contact us at: bethmelekh@gmail.com
בית מלך Beth Melekh
  • Home - דף בית
  • Soundbites with Yaakov
  • Yaakov's Commentary - פירוש יעקב
  • Yeshivah Videos - וִידֵאוֹ
  • This Week at Yeshivah
  • Faith Statement - הצהרת אמונה
  • Worship Songs
  • Yeshivah - ישיבה
  • Weekly Torah - פרשה התורה
  • Yaakov Ben Yehoshua a Concise Life Story
  • Yaakov's BOOKS ספרי שׂל יעקוב
  • Torah Kosher Foods - אוכל כשר
  • Festivals 5780 - 5781 - חגים
  • Affiliate - בית הכנסת שותפים
  • Counting the Omer - ספירת העומר
  • Eliyahu Chris Hennessy

Ha-Sefer shel Yochanan John 8:1-30: Caught in the Act by the Light of the World

1/5/2020

 
“Aniy Or Ha-Olam, I am, I exist, am present as the uncreated Light of the world:” -Yeshua
​Introduction:
 
With regard to the debate over whether the portion of John’s Gospel from 7:53 to 8:11 is valid Scripture or not: while it’s true that no early manuscripts include this account, it is equally true to say that it’s more than likely a legitimate oral or written tradition passed on by the first century Ecclesia (Body of believers), Church, and included by later scribes. Any believer who has met Yeshua and been filled with His Spirit will testify that the Spirit of God in us witnesses to the inspiration of this portion of the text.
 
Therefore, in keeping with the teaching of Messiah, I trust myself to the unity of Scripture and Power (Born of the Spirit), and consider this account to be Scripture, inspired by God and passed on to us for good purpose.
 
It seems to me that the Yeshua of this story is the Yeshua of the wider body of New Testament writing. He is here, unmistakable, the Teacher of Israel, full of compassion, mercy, tenacity and holy chutzpah. His feet firmly planted on the ground and His Spirit drawing wisdom from the heavens.
 
I invite you to put away the conjecture of scholarship and instead to embrace the incomparable Messiah of Israel. The story of the young woman caught in adultery is one of His most powerfully intimate public moments.
 
1But Yeshua[H] (YHVH Saves, Joshua, Jesus) walked (halakh[H]) to the Mount of Olives (har-hazeiytiym[H]). 
 
Yeshua had clearly walked to the Mount of Olives (Har Ha-zeiytiym) the night before, probably with His disciples in tow. It appears He had spent the night there, or alternatively He may have stayed in the village of Bethany on the lower eastern slope of the mount with His friends Miriyam (Mary), Marta (Martha) and El’azar (Lazarus)[John 11:1-2].
 
Keep in mind that the walk from the Temple precinct the night before down the hill into the Kidron valley would have taken Yeshua and His disciples past Gat Sh’maniym (Gethsemane) and then up the other side to the summit. The journey to and from the mount of Olives is approximately 1.5km, taking in terrain and the navigating of a clear path. If Yeshua had stayed overnight in Bethany, He would likely have taken a path along the Kidron ravine on the road to Bethany, an estimated further 2 kilometres could be added to each trip if this was His route. Of course, it would have meant that He climbed to the summit of the Mt of Olives from the opposite side the following morning before sunrise and thus ascended from the Mount as described in the text.
 
2 In the morning, at daybreak (orthos[G], ba-boker[H]) He came again into the temple (hieron[G], ha-mikdash[H]), and all the tribes (ho laos[G], ha-am[H]) were coming to Him (Yeshua); and He sat down (yeishev[H]) and taught, held discourse with them (didasko[G], vay’lam’teim[H]).
 
This event took place early, probably prior to Sacharit (Morning Prayer). Yeshua sat down to teach in the court of women as was the custom of other rabbis of the time. This is unlikely to refer to the court of the Gentiles as some suggest. Those coming to Him were of the “tribes” of Israel, the collected Jewish pilgrims who had made aliyah for the festival of Sukkot, only Jews were allowed in the court of women. As confirmation of this location verse 20 has Yeshua near the treasury which is situated in the court of the women.
 
The Greek “didasko” perfectly conveys the rabbinical method of teaching which involved discourse rather than a Greco-Roman style lecture and rhetoric format.
 
Keep in mind that the Jewish day had begun after the previous sundown and it would continue to be the seventh day of Sukkot until after sundown that evening. Therefore, Sh’mini Atzeret (the eighth day Sabbath following Sukkot was yet to occur).
 
It is important to note that the great lamps of the court of women had been put out for the final time at the conclusion of the last full night of Sukkot (The previous night). This gives context to Yeshua’s “I am the light of the world” statement later in the text.
 
3 Some of Ha-Soph’riym The Scribes (of Torah & commentary; often Sadducees) and the P’rushiym[H] (Separate, distinct, chased ones, Pharisees) brought a woman caught in adultery, and had her stand (histemi[G]) in the centre of the court (of women), 4 they said to Him (Yeshua[H]), “Rabbi [H] (didaskalos[G]), this woman has been caught in the act of adultery. 5 Now in the Torah[H] (Instruction) Moshe[H] (Moses, drawn out) commands us to stone such women; what then do You say?”
 
“Scribes and Pharisees” is used only here in John’s Gospel, leading some to believe that the textual addition of verses 7:53 to 8:11 is more likely to be connected to Luke’s Gospel account, due to similar language being employed more often by Luke. However, it is equally possible that the author of John’s Gospel simply used a different turn of phrase. The result is the same, it shows the unified front of the two groups who held little theological common ground between them, the Scribes generally being associated with the Sadducees rather than the Pharisees.
 
