“You shall not go about as a talebearer: I say that, since all those who start quarrels and speak lashon hara go into homes to seek what evil they can see, or what evil things to tell in the marketplace,” -Rashi on Leviticus 19:16:1 Sefaria Community translation Yaakov 3:1-18 (Author’s convergent translation from Greek, Aramaic and Hebrew)
1 Not many of you should seek to become teachers, masters, instructors with doctorates, my brothers and sisters, fellow Jews[1:1], see, perceive, view to know that we who are teachers will receive a greater, stricter judgment. 2 For in many ways all, absolutely stumble, fall, offend. If any certain one does not stumble in word, essence, substance, he is a perfect, complete man, person, strengthened to bridle, rein in, direct, guide the whole body as well. 3 Now, behold, pay attention we put the bits into the horses’ mouths so that they will trust, be persuaded by us, we turn, direct their whole body as well. 4 Now, behold, pay attention, look at the ships too: though they are so large and are driven by fierce winds, they are turned, directed by a very small rudder wherever the violent motion of the one who makes straight, governs, the pilot, wills, determines. 5 Thus also the tongue is a small member, part, and it boasts greatly. Now, behold, pay attention, see how a great forest, large amount of wood matter is kindled into an inferno by a small flame! 6 And the tongue is a fire, flame, the world of the unrighteousness, iniquity, injustice, poor judgement; the tongue is set among our members, parts, as that which stains, defiles the whole body and sets ablaze the wheel, course, perpetual direction of the life, and is set ablaze by Gehinnom[H]. 7 For every species of wild beasts and birds, of reptiles and creatures of the sea, is tamed, restrained and has been tamed, restrained by human beings. 8 But the tongue not one person can tame, restrain; a constantly unstable evil, full of deadly poison, rust. 9 With it we bless, praise the Lord, God and Father, and with it we curse people, who have been made in the likeness of God; 10 from the same mouth proceed blessing and cursing. My brothers and sisters, fellow Jews[1:1], these things should not be. 11 Does a spring produce out of the same opening sweet, fresh and bitter water? 12 Can a fig tree, My brothers and sisters, fellow Jews[1:1], bear olives, or a vine bear figs? So it is that no spring can yield both salt water and sweat, fresh water. 13 Who among you is wise and understanding, well learned, knowledgeable? Let him show by his good conversation his works, actions in a gentle disposition of wisdom. 14 And if you have bitter jealousy, envy, zeal and contention, selfish ambition in your hearts, do not rejoice and lie against the truth. 15 This kind of wisdom is not that which descends from above, but is earthly, sensual, demonic. 16 For where jealousy, envy, zeal and contention, selfish ambition exist, there is confusion, disorder and every kind of evil thing, work, practice. 17 But the wisdom from above is first pure/clear, then peace-filled, gentle/moderate/patient, reasonable/receptive/easy to entreat, full of mercy and good fruits, impartial/devoid of favouritism, free of hypocrisy. 18 And the fruit of righteousness, right action is sown in peace by those who make/do peace. Yaakov 3:1-18 (Line upon line) 1 Not many (polus[G], rabiym[H]) of you should seek to become teachers, masters, instructors with doctorates (didaskalos[G], lemoriym[H]), my brothers and sisters, fellow Jews[1:1] (adelphos mou[G], achay[H]), see, perceive, view to know (eidō[G], yad’tem[H]) that we who are teachers will receive (lambanō[G]) a greater, stricter (megas[G]) judgment (krima[G], hadiyn[H]). 2 For in many (polus[G]) ways all, absolutely (hapas[G]) stumble, fall, offend (ptaiō[G]). If any certain one (tis[G]) does not stumble in word, essence, substance (logos[G], bedibor[H]), he is a perfect, complete (teleios[G], mushlam[H]) man, person (aner[G], iysh[H]), strengthened (dunatos[G]) to bridle, rein in, direct, guide (chalinagōgeō[G]) the whole (holos[G], lechol[H]) body (soma[G], gufo[H]) as well (kai[G]). 1 Not many of you should seek to become teachers, masters, instructors with doctorates, my brothers and sisters, fellow Jews[1:1], see, perceive, view to know that we who are teachers will receive a greater, stricter judgment. 2 For in many ways all, absolutely stumble, fall, offend. If any certain one does not stumble in word, essence, substance, he is a perfect, complete man, person, strengthened to bridle, rein in, direct, guide the whole body as well. Simply put, if we take on the responsibility as rabbis, teachers, shepherds, of passing on the teaching of God’s word in Messiah, we must do so with considered accuracy. We must also accept that we will be assessed in a more detailed way. This warning is meant as a call to take care with the instruction we give to those who look to us for godly council. Everyone who teaches Scripture to others should pause to consider this first verse of Yaakov 3. Pause, consider the awesome God Who inspires all Scripture and then proceed to teach with fear and trembling. It has not been for a lack of access to Scripture that the body of believers has fallen into error but for a lack of sober judgement and awe in approaching interpretation. Yeshua said to the learned men of the first century “You are in error because you do not know the Scriptures or the power of God.” (Matt. 22:29). His hearers were the most well-read theologians of the time, many of them had learned the Scriptures verbatim from early childhood, and yet Yeshua says they “don’t know the Scriptures or the power of God”. They failed to properly comprehend the Scriptures because devoid of the Holy Spirit (Power, Strength) of God no one can understand the Ketuvim[H], Writings, Scriptures. Many among the body of believers who seek training as leaders and teachers today attend tertiary institutions that teach people to critique, stand in judgement over God’s Word and to question everything except their own evil motivations. These institutions cannot teach the power of God because the Ruach HaKodesh (Holy Spirit) is not taught but given. He is given of the Father and the Son and must either be received or rejected. He is the teacher. Those who reject Him in favour of pursuing fallen human intellectual understanding end in error. Thus, worldwide, the body of believers has been poisoned by false teachers, those who sit in judgement over Scripture rather than allowing themselves to be judged by Scripture. They lord their false understanding over uneducated communities, leading many astray. Their judgement will be great and the result terrifying. Those of us who teach Scripture have been given a sacred and terrifying responsibility. Anyone who does not teach the Scriptures with fear and trembling places both themselves and their hearers in grave danger. We note that there is a drash (comparative teaching) to be made between the words of Yaakov and the words of Yeshua. “The Power (Strength)” of God mentioned in Yeshua’s words is a reference to the manifest strength of the Ruach HaKodesh (Holy Spirit). The Greek dunamis meaning “strength, power, ability”. Yaakov says “If any certain one does not stumble in word, essence, substance, he is a perfect, complete man, person, strengthened to bridle, rein in, direct, guide the whole body as well.” Therefore, we understand that the unity of God’s Spirit and Word bears the fruit of self-control, the Spirit being the Director of a “complete” person’s entire body. Yeshua is the ultimate example to us of one Who “does not stumble in word, essence, substance, he is a perfect, complete man, person, strengthened to bridle, rein in, direct, guide the whole body as well.” With respect to the body of believers (Ecclesia[G]) over whom Yeshua is head, He is able to direct us so that we might be reined in when we walk to close to the edge of a cliff. 