusion to the tithe that has gone unoffered in Israel’s wickedness. The number ten is also a symbol of fullness. Thus the tenth, which is a remnant, will again become a full nation. This verse is characteristic of Isaiah’s message. In the midst of the dire observations and future consequences of Israel’s sin, hope shines through. God reminds the prophet that there will always be a remnant (Tenth) and that even when the returning people fall like trees and are consumed by fire, the remnant will remain as a stump and a memorial before Hashem. The remnant of religio-ethnic Israel will be according to the election of God’s grace (Romans 11:5). The holy seed of Israel will one day produce the Holy One of God, The Branch and Redeemer. © Yaakov Brown 2017 |
Yaakov BrownFounder of the Beth Melekh International Messiah Following Jewish Community, Archives
February 2024
|