The first question many ask is, “If the woman was caught in the act of adultery as the text explains, where is the man who had been involved?” Of course, this can be answered by conjecture in many different ways: perhaps the Scribes and Pharisees in question were Patriarchal chauvinists’, happy to let a fellow male go free? It is possible, based on Mishnaic assertions regarding the proliferation of adulterous acts in the first century (ref. note on v.7-6), that several of them might have been guilty of such sin themselves? It is even possible that the man involved in the sinful act was complicit in the plan to trap the girl or that he was simply able to escape while she was being caught? There is no way of knowing for certain. There must however, be two witnesses to this crime according to Torah (Deut. 19:15).
 
What we do know is that the Torah requires that both the man and the woman caught in this type of sexual sin are to be punished (Lev.20:10; Deut.22:22-24 ref. Num. 5:11-31). Therefore, the question that was being posed by the Scribes and Pharisees was already outside the specific guidelines of the Torah, meaning that the response must come in the form of an interpretive halakhic ruling from the rabbi being questioned, in this case, Yeshua.
 
We also know (because the Torah Scribes and Pharisees, specify stoning as the punishment) that the woman was a virgin pledged in marriage prior to the act of adultery. We know this because that is the only situation in which the Torah specifies stoning as the method of punishment for adultery (Deut. 22:23-24). Elsewhere in cases of adultery strangling is the commanded punishment (Lev. 20:10).
 
The fact that this was done publicly was unusual, given that it was illegal for Jews to carry out the death penalty under Roman governance (Though this was not always successfully policed Acts 7:58-59). This was the counter balance to the fact that the Torah required stoning for such an offense, leaving Yeshua in what some of the Torah Scribes (teachers) and Pharisees might have hoped to be an impossible position.
 
It’s important to note that Yeshua’s mother Miriyam (Mary) might just as easily have found herself in this situation if not for the righteous action of Yeshua’s earthly (adoptive) father Yosef (Joseph). The key difference of course being that Miriyam was not guilty of adultery. This correlation may well have made this an especially emotional event for Yeshua. It’s also important to note that throughout His earthly ministry Yeshua sought to honour women and restore their rightful place in God’s creative order. Therefore, the intentional humiliation of this young woman could only have served to anger Yeshua. In light of this, His measured response under the circumstances is without comparison.
 
 6 They were saying this, to try Him, so that they might have grounds for accusing Him. But Yeshua[H] stooped down and with His finger (daktulos[G]) wrote, (grapho[G], letters as opposed to drawing) on the ground (stone floor of the court of the women).
 
In the midst of this tumultuous scene, Yeshua, calmly bends down and starts to write in the dust on the stone floor of the temple court of the women of Israel. One of our Yeshivah students noted that it reminded her of a child at play. Another student suggested that in doing this He took control of the situation, drawing everyone’s attention to Himself and requiring the Torah Scribes (teachers) and Pharisees to work to His time table, unwilling to be bullied into playing their silly game. Those of us who are old enough to remember might also liken it to a teacher writing on a black board. All eyes and ears are now on Yeshua and what He is writing.
 
We know that He wrote rather than drew. The Greek “grapho” refers to the writing of letters.
 
So, what did He write? We can’t possibly know for certain though there are many suggestions. The only one I have found value in outside of what I will propose is the idea that He may have written the words of Jeremiah 17:13:
 
“Lord, you are the hope of Israel;
    all who forsake you will be put to shame.
Those who turn away from you will be written in the dust
    because they have forsaken the Lord,
    the spring of living water.”
 
Perhaps Yeshua began His list of their names here and completed them when He stooped down to write the second time. However, while I like this idea, It seems highly unlikely. I would like to propose another option.
 
I have asked myself, “Did God the Father ever write on stone with His finger?” The answer is “yes”, in fact He did it three times (Exodus 31:18; 34:1; Dan. 5:25). I suggest that the first thing Yeshua wrote in the dust of the stone floor was the Ten commandments. Perhaps He did this, emulating His Father (Exodus 31:18; 34:1). It’s worth noting that the second to last commandment is, “You shall not commit adultery.” Thus, He reminded His audience of the many commandments each one of them had broken, and that they might just as well find themselves standing where the woman was now put on display.
 
7 But when they stayed to question Him (Yeshua), He rose up, and said to them, “The sinless one (ho-anamartetos[G]) of you, let him be the first (protos[G]) to drop (ballo[G]) a building stone (lithos[G]) on her.” 8 Again He stooped down and wrote (grapho[G], letters as opposed to drawing) on the ground (stone floor of the court of the women). 9 When they heard (akouo[G]) it, they began to leave one by one, beginning with the elderly ones, and He (Yeshua) was left alone, and the woman, where she was, in the centre of the court of women. 
 
Clearly there were none present who were without sin. Therefore, Yeshua’s statement was intended to bring a right judgment to this situation (Deut.17:7).
 
We note that elsewhere Yeshua calls that generation an adulterous one (Matt. 12:39). If there’s one thing we know about Yeshua it is that He detests hypocrisy.
 
In reference to the time of Roman occupation, during the lifetime of Rabban Yochanan ben Zaccai, the Mishnah records the following:
 
"when adulterers increased, the bitter waters ceased; and Rabban Yochanan ben Zaccai (who was now living) caused them to cease.'' -Mishnah. Sotah, c. 9. sect. 9.
 
In other words, adultery had become so prolific among the people of that generation that the practice of the Torah concession regarding trying a suspected adulteress with “bitter waters” (Num. 5:11-31) was stopped due to the fact that many of the husbands in question were already guilty of adultery themselves.
 