3 Now, behold, pay attention (idou[G], hineih[H]) we put the bits (chalinos[G]) into the horses’ (hasusiym[H]) mouths so that they will trust, be persuaded by (peithō[G]) us, we turn, direct (metagō[G]) their whole (holos[G]) body (soma[G], gufo[H]) as well (kai[G]). 4 Now, behold, pay attention, (idou[G], hineih[H]) Look at the ships (ploion[G]) too: though they are so large (gedolot[H]) and are driven by fierce winds (beruach azah[H]), they are turned, directed (metagō[G]) by a very small (elachistos[G]) rudder (pēdalion[G]) wherever the violent motion (hormē[G]) of the one who makes straight, governs, the pilot, (euthunō[G]) wills, determines (boulomai[G]). 3 Now, behold, pay attention we put the bits into the horses’ mouths so that they will trust, be persuaded by us, we turn, direct their whole body as well. 4 Now, behold, pay attention, look at the ships too: though they are so large and are driven by fierce winds, they are turned, directed by a very small rudder wherever the violent motion of the one who makes straight, governs, the pilot, wills, determines. The tongue is like a bit or a rudder, these tools are used by a rider and pilot respectively, neither of them in and of themselves are able to direct anything. The tongue is a neutral muscle until such a time as it is directed. The tongue, like a rudder, is small but powerful, with disproportionate control over the whole body. Like a rapidly spreading fire a small lie can destroy a nation. “You love all devouring words, you deceitful tongue.” -Psalm 52:4 “Where there is no wood, the fire goes out: so too where there is no talebearer, the strife ceases.” -Proverbs 26:20 We note that with regard to the analogy of the bit in the horses’ mouths, while “obey” is a valid translation of the Greek peithō, “trust, be persuaded” are equally valid. In the context of what Yaakov is saying and given the ship analogy that follows, “trust, persuaded by” is a better translation. The rider may at times yank hard on the reins, for example, when the horse is careening toward a cliff edge. It is because the horse trusts the rider that he responds to the guidance of the reins and when the horse is overwhelmed or frightened and runs aimlessly as a result, the fierce strength of the rider and the sharp, hard yanking on the reins brings the horse back into focus. Therefore, trust and discipline are being taught. When the Messiah follower loses his way and is headed for danger, Messiah yanks on the reins. It may be painful, but we trust that it is for our good. The ship rudder analogy affirms the meaning of the horse and bridle analogy. Using two analogies in succession like this reflects the ancient Hebrew poetic mechanism of repetition. The Greek text is sometimes euphemism in translation, and usually reads something like “directed by a small rudder whenever the will of the ship captain determines.” The context describes a very large ship blown by fierce winds and the Greek text describes the ship captain’s response in directing the rudder as being equally fierce “violent” hormē[G]. A better translations being “directed by a very small rudder wherever the violent motion of the one who makes straight, determines.” Therefore, the ship captain does more than “will” the change in direction, he makes a violent motion with the rudder in order to force the ship in the right direction and thus ensure the safety of the crew. This teaching of Yaakov first and foremost uses Yeshua as the primary example. Yeshua in one sense is the Rider, the Captain. We receive His bridle in trust and are directed accordingly, sometimes gently, sometimes forcefully, but always for our good. Likewise as Captain Yeshua directs us through the violent storms of life in the fallen world. At times this means that He violently pulls or pushes on the rudder in order to secure our spiritual safety and direct us in sanctification. Secondly, as disciples of Yeshua filled by His Spirit we are to participate in the bridling of our beings, the guiding of our bodies, and given the context, in particular, we are to rein in, direct, guide our speech. 5 Thus also the tongue (ho glōssa[G], halashon[H]) is a small (mikros[G]) member, part (melos[G]), and it boasts greatly (megalaucheō[G], gadol[H]). Now, behold, pay attention, see (idou[G], hineih[H]) how a great (hēlikos[G]) forest, large amount of wood matter (hulē[G]) is kindled (anaptō[G]) into an inferno by a small (oligos[G]) flame (pur[G], iesh[H])! 6 And the tongue (ho glōssa[G], halashon[H]) is a fire, flame, (pur[G], iesh[H]) the world (ho kosmos[G], haolam[H]) of the unrighteousness, iniquity, injustice, poor judgement (ho adikia[G]); the tongue (ho glōssa[G], halashon[H]) is set among (kathistēmi[G]) our member’s, parts, (melos[G]) as that which stains, defiles (spiloō[G]) the whole body (holos ho soma[G], et-kol-haguf[H]) and sets ablaze (phlogizō[G]) the wheel, course, perpetual direction (trochos[G]) of the life (ho genesis[G]), and is set ablaze (phlogizō[G], be’eish[H]) by Gehinnom[H] (geenna[G]). 5 Thus also the tongue is a small member, part, and it boasts greatly. Now, behold, pay attention, see how a great forest, large amount of wood matter is kindled into an inferno by a small flame! 6 And the tongue is a fire, flame, the world of the unrighteousness, iniquity, injustice, poor judgement; the tongue is set among our member’s, parts, as that which stains, defiles the whole body and sets ablaze the wheel, course, perpetual direction of the life, and is set ablaze by Gehinnom[H]. The specific tongue in question here is the tongue that gives in to temptation (as explained in chapter 1), and is therefore used to direct our entire being toward evil. Because the tongue speaks forth that which is in the heart its words are the evidence of things kept deep within. If our hearts (core being) are given over to wickedness then our words will perpetuate that wickedness and we will act accordingly. Yeshua warned that what comes out of a man’s mouth is what defiles him. (Matthew 15:19-20) One might say that in contrast to the Messiah, Whose tongue directs the body (Ecclesia, body of believers) toward perfection, our tongues have the potential to damage and defile the body (Ecclesia, body of believers). It's important to note that Gehinnom is spoken of as existing concurrently and as the ignition source for the corruptible fire that dances on the tongue when it is used by the yetzer ha-ra (evil inclination). Therefore the place to which Yaakov is referring (which, at that time was understood