By responding as He did Yeshua was not breaking the Torah, as some suggest, to the contrary, He was upholding its finer requirements. Both offenders were not present, nor was this being done in a court of Jewish rulers. Yeshua therefore, was making a halakhic ruling based on the fact that the Torah could not possibly be honoured by this illegitimate trial.
 
After speaking He then stooped down to write for the second time. The result being that one by one the woman’s accusers walked away in defeat.
 
I suggest that this time He wrote the words that the finger of God wrote on the wall of Belshazzar’s palace in Babylonian:
 
“Mene: God has numbered the days of your reign and brought it to an end.
 
Tekel: You have been weighed on the scales and found wanting.
 
Uparsin (Peres): Your kingdom is divided and given to the Medes and Persians.”
 
In other words, to these particular Scribes of the Torah and the Pharisees He was saying, “God has numbered the days of your reign and brought it to an end. You have been weighed on the scales and found wanting. Your kingdom is divided and given to your oppressors (not the Medes and Persians but the Romans).”
 
Therefore, in all of Scripture God has written directly on stone three times plus one (Yeshua in the present account).
 
Whatever Yeshua wrote, it seems that it was what He said that moved them to leave. After all, the scripture says, “When they heard it, they began to go out one by one.” This likely refers to His challenge “Let the one among you who is without sin drop the first building stone…” Although, given that the chronology places the second writing before the description of their leaving, it may be that Yeshua spoke while He wrote, or even spoke out loud what He wrote.
 
Now Yeshua is left standing with the young woman, an intimate moment emphasized by the tender words that follow.
 
10 Rising up, Yeshua[H] (YHVH Saves, Joshua, Jesus) said to her, “Dear woman (gune[G]), where are they? Is there no one to give judgement (katakrino[G]) against you?” 11 She said, “No one, Lord (Adonay[H], kurios[G]).” And Yeshua[H] said, “Neither do I pass judgement on you. Separate (apo[G]) yourself now and miss the mark (sin) no more hereafter.”
 
Yeshua looks upon this humiliated and broken woman and with great mercy and compassion He shows her that social justice is but a tear in the vast ocean of God’s eternal justice.  “Does anyone condemn you?” He says, to which she responds in a somewhat shaky but surprised voice, “No one, Adonay.” And in keeping with what John’s Gospel says about Him Yeshua says, “I do not condemn you, either. Go. From now on sin no more.” I hear it this way, “Your sin has been covered, you’re free to start again child, don’t go back to that self-destructive lifestyle.”
 
And, just maybe, He was also thinking, We need to get my mum to set you up with a nice Jewish boy with the character of my adoptive dad Yosef (Joseph), someone who will honour you and treat you the way a woman should be treated.
 
It’s important to note that Yeshua did not validate the woman’s sin, rather He showed her that she had great worth in God’s sight in spite of her sin. Therefore, “Continue to live, and turn away from your sinful practices…” Yeshua upheld the Torah and the redemptive grace of God.
 
12 Again (palin[G]) therefore (oun[G]) Yeshua[H] spoke to them, saying, “Aniy Or Ha Olam[H] I am, I exist, am present as (eimi[G]) the uncreated Light of the world (kosmos[G]); the one who follows, joins, accompanies (akoloutheo[G]) Me will not, not in the smallest way (ou me[G]) continue to walk (haholeikh[H], peripateo[G]) in the darkness (bachosheikhah[H], skotia[G]), but will have the Light of the life (phos ho zoe[G]).”
 
This must have taken place sometime later given that “they” had all walked away prior to Yeshua’s closing words with the woman caught in adultery. Therefore, verse 12 begins a separate discussion held later that day (still Hoshanah Rabah) in the court of women near the treasury or treasury receptacles that surrounded that place. This was not heard by non-Jews.
 
Yeshua’s claim to being the light of the world is made with the backdrop of the Sukkot lamp stands in mind. Further, it is made in the court where those same lamp stands had stood shining light into all Jerusalem for the seven days of Sukkot.
 
There were great Menorah-like four branched candle stands in the Temple precinct. At sundown on the first day of the feast, they went down to the court of the women where golden candlesticks had been erected, and at the head of them four golden basins, and four ladders to every candlestick, and four young priests had four pitchers of oil, that held a hundred and twenty logs (an ancient measure of oil), which they put into each basin. Wicks were made from the old breeches and girdles of the priests, and it was these oil soaked wicks that the priests would light. There was not a court in Jerusalem which was not lit up with that light, and religious men, and men of good works, danced before them, with lighted torches in their hands, singing songs and hymns of praise, which continued for the following six nights (Mishnah. Succah, c. 5. sect 2, 3, 4; Maimon. ib. c. 8. sect. 12.).
 
“Aniy Or Ha-Olam” I am, I exist, am present as the uncreated Light of the world:” This is a statement of Deity and an allusion to the light through Whom God spoke all things into existence. It’s interesting to note that unlike other occasions the Pharisees did not immediately seek to take hold of Yeshua for what they may well have understood to be a blasphemous statement. It may have been because they were still smarting from the theological defeat they had experienced earlier that day.
 
“…the one who follows Me will not, not in the smallest way continue to walk in the darkness, but will have the Light of the life.” A flood of Scripture comes to mind:
 
“The people who walk in darkness
Will see a great light;
Those who live in a dark land,
The light will shine on them.” -Isaiah 9:1 [2] NASB

 
““But for you who [b]fear My name, the sun of righteousness will rise with healing in its wings; and you will go forth and skip about like calves from the stall.” -Malachi 4:2 (3:20) NASB
 
“He says, “It is too [a]small a thing that You should be My Servant
To raise up the tribes of Jacob and to restore the preserved ones of Israel;
I will also make You a light [
b]of the nations
So that My salvation may [c]reach to the end of the earth.” -Isaiah 49:6 NASB
 
Each of these Scriptures and many more throughout the New Testament testify to Yeshua being the light of the world. This is revealed first and always first to the Jews and also always to the nations.
 
We note that it is the one “who follows” who will not walk in darkness. Following is the fruit of true belief, trust, faith. By nature following Messiah proves faith because it is an act of faithfulness.
 
13 So some of the P’rushiym[H] (Separate, distinct, chased ones, Pharisees) said to Him, “You are testifying about Yourself; Your testimony is not true, valid, faithful (ne’emanah[H], alethes[G]).”
 
If they consider Yeshua’s statement to be blasphemy they may also consider Him on trial and therefore cite Torah in relation to the need for witnesses to establish a matter (Deut.17:6; 19:15). However, it’s not clear why they say this, they may simply be invoking a sense of accountability (Prov.27:2). Regardless, it is not true to say that simply because a person speaks of themselves that the person is lying or that their testimony is unfaithful/invalid. If it were, the complaint of the Pharisees would be equally inadmissible.
 
14 Yeshua[H] answered and said to them, “Even if I testify about Myself, My testimony is true, valid (emet[H], alethes[G]), for I see, perceive (eido[G]) My place of origin (pothen[G]) and where I am going; but you do not see, perceive (eido[G]) My place of origin (pothen[G]) or where I am going. 
 
This re-establishes the former conversation regarding false judgement by sight as opposed right judgement by the relational knowledge of God (John 7:24).
 
Yeshua being God with us, has every right to testify on His own behalf because He has come from God, is in God, is One with God. God Who is faithful and cannot lie is the origin and the present person of Yeshua.
 
15 You all according to the flesh (ha-basar[H], sarx[G]) separate, choose, discern, esteem, prefer, judge (tishpotu[H], krino[G]); I am not separating, choosing, discerning, esteeming, preferring, passing judgement (eshpot[H], krino[G]) on anyone.
 
“Stop judging by mere appearances, but instead judge correctly.” -John 7:24
 
“I am not separating, choosing, discerning, esteeming, preferring, passing judgement on anyone.” Yeshua was not at that time acting as Judge, however, He will in the future judge everyone (5:22, 27-30).
 
16 But even if I do separate, choose, discern, esteem, prefer, judge (eshpot[H], krino[G]), My judgment (mishpatiy[H]) is true, valid (emet[H], alethes[G]); for I am not alone in it, but I and the Father (Aniy ve’ha-Av[H]) Who sent Me (shelachaniy[H]). 
 
The unity of God as unique manifestations of Himself, Father and Son, is self-evident here. Yeshua is qualified to judge because the Judge (the Father) is with Him and His judgement is truth.
 
17 Even in your Torah (be’torat’chem[H]) it is written (katuv) that the testimony of two men is true, valid, faithful (ne’emanah[H], alethes[G]). 18 I am He who testifies about Myself, and the Father (ve’ha-Av[H]) Who sent Me (shelachaniy[H]) testifies about Me.”
 
Some say Yeshua is distancing Himself from the Torah by saying “Your Torah”. This is utter nonsense. He is the Author and goal of the Torah, why would He distance Himself from it? In fact, saying “Your Torah” is intended as an admonition to accountability. “If you cite the Torah, then be prepared to abide by it.”
 
When a Prime Minister speaks to the nation and says “Your country needs you”, that same Prime Minister is not saying “It’s your nation, not mine” rather the statement is a call or challenge that is being made with the intention of uniting the nation. Something similar is happening here.
 
Yeshua offers two witnesses according to the Torah as a concession to their disbelief, Himself and God the Father.
 
19 So they were saying to Him (Yeshua), “Where is Your Father (Aviykha[H])?” Yeshua[H] answered, “You see, perceive (eido[G]) neither Me nor My Father; if you see, perceive (eido[G]) Me, you would see, perceive (eido[G]) My Father also.” 20 These words He spoke in the treasury (nishkah[H], gazophulakion[G]), as He taught (didasko[G]) in the temple precinct (hieron[G]); and no one seized Him, because the certain, definite, time, hour (hora[G]) for Him had not yet come (lo bai to[H]).
 
As is the case elsewhere, they had obviously misunderstood Yeshua and had concluded that He was speaking of His adoptive earthly father. Yosef is not mentioned in the Gospels following Yeshua’s youth and it is likely that he had passed away. So when Yeshua, referring to God, says “You see neither Me nor My Father; if you see Me, you would see My Father also.” They presume He is speaking of an earthly father whom they have not seen. In fact, Yeshua is clearly alluding of their spiritual blindness.
 
NB: The Septuagint text of Neh. 13:7 uses the same gazophulakion[G] to translate the Hebrew nishkah[H], meaning “storeroom”.
 
The Temple treasury may be a reference to a storeroom in the court of the women or to the treasury receptacles for financial offerings which were positioned in the colonnade which surrounded the court. Either way, these things were being said in a place where only Jews could enter.
 
We note the now familiar refrain:
 
“…and no one seized Him, because the certain, definite, time, hour for Him had not yet come.”
 
21 Therefore, He (Yeshua) said again to them, “I go away, and you will seek (zeteo[G]) Me, and will die in your sin (missing the mark);
 
For the first time in the Gospel of John dying in sin without a vicarious means of redemption is alluded to. This is not an idea foreign to Torah but it is an idea that is beyond the scope of the first century Jewish understanding of atonement as it pertains to a transcendent application.
 
where I am going, you’re not able, nor do you have the power (dunamai[G]) to come.” 22 So the Religious Judean leaders (Yehudiym[H]) were saying, “Surely He will not kill Himself, will He, since He says, ‘Where I am going, you’re not able, nor do you have the power (dunamai[G]) to come.’”?”
 