by the rabbi’s to be the holding place for the wicked, a section of sheol, Hebrew for underworld [not grave, the Hebrew for grave is Kever]), was believed to have existed for some time, probably having had its inception before the creation of humanity (that is after the fall of haSatan, the accuser). We should also remember that Jewish tradition speaks of the Torah descending like tongues of fire. There is a fire born of truth and a fire born of evil. Truth is a fire that cleanses all in its path, evil is a fire that scars, damages, defiles and destroys all in its path. Truth is so hot that it has the power to transform the fuel it consumes, evil is only hot enough to deform the fuel it uses. In the first century C.E. Geiy Ben Hinnom[H] “The valley of Hinnom” located close to the city of Jerusalem, was used as a valley of refuse, it was constantly burning. It was and is associated to the idolatrous worship of false gods and demons and the sacrificing of children. Thus, very early in the development of Biblical Judaism (prior to 400 B.C.E.) it became a metaphor for the perpetual torment of that part of Sheol (holding place of the departed, NOT the grave [kever[H]]) where the wicked await judgement. It was so firmly established as its own uniquely defined part of the afterlife that it was given a name by the rabbis of Judaism, “Gehinnom.” Yeshua understood and taught Gehinnom as a spiritual location following death where the departed wicked are tormented (Matt. 10:28; 2 Peter 2:4). Gehinnom is the prejudgement location of the wilfully unredeemed (Luke 16:19-31) whereas the lake of fire is the post judgement and eternal location of the wilfully unredeemed wicked (Matt. 13:42, 18:8, 25:41, 46; Mark 9:47-48; 2 Thess. 1:8-9; Rev. 19:20; 20:10-15; 21:8). Many false teachers and heretics seek to confuse believers by misusing these very different and unique terms (Sheol, Kever, Gehinnom, Gehenna, hell, hades, lake of fire, eternal torment etc.) in an attempt to disempower and reduce Gehinnom and the lake of fire to nothing more than metaphorical warnings devoid of eternal consequence. Those who teach that there is no eternal punishment for the unrepentant wicked are liars, children of Satan. Scripture explicitly teaches the very real and eternal consequences of a refusal to accept God’s redemptive offer in Yeshua the King Messiah. It is an outright lie to say, as some do, that Judaism holds no belief in hell. Our ancient rabbis teach prolifically on the subject of Gehinnom and in certain aspects of their theology are in agreement with the teaching of Yeshua. However, while many of our Talmudic rabbis rightly understand Gehinnom as a temporary place, they gravely misunderstand it to be a sort of purgatory intended to purify the wicked, it is not. Ironically this so called “Jewish” idea is born of the influence of Hellenistic paganism and is not based on Torah, Nevi’im, Ketuvim (Hebrew Scripture, OT). In short, Biblical Judaism informs and affirms the New Testament teaching concerning both Gehinnom (temporal) and the lake of fire (everlasting). “And Rabbi Elazar says: Any person who has flattery in him falls into Gehenna, as it is stated: “Woe to those who call evil good, and good evil” (Isaiah 5:20). What is written afterward? “Therefore, as the tongue of fire devours straw, and as the chaff is consumed by the flame” (Isaiah 5:24), meaning that the people described in the earlier verse will end up burning like straw in the fires of Gehenna.” -Sotah 41b, 14 Talmud, William Davidson Edition Regardless of the rabbinical Jewish view, we are not subject to it but to the Word of God. The Scripture teaches that at the resurrection all will rise and be judged and the wicked will be thrown into the lake of fire with Satan and his servants, their torment rising day and night forever (Rev. 20:10). Given that this takes place after the judgement, it cannot as some wrongly teach imply a temporal application of the phrasing “Day and night” or the term “forever”. There is no time in eternity. The question "Why would a loving God send people to eternal damnation?" presumes that eternal damnation is evidence of a lack of love, it is not. Evil is determined to propagate itself eternally. Therefore, the problem of evil requires a solution that is eternally effective. Being angry at God for coming up with that solution is itself an act of evil. Sadly, after decades of enlightenment we have learned to question everything except the motivation for our questions. Are we surprised then to find that our questions defeat themselves? We shake a fist at God, and accuse Him of injustice, and He says, "I see you're angry, you shake your fist at Me, I will open up My fist and nail it to a tree". God doesn't send people to eternal damnation. He offers those headed there salvation through the sacrificial substitutionary death of His Son the King Messiah Yeshua. 7 For every species of wild beasts (thērion[G]) and birds (peteinon[G]), of reptiles (herpeton[G]) and creatures of the sea (enalios[G], vehayam[H]), is tamed, restrained (damazō[G]) and has been tamed, restrained (damazō[G]) by human beings (anthrōpinos[G], ha’adam[H]). 8 But the tongue (ho glōssa[G], halashon[H]) not one person can tame, restrain (damazō[G]); a constantly unstable (akatastatos[G]) evil (kakos[G], lara’ah[H]), full (mestos[G]) of deadly poison, rust (ios thanatēphoros[G], chamat hamavet[H]). 7 For every species of wild beasts and birds, of reptiles and creatures of the sea, is tamed, restrained and has been tamed, restrained by human beings. 8 But the tongue not one person can tame, restrain; a constantly unstable evil, full of deadly poison, rust. As stated previously, no one can tame the tongue, that is, no one except the man mentioned in verse 2 (the man who does not stumble in anything He says but has power over all of His being). This of course is Messiah Yeshua. It is fallen humanity’s tongue “lashon hara” (tongue of evil) that is an evil thing, not the physical muscle but the physical muscle informed by the yetzer hara “evil inclination” and misused for evil purpose. 9 With it we bless, praise (eulogeō[G], nevareikh[H]) the Lord (ho kurios[G], Adon[H]), God (Theos[G], et-haElohiym[H]) and Father (pater[G], Avinu[H]), and with it we curse (kataraomai[G], nekaleil[H]) people (anthrōpinos[G], ha’anashiym[H]), who have been made in the likeness (homoiōsis[G], betzelem[H]) of God (Theos[G], Elohiym[H]); 10 from the same mouth (stoma[G], mipeh echad[H]) proceed (exerchomai[G]) blessing (eulogia[G], berachah[H]) and cursing (katara[G], ukalalah[H]). My brothers and sisters, fellow Jews[1:1] (adelphos mou[G], achay[H]), these things should not be. 9 With it we bless, praise the Lord, God and Father, and with it we curse people, who have been made in the likeness of God; 10 from the same mouth proceed blessing and cursing. My brothers and sisters, fellow Jews[1:1], these things should not be. Yaakov clarifies his position by identifying the motivation or intention behind the tongue’s use: firstly it is used correctly to bless God but incorrectly for cursing human beings made in God’s image. Therefore it is Messiah in us that steers the rudder of the tongue toward blessing and the evil inclination or fallen nature that is at work in the misuse of the tongue. The royal commandment or royal Torah mentioned in Chapter 2 of Yaakov’s book is here, reaffirmed as central to right action. One who blesses God with his tongue and then turns to his neighbour and curses him, has effectively blessed and cursed God in the same breathe. On the other hand, the one in whom the Son of God resides, calls out blessing with Messiah’s voice (and we cry Abba, through the spirit of son-ship) and from the same root turns and blesses his neighbour. This is born of Messiah, as opposed to the misuse of the tongue which is born of Gehinnom/ha-Satan when submitted to the evil inclination (yetzer hara). 