Ref. 7:34
 
Once again they understand Yeshua literally and ironically conclude at least part of the whole. See my commentary of John 7:34 for further clarification of what Yeshua is alluding to.
 
23 And He was saying to them, “You are from below (kato[G]), I am from above (ano[G]); you are of this world (ha-olam[H], kosmos[G]), I am not of this world (ha-olam[H], kosmos[G]). 
 
“You are from below, I am from above” Not, “you are from under the earth” but, “Your origin is of the earth”. Whereas, “My origin is above in the heavens, of God Himself”. Yeshua was born into time and space from an eternal existence outside of time and space, being a manifestation of the person of God seeded in a human womb and thus fully God and fully man.
 
“you are of this world, I am not of this world” Once again this concerns origin. Yeshua is quite clearly in the world but He originates from within God whereas those who are hearing His words originate from within the sin affected creation.
 
24 Therefore I said to you that you will die in your sins (missing the mark); for unless you believe, are persuaded (pisteuo[G]) that I Am (ego eimi[G]), you will die in your sins (missing the mark).”
 
Therefore, as alluded to previously, without a saving knowledge of Yeshua they will die in their sin. In fact, the Greek text essentially says “Unless you believe that I AM (God with you), you will die in your sins.”
 
25 So they were saying to Him (Yeshua[H]), “Who are You?” Yeshua said to them, “What have I been saying to you from the beginning?
 
It’s possible that those questioning Him were wondering who could have devised this strange new teaching and therefore, asked “Who are You?” Alternatively, some of them had begun to feel a pricking of awe and were seeking an explicit revelation in order to decide whether or not to accept Yeshua and His teaching. Finally, those who hated him were challenging His claims by saying “Who are You?”
 
26 I have many things to speak and to judge (lishpot[H]) concerning you all, but He who sent Me (sholchiy[H]) is true, faithful (ne’eman[H], alethes[H]); and the things which I heard from Him, these I speak to the world (ha-olam[H], kosmos[G]).”
 
Yeshua is essentially saying, “You don’t get to know all the details now, I will say only what the Father has given Me to say, the rest will be revealed at the proper time.”
 
27 They did not realize that He had been speaking to them about the Father (Ha-Av[H]). 28 So Yeshua said, “When you lift up the Son of Man (Ben Ha-Adam[H]), then you all will know (yoda’tem[H], ginosko[G]) that I Am (ego eimi[G]), and of separation (apo[G]) I Myself make, fashion, produce (poieo[G]) nothing, but according (kathos[G]) to that taught (didasko[G]) to Me of the Father (Ha-Av[H]), these things I speak.
 
“When you lift up the Son of Man, then you all will know that I Am…” Yeshua is referring to the means of His death and inferring that His death will come about as a result of their actions. He is also clearly saying that those listening will come to understand that He is the King Messiah and God with us, upon seeing Him crucified. Therefore, lifting up in the sense of glory is intrinsically connected to His suffering on the cross.
 
Once again Yeshua points to the Father God as the origin of His actions and speech. 
 
29 And He who sent Me is with, after, behind, in the midst of (meta[G]) Me; He is not leaving Me alone, for I always do the things that are pleasing to Him.”
 
Yeshua is saying that He is inseparable from God. The Father Who sent Him is with Him before, after, and in the midst of Him, eternally present and One. Therefore, the foolish popular evangelical notion that the Father turned His face away from Messiah on the cross (Not recorded in Scripture), is untenable and diminishes both the nature and the redemptive work of God in its presumption that the Father did not suffer with the Son. It is tantamount to blasphemy. 
 
30 As He spoke these things, many had come to believe, were persuaded by, put their trust (ya’amiynu[H], pisteuo[G]) in Him (Yeshua).
 
Once again “many”, including some of them Pharisees and Scribes, Sadducees and rulers, had come to believe in Yeshua as they listened to His words. These same ones would later come to have a fulness of understanding regarding His redemptive work following His death and resurrection and the outpouring of the Ruach HaKodesh (Holy Spirit). They had begun a genuine journey of faith. This does not, as some Christian scholars presumptively conclude, describe a shallow intellectual assent to faith in Yeshua. It saddens me to hear even some Messianic Jews proliferate this nonsensical idea. The text gives no such indication.
 
Copyright 2020 Yaakov Brown

Comments are closed.
    Picture

     כתביו של יעקב
    Yaakov Brown

    Spiritual leader of Beth Melekh Community, Auckland, N.Z.