11 Does a spring (pēgē[G], hamaeyan[H]) produce out of the same opening sweet, fresh (glukus[G], metukiym[H]) and bitter (pikros[G], umariym[H]) water? 12 Can a fig tree (sukē[G], hayuchal eitz[H]), My brothers and sisters, fellow Jews[1:1] (adelphos mou[G], achay[H]), bear olives (elaia[G], zeiytiym[H]), or a vine (ampelos[G], hatuchal hagefen[H]) bear figs (sukon[G], te’einiym[H])? So it is that (houtō[G]) no (oudeis[G]) spring (pēgē[G], maeyan[H]) can yield both (poieō[G]) salt (halukos[G], meluchiym[H]) water (hudōr [G]) and sweat, fresh water (glukus[G], umetukiym[H]). 13 Who among you is wise (Sophos[G], chacham[H]) and understanding, well learned, knowledgeable (epistēmōn[G], venavon[H])? Let him show (deiknuō[G]) by his good (kalos[G], hatovah[H]) conversation (anastrophē[G]) his works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asayv[H]) in a gentle disposition (prautēs[G], beanevat[H]) of wisdom (Sophia[G], hachachmah[H]). 11 Does a spring produce out of the same opening sweet, fresh and bitter water? 12 Can a fig tree, My brothers and sisters, fellow Jews[1:1], bear olives, or a vine bear figs? So it is that no spring can yield both salt water and sweat, fresh water. 13 Who among you is wise and understanding, well learned, knowledgeable? Let him show by his good conversation his works, actions in a gentle disposition of wisdom. With reference to the spring we are reminded that it is from the source that the spring produces either fresh or bitter water. The fresh spring is born of a pure source, some might say it is of the heavens, while the bitter spring is born of an unclean source (deep within the earth, a metaphor for Gehinnom). Our tongues must be guided by the pure life giving water of God’s Son, which comes from above. He guides us, we do not direct Him. With regard to the fruit analogy the believer is to be known by the appropriate healthy fruit. In the same way that it is contrary to the nature of a fig tree to bear olives, it is contrary to the nature of the born from above believer to bear false witness, lie, slander, curse that which is good etc. We note that good or godly conversation is considered right action. Yaakov affirms pure core faith that bears the fruit of our humble Messiah. 14 And if you have bitter (pikros[G], marah[H]) jealousy, envy, zeal (zēlos[G]) and contention, selfish ambition (eritheia[G]) in your hearts (kardia[G], bilevavechem[H]), do not rejoice (katakauchaomai[G], tithalalu[H]) and lie (pseudomai[G]) against the truth (alētheia[G], baemet[H]). 15 This kind of wisdom (Sophia[G], hachachmah[H]) is not that which descends (katerchomai[G]) from above (anōthen[G]), but is earthly (epigeios[G], hacheled[H]), sensual (psuchikos[G], vehayeitzer[H]), demonic (daimoniōdēs[G], vehasheidiym[H]). 14 And if you have bitter jealousy, envy, zeal and contention, selfish ambition in your hearts, do not rejoice and lie against the truth. 15 This kind of wisdom is not that which descends from above, but is earthly, sensual, demonic. If the source of your words is evil, don’t think you will be able to delude others by attempting to twist the truth with lies. Again, it is from a man’s heart (core being) that he speaks. Pretentious false wisdom doesn't come from God but from the convergent forces of the yetzer hara evil inclination and the demonic, be it by influence or possession. Much of the philosophy of Yaakov’s day seemed wise on the surface but was soon exposed as Gnostic, ungodly and deceptive. It is interesting to note that the Zohar refers to the wisdom of the Egyptians as Chochmah tata’ah “Wisdom from below”, inferior wisdom (Zohar 1:91b:3). 16 For where jealousy, envy, zeal (zēlos[G]) and contention, selfish ambition (eritheia[G]) exist, there is confusion, disorder (akatastasia[G]) and every kind (pas[G], vechol-ma’aseh[H]) of evil (phaulos[G], ra[H]) thing, work, practice (pragma[G]). 17 But the wisdom (Sophia[G], hachachmah[H]) from above (anōthen[G]) is first (prōton[G]) pure/clear (hagnos[G]), then peace-filled (eirēnikos[G], ohevet shalom[H]), gentle/moderate/patient (epieikēs[G]), reasonable/receptive/easy to entreat (eupeithēs[G]), full of mercy (eleos[G], rachamiym[H]) and good (agathos[G]) fruits (karpos[G], up’riy tov[H]), impartial/devoid of favouritism (adiakritos[G]), free of hypocrisy (anupokritos[G]). 18 And the fruit (karpos[G], up’riy [H]) of righteousness, right action (dikaiosunē[G], hatzedakah[H]) is sown (speirō[G]) in peace (eirēnē[G], beshalom[H]) by those who make/do (poieō[G], leoseiy[H]) peace (eirēnē[G], hashalom[H]). 16 For where jealousy, envy, zeal and contention, selfish ambition exist, there is confusion, disorder and every kind of evil thing, work, practice. 17 But the wisdom from above is first pure/clear, then peace-filled, gentle/moderate/patient, reasonable/receptive/easy to entreat, full of mercy and good fruits, impartial/devoid of favouritism, free of hypocrisy. 18 And the fruit of righteousness, right action is sown in peace by those who make/do peace. “You shall not go about as a talebearer: I say that, since all those who start quarrels and speak lashon hara go into homes to seek what evil they can see, or what evil things to tell in the marketplace,” -Rashi on Leviticus 19:16:1 Sefaria Community translation Selfish ambition is idolatry and when fuelled by jealousy it produces disharmony and abominable actions. Jealousy was the catalyst for Satan’s desire to usurp God’s authority. All sin is a form of idolatry and like Gehinnom it sets the tongue on fire. God is a God of symmetry and order, of harmony, unity and reconciliation. Satan on the other hand seeks to divide, taint, separate, defile and breed disharmony. The wisdom that comes from God is pure (like the freshwater of the previous analogy), peaceful, it doesn't seek to divide, it is kind, not nasty, listens to reason rather than jumping to conclusions. Therefore, the previous chapter’s admonition to be quick to listen, slow to anger and slow to speak. The wisdom from above prefers mercy over judgment (as alluded to in the previous chapter), thus it produces the fruit of mercy which is reconciliation and unity (the opposite of disharmony). Again Yaakov reminds his readers that hypocrisy and partiality are the fruit of a misused tongue and a jealous, self-glorifying heart (core being). Finally, the tongue that Messiah directs will be a platform for peaceful reconciliatory words that when sown into the lives of others will produce a harvest of right action both in the life of the speaker and in the lives of those who receive the Word. “Peace makers who sow in peace will reap a harvest of righteousness, right action.” Notice that the text doesn't say, “Peacemakers will reap a harvest of righteousness.” Simply being a peacemaker is not enough, anyone can, by their own inclination, attempt to make peace. This does not always produce a righteous outcome. The peace process in the Middle East is a perfect example of this. The Scriptures remind us that, “They dress the wound of my people as though it were not serious. ‘Peace, peace,’ they say, when there is no peace.” (Jeremiah 6:14) Only peacemakers who sow in Shalom, will reap a harvest of righteousness, that is, a truly peace-filled outcome. Peace Himself is the key here. The Peace we sow in is Messiah Yeshua, Sar Shalom—the Prince of Peace. © 2022 Yaakov Brown Concerning faith and right action: what God has made one, let no man separate. Yaakov 2:1-26 (Author’s convergent translation from Greek, Aramaic and Hebrew)