    Yaakov Brown BOOKS
    Picture

    Archives

    February 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013

    Categories

    All
    2019
    5778
    666
    Aaron
    Abba
    Abimelech
    Able
    Abraham
    Abram
    A Child Is Born
    Acts
    Adam
    Adam And Eve
    Adonai Roi
    Adonai Tzevaot
    Adultery
    Adversity
    Affliction
    Ahaz
    Ahsur
    Al Chet
    Aleph
    Aliens
    Aliyah
    Aliyot
    Allah
    All Tribes
    Almah
    Altar
    Amalek
    Ancient Hebrew
    Andrew
    Angel Of The Lord
    Angels
    Annas
    Annul
    Anointed
    Anointing Oil
    Anti-Christmas
    Antonia
    Anxiety
    Approval
    Arabic
    Aramaic
    Ariel
    Ark
    Ashamnu
    Ashteret
    Ashterot
    Ashur
    Ask
    Ask The Rebbe
    Asneth
    Assyria
    Atonement
    Aviyad
    Avram
    Azariah
    Babel
    Babylon
    Baker
    Baladan
    Baptism
    Bavel
    Bedikat Chametz
    Beersheba
    Beersheva
    Beggar
    Begin Again
    Beginning
    Behjamin
    Beit Chasda
    Beit Tzaida
    Bel
    Belly
    Beloved
    Benjamin
    Bereishit
    Besorah
    Bethany
    Bethesda
    Bethlehem
    Beth Melekh
    Bethsaida
    Betrayal
    Betrothal
    Betulah
    Bilhah
    Birth
    Birthdays
    Birthright
    Blasphemy
    Blessing
    Blessing For The Season
    Blind
    Blood
    Boat
    Body
    Bondage
    Book Of Life
    Books
    Books Of Moses
    Booths
    Branch
    Branches
    Bread
    Bread From Heaven
    Bread Of Life
    Brit HaChadashah
    Brother
    Brothers
    Burden
    Caiaphas
    Cain
    Camping
    Cana
    Capernaum
    Capital Crime
    Capstone
    Carry
    Caught In Adultery
    Celebration
    Challah
    Challot
    Channukah
    Chanukah
    Chanukiyah
    Chanukkah
    Chasidiym
    Chatan Bereishit
    Chatan Torah
    Chavah
    Chesed
    Chief Priests
    Children
    Children Of Light
    Chosen
    Chosen One
    Christian
    Christmas
    Chuppah
    Circumcision
    City
    Civil New Year
    Clay
    Clean
    Cloud Of Witnesses
    Clouds
    Coal Fire
    Coals
    Cohen Hagadol
    Comfort
    Comforter
    Command
    Commandments
    Compass
    Confusion
    Construct
    Contemplative Worship
    Context
    Contextual Fallacy
    Cornerstone
    Corner Stone
    Cosplay
    Courage
    Court Of Women
    Covenant
    Covenants
    Creation
    Creator
    Crescent
    Cross
    Crown Of Thorns
    Crucifixion
    Crushed
    Crying
    Cults
    Culture
    Cup
    Cupbearer
    Curse
    Cyrus
    Darkness
    Daughters Of Men
    Daughters Of Zion
    Davar
    David
    Day
    Day Of Atonement
    Day Of Coverings
    Day Of Soundings
    Death
    Dedication
    Deliver
    Demons
    Depression
    Desert
    Desolate
    Deuteronomy
    Devar
    Difficult
    Dinah
    Dionysus
    Dipped
    Disciple
    Disciples
    Discipline
    Disembodied Spirits
    Disputes
    Distinction
    Diversity
    Doctrine
    Dominion
    Dragon
    Dreams
    Drink
    Drunk
    Eat
    Echad
    Edom
    Egypt
    Eighth Day
    Elazar
    El Gibor
    Elieizer
    Eliphaz
    Elohim
    Elohiym
    Emmanuel
    Emotion
    Empirical
    Emunah
    Endor
    End Times
    Enemies
    Envoys
    Ephraim
    Error
    Esau
    Escaping Goat
    Eschatology
    Esther
    Eternal Life
    Eternal Priesthood
    Eternal Punishment
    Eternal Security
    Ethnic
    Etrog
    Eunuchs
    Eve
    Even
    Even Ha Shetiyah
    Everlasting
    Everlasting Father
    Evidence
    Evil
    Exodus
    Eye
    Eyes
    Faith
    Faithfulness
    False Gods
    Family
    Famine
    Farmer
    Fasting
    Father
    Fear
    Fear Not
    Fear Of Death
    Feast Of Trumpets
    Feet
    Fence
    Festival
    Festival Of Shelters
    Festival Of Tabernacles
    Festivals
    Filthy Rags
    Fire
    First Century
    First Century CE
    Fish
    Fishes
    Flagrum
    Flesh
    Foreigners
    Forsaken
    Foundation Stone
    Free
    Freeborn
    Freedom
    Free From Fear
    Freewill
    Fullness
    Gabbatha
    Galilee
    Galilee Of The Nations
    Gates
    Gathered
    Gat Sheminim
    G-d With Us
    Genealogy
    Generations
    Genesis
    Gentile
    Gethsemane
    Ghosts
    Gift
    Giving
    Glory
    Goal
    Goal Of Torah
    God
    Godhead
    Gods
    God With Us
    Golgotha
    Gomer
    Good
    Good News
    Goshem
    Goshen
    Gospel
    Gospel According To John
    Gospel Of John
    Government
    Goy
    Goyim
    Grain
    Grapes
    Grave
    Greek
    Groom
    Ha Akedah
    Ha Akeidah
    Haaretz
    Ha Aretz
    Ha Beit
    Ha Besorah Al Piy Yochanan
    HaBrit HaChadashah
    Ha Davar
    Ha Devar Emet
    Ha Din
    Ha-D'var Emet