1 My brothers and sisters, fellow Jews [see 1:1], do not in partiality, favouritism, respect of persons hold the faith, belief, persuasion, trust in the Lord Yeshua Messiah the glory. 2 For if a person enters your synagogue wearing a gold ring, dressed in white, clean clothes, and a poor person, a beggar in shabby, dirty clothes also comes in, 3 and you gaze at the face of the one who is wearing the white, clean clothes, and say, “You sit here it’s a good spot,” and you say to the poor person, beggar, “You stand over there, or sit down by my footstool,” 4 Are you not then making separations, showing partiality among yourselves, and making yourselves judges with thoughts of evil, intentional harm? 5 Listen, hear, comprehend, understand my completely loved brothers and sisters, fellow Jews: did the God not select the poor, beggar of this world to be rich in faith, trust, persuasion, belief and heirs of the kingdom which He announced, promised to those who love Him completely, fully? 6 But you have despised, dishonoured the poor person. Is it not the rich who oppress, exercise harsh control over you and drag you before judgement seats? 7 Do they not blaspheme, speak evil of the good Name by which you have been called? 8 If, however, you are being filled with, the Kingly Torat/specific law/instruction according to the Writings/Scripture, “You shall love your neighbour as yourself, [Lev. 19:18]” you are doing good. 9 But if you show partiality, favouritism, you are committing sin, missing the mark set by God’s holiness and are rebuked, convicted by the Torah/Law as Torah/law breakers. 10 For whoever keeps, guards the entire Torah[H]/Law, yet stumbles, falls, offends in one, has become guilty, subject of all, individually and collectively. 11 For He who said, “Do not commit adultery,” also said, “Do not murder.” Now if you do not commit adultery, but do murder, you have made yourself a breaker of the Torah[H]/Law. 12 So speak, and so do, as those who are to be judged by the Torah[H]/law of freedom, liberty. 13 For judgment devoid of mercy will be shown to one who has shown no mercy; the mercy rejoices against, is glorious over, triumphs over, perpetually boasts against the judgment. 14 What does it profit, my brothers and sisters, fellow Jews if someone says he has faith, trust, belief, persuasion, but he has no works, actions? Can faith, trust, belief, persuasion save him? 15 If a brother or sister is naked and lacks daily food, bread 16 and any one of you says to them, “Go in peace, wholeness, wellbeing, be warmed and be filled,” yet you don’t give them the things they need for their body, what use is that? 17 In the same way, faith, trust, belief, persuasion also, if it has no works, actions, deeds is dead, necrotic being alone, separate, apart. 18 But someone might say, “You have faith and I have works, actions; show me your faith without the works, actions, and I will show you my faith by my works, actions.” 19 You believe that the God is one, well done; the demons also believe, and shudder, tremble, stiffen, are horrified. 20 Now are you willing to know, act on the knowledge, you vain, empty person, that faith, trust, belief, persuasion without works, actions is barren, dead, necrotic? 21 Was our father Avraham not justified by works, actions when he bore, led, offered up his son Yitzchak (Isaac) on the altar? 22 You see that faith, trust, belief, persuasion together with his works, actions, and as a result of the works, actions, faith, trust, belief, persuasion was made perfect, fully filled, made whole, well-constructed. 23 and the Scripture, TaNaKh, Hebrew Bible was fulfilled which says, “And Avraham believed, agreed with God, and it was counted to him as righteousness, charity, practical love, [Gen. 15:6]” and he was called a friend of God. 24 You see, perceive therefore, now truly that a person is justified by works, actions and not by faith alone. 25 In the same way, was Rachav the prostitute not justified by works, actions also when she allowed entry to the messengers, angels and sent them out by another way? 26 For just as the body without the spirit is dead, so also faith without works, actions is dead. Yaakov 2:1-26 (Line upon line) 1 My brothers and sisters, fellow Jews[see 1:1] (adelphos mou[G], achay[H]), do not (me[G]) in partiality, favouritism, respect of persons (prosōpolēpsias[G]) hold (echo[G]) the faith, belief, persuasion, trust (ho pistis[G], be’emunat[H]) in the Lord (ho kurios[G], Adoneinu[H]) Yeshua[H] (Iesous[G], Joshua, Jesus: YHVH Saves) Messiah (Christos[G], HaMashiyach[H], Anointed One) the glory (ho doxa[G]). 1 My brothers and sisters, fellow Jews [see 1:1], do not in partiality, favouritism, respect of persons hold the faith, belief, persuasion, trust in the Lord Yeshua[H] Messiah the glory. Put simply, “As Jews and followers of Yeshua, Who is God with us (Imanu El), the glory of God in us, don’t practice favouritism. In particular, show no favouritism when new people, Jews and Gentiles alike, come into your Messianic Jewish Synagogue.” (v.2-3) Yaakov continues to address the Messianic Jewish community of the first century Diaspora. He begins this portion with a reminder that halakhah (the way we walk) in Messiah is lit with Yeshua’s Glory. Therefore we are to walk as people who are aware of our own identity. We are Talmidim (students) of our Glorious Messiah, having been shown favour we are to reject the practice of favouritism. The key to right action, that is, present halakhah, is the very nature of Messiah Himself. The Jewish writer of the Book to the Hebrews gives us a beautiful glimpse into the vast glory of the Mashiyach (Messiah) when he writes: “Ha-Ben (the Son) is the radiance of HaShem’s (YHVH’s) glory and the exact representation of His being, sustaining all things by His powerful Davar (Word, Essence, Substance).” – Book to the Hebrews 1:3 (Author’s Translation) We further notice that the previous (1:17-18, 23-25) metaphor promoting reflected glory is alluded to by way of inference in the latter part of the first verse of the present chapter “Messiah the glory”. Yaakov is writing to Messiah following Jews living in Jewish communities throughout the known world. At this time (approx. 