    Haf Tarah
    Hagar
    Hail
    Ha Kotel
    Halakhah
    Haman
    Hannukah
    Haran
    Har Beit
    Harvest
    HaShem
    Hassidim
    Healing
    Heaven
    Heavens
    Hebrew
    Hebrews
    Hebron
    Hermon
    Herod Antipas
    Hezekiah
    Hidden Meaning
    Hidden Messiah
    High Holy Days
    High Priest
    High Shabbat
    Historical
    History
    Holy
    Holy Of Holies
    Holy One Of Israel
    Holy Spirit
    Homosexuality
    Horus
    Hosea
    Hosheia
    House
    House Of Prayer
    Humanity
    Humility
    Husband
    Hyper-grace
    I AM
    Identity
    Idolatry
    Idols
    Images
    Imannuel
    Imanuel
    Imanu El
    Immanuel
    Immature
    Immersion
    Inerpretation
    Instruction
    Isaac
    Isaiah
    Isaiah 10
    Isaiah 12
    Isaiah 14
    Isaiah 30
    Isaiah 38
    Isaiah 47
    Isaiah 8
    Isaiah 9
    Ishmael
    Islands
    Israe
    Israel
    Israelite
    Israelites
    Jabok
    Jacob
    Jacob's Ladder
    Jacob's Well
    Jeremiah
    Jerusalem
    Jesse
    Jesus
    Jew
    Jewish
    Jewish Wedding
    Jews
    Jezreel
    John
    John 1
    John's Gospel
    Jonah
    Jordan
    Joseph
    Joseph Of Arimathea
    Josephus
    Jotham
    Judah
    Judaism
    Judas
    Judea
    Judean
    Judeans
    Judge
    Judgement
    Judges
    Justice
    Kadesh
    Kadosh
    Kashrut
    Keeping The Sabbath
    Kefa
    Kerosh
    Ketonet
    Keturah
    K'fa
    K'far Nachum
    Kfar Nachum
    Kinetic Worship
    King
    King David
    Kingdom
    King Messiah
    King Of Glory
    King Of The Jews
    Kinneret
    Kinsman Redeemer
    Kiriat Arba
    Kislev
    Know
    Kohen HaGadol
    Kol Nidrey
    Koresh
    Kosher
    Kosmos
    Laban
    Lake
    Lamb
    Lame
    Land Of Israel
    Last Days
    Law
    Lazarus
    Leah
    Levi
    Leviathan
    Levites
    Levitical
    Levitical Priesthood
    Leviticus
    Life
    Life In The Blood
    Lifted Up
    Light
    Light Of The World
    Light To The Nations
    Lion
    Lion Of God
    Lion Of Judah
    Lions' Gate
    Live
    Living
    Living Water
    Living Waters
    Loaves
    Locusts
    Logos
    Lord
    Lost Tribes Myth
    Lot
    Love
    Love One Another
    Love Your Neighbour
    Lulav
    Maccabees
    Machpelah
    Magen David
    Malchus
    Man
    Manasseh
    Mangal
    Manna
    Mansions
    Marduk
    Mark Of The Beast
    Marriage
    Marta
    Martha
    Mary
    Mashal
    Mashalim
    Mashiach
    Mashiyach
    Mashiyach Neshlach
    Mashlim
    Matriarchs
    Matzah
    Matzot
    Mayim Chayim
    Meaning In Names
    Medium
    Meggilat
    Megiddo
    Megillah Ruth
    Melki Tzedek
    Memra
    Menachiym
    Mene
    Menorah
    Menstrual Cloth
    Meradoch
    Mercy
    Merodach-Baladan
    Messenger
    Messengers
    Messiah
    Messianic
    Messianic Age
    Messianic Gentiles
    Messianic Judaism
    Messianic Judaism 101
    Mighty God
    Mikdash
    Mikvah
    Mikveh
    Millennium
    Miltha
    Miracle
    Miracles
    Miriam
    Miriyam
    Mishnah
    Missing The Mark
    Mithra
    Mitzvah
    Mitzvot
    Moadim
    Molech
    Moloch
    Moral Law
    Mordechai
    Moriah
    Mosaic Penmanship
    Moses
    Moshe
    Mountain House
    Mountain Of HaShem
    Mount Zion
    Mourning
    Mt Gerizim
    Mt Moriah
    Mt Seir
    Mt Sinai
    Mud
    Murder
    Na'arah
    Nablus
    Nahor
    Nakdimon
    Nakdiymon Ben Gorion
    Names
    Naphtali
    Naqdimon
    Nation
    Nations
    Nativity
    Nebo
    Nefesh
    Negev
    Nephilim
    New Beginning
    New Commandment
    New Earth
    New Heavens
    New Jerusalem
    New Land
    New Testament
    New Year
    Nicodemus
    Night
    Nikodemos
    Nisan
    Noah
    No Fear
    Northern Kingdom
    Not Of This World
    Oaths
    Oath Taking
    Officer Of The King
    Oil
    Olam Haba
    Olam Hazeh
    Olive Press
    Olives
    One
    Pagan
    Paid Servant
    Paleo Hebrew
    Parables
    Pardes
    Parousia
    Passover
    Patriarchs
    Paul
    Paul The Apostle
    Pele Yoeitz
    Pentecost
    People
    Peoples
    Perez
    Perushim
    Pesach
    Peter
    Pharaoh
    Pharisees
    Philip
    Philistia
    Pictographic Hebrew
    Pilate
    Plagues
    Pool
    Pool Of Siloam
    Potiphar
    Potiphera
    Potter
    Powerpoint
    Practice
    Praetorium
    Prayer
    Prayer Shawl
    Pre-Trial
    Priest
    Priesthood
    Priestly Under Garment
    Prince Of Peace
    Princes
    Promised Land
    Promised Messiah
    Promises
    Prophecy
    Prophet
    Prophets
    Prosper
    Protection
    Proverbs
    Provide
    Prune
    P'rushiym
    Psalm
    Psalmist
    Purim
    Purple
    Questions
    Rabbi
    Rabbinical
    Rabbis