40 – 50 C.E.) they continued to worship in synagogues which were attended by a believing Jewish majority and by Gentile God fearers who prior to the coming of Yeshua and the Messianic Jewish faith were allowed to attend synagogue meetings only as standing guests at the open entry way to the synagogue. They could listen to and observe proceedings, but could not enter and sit among Jewish worshippers. Also at this time Jewish believers were still struggling with the idea that Gentiles could be included in the redemptive work of God (Acts 10:28). Therefore, riches and poverty were just one aspect of the problem of partiality (favouritism). In part there was a righteous motivation for excluding Gentiles, who were perceived to be pagans practicing lifestyles contrary to the Torah and therefore were a danger to the spiritual health of the Jewish community. However, Biblical Judaism has always taught Israel not to act with partiality. “17 You are not to recognize faces with partiality in judgment; you shall hear the small and the great alike. You are not to be afraid of any person, for the judgment is God’s…” -D’varim/Deuteronomy 1:17 2 For if a person (anēr[G], iysh[H]) enters your synagogue (synagoge[G], l’veiyt hakeneset[H]) wearing a gold ring (chrusodaktulios[G], zahav al yado[H]), dressed in white, clean (lampros[G]) clothes, and a poor person, a beggar (ptōchos[G]) in shabby, dirty (rhuparos[G]) clothes also comes in, 3 and you gaze at the face of (epiblepō[G], poniym[H]) the one who is wearing the white, clean (lampros[G]) clothes, and say, “You sit here it’s a good (kalōs[G], tava’at[H]) spot,” and you say to the poor person, beggar (ptōchos[G]), “You stand (histēmi[G]) over there, or sit down (kathēmai[G]) by my footstool (hupopodion[G], rag’lay[H]),” 2 For if a person enters your synagogue wearing a gold ring, dressed in white, clean clothes, and a poor person, a beggar in shabby, dirty clothes also comes in, 3 and you gaze at the face of the one who is wearing the white, clean clothes, and say, “You sit here it’s a good spot,” and you say to the poor person, beggar, “You stand over there, or sit down by my footstool,” The Greek synagoge appears 57 times in the HaBriyt HaChadashah “New Testament” and is only once used to describe a non-Jewish assembly (Rev. 2:9). It is therefore unacceptable that the majority of English translations of the present text render synagoge[G] as “assembly, gathering, meeting” etc. This clouds the meaning and is at its core an antisemitic translational choice. Translators have attempted to make this very Jewish book of Yaakov sound more universal by hiding Jewish specific terms beneath generic terminology. It is important to understand that this letter was being written to functioning Messianic synagogues throughout the Diaspora sometime between 40 and 50 C.E. That means that the Messiah following Jewish communities in question were predominantly Messianic Jews joined by a small number of Gentiles (unconverted observers of 1st Century Judaism), and that the Jewish majority continued to worship as Jews in a traditional Jewish way within the revelation of Messiah Yeshua. We note that in this scenario the beggar in shabby clothing is being assigned either a standing position at or outside the door to the synagogue, or a seat on the floor. The former was once reserved for the “God fearing” Gentile (unconverted observer of 1st Century Judaism) and the latter for the lower class of Jew. However, In Messiah not only were the lower class Jews elevated, the Gentiles were now welcome to enter and be seated within the believing Jewish community. Ancient Jewish law concerning the equal treatment of rich and poor alike in judiciary matters is sighted by Maimonides: "Two adversaries (in a dispute with each other), if one of them is clothed with precious garments, goodly apparel, and the other is clothed with, vile clothing, (the judge) says to the honorable (wealthy) person, ‘either clothe him (the poor person) as you are clothed, while you contend with him, or be clothed as he is, so that you may be alike, on an equal footing.’'' -Maimonides on Hilchot Sanhedrin, c. 21. sect. 2. Further, with regard to social position as it applied to matters of law Maimonides sites the Talmud Bavliy: "One shall not sit, and another stand, but both shall stand; but if the Sanhedrin, or court, are pleased to let them sit, they sit; but one does not sit above, and the other below; but one by the side of the other.'' - Maimonides ib. sect. 3. vid. Talmud Bavliy Shebuot, fol. 30. 1. 4 Are you not then making separations, showing partiality (diakrinō[G]) among yourselves, and making (ginomai[G]) yourselves judges (kritēs[G], shoftiym[H]) with thoughts (dialogismos[G]) of evil, intentional harm (ponēros[G], resha[H])? 5 Listen, hear, comprehend, understand (shimu[H]) my completely loved brothers and sisters, fellow Jews (adelphos agapētos[G], achay ahuvay[H]): did the God (ho Theos[G], Elohiym[H]) not select (eklegomai[G]) the poor, beggar (ptōchos[G]) of this world (kosmos toutou[G], haolam[H]) to be rich (plousios[G]) in faith, trust, persuasion, belief (pistis[G], Emunah[H]) and heirs (klēronomos[G]) of the kingdom (ho basileia[G], hamalchut[H]) which He announced, promised (epaggellō[G], hivtiyach[H]) to those who love Him completely, fully (ha agapaō autos[G], leohavayv[H])? 4 Are you not then making separations, showing partiality among yourselves, and making yourselves judges with thoughts of evil, intentional harm? 5 Listen, hear, comprehend, understand my completely loved brothers and sisters, fellow Jews: did the God not select the poor, beggar of this world to be rich in faith, trust, persuasion, belief and heirs of the kingdom which He announced, promised to those who love Him completely, fully? We note that it is not distinctions but separations among the Jewish believing community that are being addressed. The primary issue is wrong motivations (yetzer hara) and the passing of judgement based on outward appearances. Yeshua had commanded His disciples to stop judging by mere appearances and make right judgements (John 7:24). Yaakov is not instructing the Jewish believers not to judge but instead not to make false judgements. When we judge by appearances we are submitting our judgement to the sin affected reality of this temporary world, whereas when we judge according to God’s Spirit we are distinguishing between the temporal and the eternal and choosing the eternal (2 Cor. 4:18). Yaakov is reminding his fellow Messiah following dispersed countrymen that their understanding of what obedience to the Torah (Instruction) requires had always included just treatment of all people within the Jewish community. This is not a foreign practice to his readers, it had simply become a neglected one within the Jewish communities of the Diaspora. Why? Because they had adopted, or syncretised pagan Hellenistic practices. “Do not pervert justice or show partiality—undue favour for one over another. Do not accept a bribe, for a bribe blinds the eyes of the wise and twists the words of the innocent.” -D’varim/Deuteronomy 16:19 The real issue being addressed here is the motive of the human core (heart) that is the point from which all the parts of our being emanate rather than the heart in opposition to the mind. Perhaps money was needed for the running of the synagogue, the purchase of Torah scrolls etc.? Whatever the reason for showing favouritism, the Torah clearly instructs against the practice. “did the God not select the poor, beggar of this world to be rich in faith, trust, persuasion, belief…” We note that the text does not say “God chose the poor to be rich”, but “God chose the poor to be rich in faith.” The false Prosperity Gospel misses the point. What good are temporal riches that dull the faith of a person? God wills prosperity for the believer in Himself, but He does not will our temporal material prosperity except that it be utilised in the furthering of His Kingdom. “What good does it do a person to gain the entire world but loose his soul?” (Mk. 8:36; Matt. 16:26) The materially poor are rich in faith because they are devoid of the distraction of temporal riches. Those who are materially poor are inclined toward trusting God because they have nothing and no one but God to place their trust in. Therefore, material poverty can act as a vehicle for spiritual prosperity. “The meek will inherit the land and enjoy peace and prosperity.” - Tehillim/Psalm 37:11 “Blessing comes from God for the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of Heaven.” – Mattitiyahu/Matthew 5:3 As I have said, Yaakov admonishes his hearers to “Look not to what is seen but to what is unseen, for what is seen is temporary, but what is unseen is everlasting” (2 Cor. 4:18). In particular Yaakov is using phrasing that speaks to the 1st Century Jewish view of the Gentiles. He is employing specific terminology. For example ancient Jewish commentary refers to aniy Yisrael “the poor of Israel” as being distinct from aniy olam “the poor of the world”*. The “world” was seen as synonymous with “goyim” nations, pagans. Therefore, in one sense “the poor of this world” is understood by Yaakov’s hearers as referring to the Gentiles who are both poor in respect to physical wealth and in respect to spiritual health. This makes the teaching somewhat offensive to the early Jewish believers which is why Yaakov has prepared them by saying “Be quick to listen and slow to anger” (1:19-20). *Talmud Bavliy. Gittin, fol. 30. 1. & Bava Batra, fol. 10. 2. “The Kingdom which He promised to those who love Him fully.” The receiving of the Kingdom is simple, it is given to those who love Him fully. Do you love Him (God) fully, in Messiah? Then the Kingdom is given to you. Devoid of Messiah Yeshua we are all poor, lacking, dressed in filth. 6 But you have despised, dishonoured (atimazō[G]) the poor person (ptōchos[G]). Is it not the rich (plousios[G]) who oppress, exercise harsh control over (katadunasteuō[G]) you and drag (helkuō[G]) you before (eis[G]) judgement seats (kritērion[H], levateiy mishpat[H])? 7 Do they not blaspheme, speak evil of (blasphēmeō[G]) the good (kalos[G], hatovah[H]) name (onoma[G], HaShem[H]) by which you have been called (epikaleomai[G], hanikra aleiychem[H])? 6 But you have despised, dishonoured the poor person. Is it not the rich who oppress, exercise harsh control over you and drag you before judgement seats? 7 Do they not blaspheme, speak evil of the good name by which you have been called? Put concisely, don’t do to fellow believers of any ethnicity what is being done to you by non-believers. The foolish false choice posed by various Christian theologians, Hebrew Roots and Messianic writers asking “To Whom does ‘the good name’ refer?” is ludicrous. First because God is One and second because nothing could be further from Hebraic practice than a refusal to accept both interpretations as valid. Ultimatums are contrary to Biblical Hebrew thought. Scripture shines a light on cause and effect and God speaks clearly concerning action and consequence, practice and outcomes, whereas ultimatums are the domain of fallen humanity. The early Jewish believers were being taken to court on false charges by both rich Gentiles who hated them because of their association to YHVH, El Elohay Yisrael (the God of Israel v.5) and by rich rabbinical Jews who hated them due to their association with Yeshua HaMashiyach (Jesus the King Messiah v.1). So, in response to the false choice posed by Christian and Messianic Scholars alike “Which Name is being referred to, YHVH or Jesus?” we respond, “Yes!” “The good Name” is YHVH (v.5), Yeshua (v.1), Elohiym, El Elyon, El Shaddai, El Gibor, Adonay Yireh, Adonay Shalom, Sar shalom, Imanu-El… Adonay Eloheinu Adonay echad (God is One)! 8 If, however, you are being filled with (teleō[G]), the Kingly (basilikos[G], hamalchut[H]) Torat[H]/specific law/instruction (nomos[G]) according to the Writings/Scripture (graphe[G], Ketuvim/kakatuv[H]), “You shall love your neighbour as yourself, [Lev. 19:18]” you are doing good (kalōs[G], heiytavtem[H]). 9 But if you show partiality, favouritism (prosōpolēpteō[G]), you are committing (ergazomai[G]) sin, missing the mark set by God’s holiness (hamartia[G]) and are rebuked, convicted (elegchō[G]) by the Torah[H]/Law (ho nomos[G], haTorah[H]) as Torah/law breakers (parabatēs[G]). 8 If, however, you are being filled with, the Kingly Torat/specific law/instruction according to the Writings/Scripture, “You shall love your neighbour as yourself, [Lev. 19:18]” you are doing good. 9 But if you show partiality, favouritism, you are committing sin, missing the mark set by God’s holiness and are rebuked, convicted by the Torah/Law as Torah/law breakers. “If, however, you are being filled with, the Kingly Torat/specific law/instruction according to the Writings/Scripture” We must first take note of the specificity of Yaakov’s language regarding “law”. In this verse he speaks of a particular “Kingly” or “Royal” nomos[G]/torat[H] that is found in the fullness of the TaNaKh, or Ketuvim (Writings, Hebrew Bible). By quoting the very specific law (torat, a part of the Torah) “You shall love your neighbour as yourself” (Le. 19:18), Yaakov is passing on the teaching of His brother Yeshua the Messiah, Who summed up the Torah of Moses and the Prophets this way: 36 “Teacher, which is the great commandment in the Torah?” 37 And He said to him, “‘You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind.’ 38 This is the head and great commandment. 39 The second is like it, ‘You shall love your neighbour as yourself.’ 