    Rabboniy
    Rachel
    Rainbow
    Ram
    Ram's Horn
    Rape
    Rapture
    Rashi
    Rav Shakeih
    Rav Shaul
    Reason
    Rebecca
    Rebeeca
    Redeemed
    Redeemer
    Redemption
    Red Sea
    Refute
    Regalim
    Rejoicing
    Rejoicing In The Torah
    Religious
    Religious Leaders
    Remnant
    Rend
    Repairing The World
    Ressurection
    Rest
    Resurrection
    Return
    Returning
    Reuben
    Revelation
    Righteousness
    Rites
    Ritual Purity
    Ritual Washing
    Rivkah
    Robe
    Rod
    Roman
    Romans
    Romans 14
    Rome
    Room
    Rooster
    Root
    Rosh Hashanah
    Ruach
    Ruach HaKodesh
    Ruach Ha-Kodesh
    Rule
    Ruth
    Sabbath
    Sacrifice
    Sadducees
    Sages
    Salem
    Salim
    Salvation
    Samaritan
    Samaritan Woman
    Sanctify
    Sanhedrin
    Sarah
    Sarai
    Sar Shalom
    Satan
    Saturday
    Saturnalia
    Saul & The Witch
    Saved
    Savior
    Saviour
    Scapegoat
    Scourge
    Scribes
    Scripture
    Scroll
    Seamless
    Second
    Second Coming
    Sect
    See
    Selichah
    Selichot
    Sennachereb
    Sennacherib
    Sent
    Sepulchre
    Seraphim
    Serpent
    Serpents
    Servant
    Servants
    Service
    Servitude
    Session
    Set You Free
    Sexual Sin
    Shabbat
    Shabbat Bread
    Shabbats
    Shaliach
    Shamash
    Shavuot
    Shechem
    Sheep
    Sheep Gate
    Sheep & Goats
    Shelters
    Shem
    Shemini Atzeret
    Shemot
    Shepherd
    Shiloach
    Shiloh
    Shimon
    Shimon Kefa
    Shivah
    Shmini Atzeret
    Shofar
    Shofrot
    Shomeir Shabbat
    Shomron
    Shomroniym
    Shomroniyt
    Shoot
    Shuvah
    Sickness
    Sight
    Sign
    Signs
    Silent
    Siloam
    Simchat Torah
    Simeon
    Simon Peter
    Sin
    Sinai
    Sisters
    Sitting Shivah
    Sixth Day
    Slave
    Slavery
    Slave To Sin
    Smoke And Fire
    Snake
    Sodom
    Sol Invictus
    Solomons Colonnade
    Solomons Porch
    Son
    Song Of The Lamb
    Sons Of God
    Sorceress
    Soul
    Speckled
    Spirit
    Spotted
    Star Of David
    Steps
    Stock
    Stomach
    Stone
    Story In Genealogy
    Streaked
    Streaming
    Strength
    Stump
    Substitution
    Success
    Sukkah
    Sukkot
    Sunday
    Superstition
    Swear
    Sychar
    Synagogue
    Tables
    Taken Away
    Tallit
    Talmidim
    Talmud
    Tamar
    Tammuz
    Tanakh
    Targum
    Tav
    Tear
    Teffilot
    Tefillah
    Tefillin
    Tehilim
    Temple
    Temple Mount
    Temple Rites
    Teshuva
    Testimony
    Tevilah
    That Day
    The Beast
    The Binding Of Isaac
    The Branch
    The Bride
    The Day
    The Exodus
    The Fall
    The Festival
    The Good Samaritan
    The Hebrew Text
    The Holy Name
    The Lamb
    The Land
    The Land Of Israel
    Theology
    The Pavement
    The Seventh Shofar
    The Third Temple
    The Two Olive Trees
    The Word
    Thirst
    Thomas
    Throne
    Tikun Olam
    Tishrei
    Tishri
    Tithing
    Toledot
    T'oma
    Tomb
    Torah
    Tower Of Babel
    Town Of David
    Tradition
    Transgression
    Translation
    Treasury
    Trial
    Tribe
    Tribes
    Trust
    Truth
    Turning
    Twins
    Tzemakh David
    Tzemakh Hashem
    Tzitzit
    Tziyon
    Uncreated
    Under Garment
    Unity
    Unleavened Bread
    Unquenchable Fire
    Uriah
    Uzziah
    Vayikra
    Vengeance
    Vicarious
    Village
    Vine
    Vinedresser
    Vineyard
    Violation
    Virgin Birth
    Voice
    Voice Of Annulment
    Voices
    Vow
    Vows
    Wait
    Waiting
    Walls
    Warning
    Washing
    Washing Feet
    Watchers
    Watchmen
    Water
    Water Of Life
    Water Ritual
    Waters
    Wave Offering
    Way
    Weak
    Weapon
    Wedding
    Well
    Wells
    Western Wall
    Whip
    Wine
    Wine Press
    Witchcraft
    Witness
    Woman
    Woman At The Well
    Wonderful Counsellor
    Word
    Work
    World
    World To Come
    Wrath
    Wrestles
    Write
    Xmas
    Yaakov
    Yaakov Ben Yehoshua
    Yaakov Brown
    Yahashua
    Yahshua
    Yam
    Yarden
    Yehoshua
    Yehudah
    Yehudi
    Yehudiym
    Yeshayah
    Yeshayahu
    Yeshivah
    Yeshua
    Yeshua In The Feasts
    Yeshua's Birth
    YHVH
    Yishaiyahu
    Yishay
    Yishayahu
    Yisrael
    Yizreel
    Yochanan
    Yom Ha Teruah
    Yom Ha-Zikharon
    Yom Kippur
    Yom Shishi
    Yom Teruah
    Yom T'ruah
    Yoseph
    Yoseph Ben Gorion
    Zebulun
    Ziggurat
    Zion

    RSS Feed

May the present peace of Messiah Yeshua reconcile you to the eternal rest of HaShem!


Meeting times

Friday evening: 6:30pm - 10pm

Telephone

64 212709933

Email

bethmelekh@gmail.com