40 Upon these two commandments hang the entire Torah and hanevi’im.” -Mattitiyahu (Matthew) 22:36-40 Yaakov calls the summation of Yeshua’s teaching on the Torah and the Prophets the “Kingly Torah”, as distinct from the Torah of Moses. As I have explained previously, while aspects of the Torah of Moses are present as part of the whole of the “Kingly Torah, Torah Perfected, Torah of Freedom”, the clear distinctions made by both Yaakov and Rav Shaul, based on the teaching of Yeshua, mean that we cannot simplistically understand Torah in these verses to refer to the Torah of Moses except when it is clearly qualified as it is in verse 9 where the Greek reads “ho nomos” the Torah. In verses 8-9 Yaakov speaks to those Jews called in Yeshua to act in accordance with the Kingly Torah of Yeshua and to recognize their hypocrisy in the face of both the Kingly Torah and the Torah of Moses. Parts of the Torah of Moses will pass away, but nothing of the Kingly Torah of Yeshua will ever pass away. Yaakov’s audience is Jewish, when they hear “torat” they understand a singular aspect of the Torah, and when they hear the words “ha Torah” at the end of verse 9 they recognize the Torah of Moses. Yaakov then, is linking the Kingly Torah of God’s Messiah with the Torah of Moses while making a clear distinction between the two. Therefore the Kingly Torah as understood through the lens of the pivotal verse, “Love your neighbour as yourself,” thus creating a unity of belief and action born in the freedom of Messiah’s teaching. The point being that Yaakov is not inventing a new kind of Torah, he is revealing the Torah filled with Messiah and driven by the Ruach ha-Kodesh (Holy Spirit). As I have explained, there are parts of the Torah of Moses which will become obsolete at the point of final judgment and our entry into the Olam Haba (world to come), but as Messiah himself has said, “I tell you truly, until heaven and earth pass away not one minor or major mark will disappear from the Torah until all things are accomplished.” – Mattitiyahu/Matthew 5:18 “Zayit Ra’anan says… ‘The Holy One, blessed be He, says, “you sin in this world because the yetzer hara (evil inclination) governs you; but in the Olam haba (world to come), I will take it (yetzer ha-ra) away from you;” as it is said in Ezekiel 36:26 “I will take away the stony heart out of your flesh and give you a heart of flesh.”’” – Midrash Yalkut Shim’oni (medieval) When we abide in the Kingly Torah within Messiah we do well, recognizing the discipline and instruction of God. On the other hand, when we give in to the yetzer ha-ra “fallen inclination”, we cloud our ability to see the Kingly Torah (which brings liberty). When we wilfully break the Torah we deceive ourselves and are in danger of believing the lie that we are no longer secure. The irony here is that in showing favouritism we are endanger of believing that at some point we could lose God’s favour. Therefore, we must show others the favour that God has shown us in Messiah. “You shalt not avenge, nor bear any grudge against the children of your people (Israel), and you shall love your neighbour as yourself: I am YHVH.” -Leviticus 19:18 We note that “You shall love your neighbour as yourself” is the second clause in the commandment being quoted by Yaakov. The commandment begins by saying “You shalt not avenge, nor bear any grudge against the children of your people (Israel)”. Therefore, Yaakov is addressing the problem of early Jewish believers discriminating not only against the poor and bedraggled but also against Gentile believers. “Owe no person anything, but to love one another: for those who love one another have fully filled the Torah.” -Rav shaul: Letter to the Roman Believers 13:8 Those who are focused on the Messiah and as a result love others as themselves are fully filling the Torah of Moses, whereas those focused on attempting to fully observe the Torah of Moses are continually failing to do so. With regard to Torah there is no “try”, there is only “Do” and “Do not”. How much better then to request that God manifest Himself in me through Yeshua, than to seek to reach Him through the delusional claim of Torah observance. 10 For whoever keeps, guards (tēreō[G]) the entire (holos[G]) Torah[H]/Law (nomos[G]), yet stumbles, falls, offends (ptaiō[G]) in one (heis[G]), has become guilty, subject (enochos[G]) of all, individually and collectively (pas[G]). 11 For He who said, “Do not commit adultery,” also said, “Do not murder.” Now if you do not commit adultery, but do murder, you have made yourself (ginomai[G]) a breaker (parabatēs[G]) of the Torah[H]/Law (nomos[G]). 10 For whoever keeps, guards the entire Torah[H]/Law, yet stumbles, falls, offends in one, has become guilty, subject of all, individually and collectively. 11 For He who said, “Do not commit adultery,” also said, “Do not murder.” Now if you do not commit adultery, but do murder, you have made yourself a breaker of the Torah[H]/Law. Given the context this teaching says, “If you’re keeping most of the laws of the Torah but are breaking the Kingly law to love your neighbour as yourself, then the Torah exposes your guilt and you come under the judgement of the entire Torah.” Those who claim that Yaakov teaches Torah Observance are delusional. He is in fact teaching that Torah Observance (with the exception of Yeshua) is impossible. This is consistent with what Yaakov says in Acts 15. The early Jewish Fathers of the Body of believers agreed that Torah Observance was not incumbent on the Gentile believers. Those demanding that Gentile believers be circumcised were silenced by Rav Shaul (Paul), Yaakov, and Kefa (Peter). It is important to note that the two commandments mentioned here by Yaakov are to do with the love of one’s neighbour. It is often the case that as we journey with God we begin to become complacent. On a historical level the physical separation of the Messianic Jews in the Diaspora from the Jews of Israel was a living metaphor for their journey away from right action. When we become complacent in our faith we can fall into the trap of considering some commandments more important than others, thus we justify sinful action based on a sort of sin hierarchy where murder is bad but lusting after my neighbour’s wife is just what men are prone to do. Yaakov reminds his Jewish brothers and sisters that when we say to God, “I’ll keep most of your commandments but I don’t agree with this one, so I’ll just ignore it,” we are already guilty. As I have already stated, in more general terms Yaakov is teaching the one who says, “I am a Torah keeper” that such a statement is lie and thus breaks Torah. With the exception of Yeshua no one can claim to be a Torah keeper. I am obligated to add a further warning concerning a grave mis-teaching within the modern Messianic movement which makes Torah Observance an object of worship: Those who teach the lie "Obeying Torah is the fruit of salvation" mis-qualify both Torah and salvation. "Messiah is the goal of Torah" unto works of righteousness. Torah observance is not the goal, end, or fruit of Messiah. If it were, Messiah would be subject to Torah, but instead He is the Author and Goal of it. It is not Torah observance that is the fruit of the redeemed but right action. Ezekiel 36:26-27 explains that by the Spirit of Life (Holy Spirit) in Messiah Yeshua (Rom.8:2), we are empowered to act according to His (YHVH) prescribed (בְּקִרְבְּכֶם) way of living and according to His judgements (מִשְׁפָּטַי). Torah is not mentioned. Why? Because observance of the Torah of Moses is not the goal, end, or fruit. Thus we are "set free from the Torah of sin and death (the result of a failure to observe the unkeepable Mosaic Torah)" [Rom.8:2]. Peter (Rav Kefa) explains that no one can "bear" the "burden" of Torah observance (Acts 15:10). Yaakov (James) and the early Jewish Fathers of the body of faith along with Peter, agreed that therefore Gentile believers should not be taught Torah observance but to simply refrain from all forms of idolatry in accordance with the universally moral commandments of God (10 commandments minus Shabbat, which is a sign on ethnic Israel, the Jews [Ex.31:16-17]) Peter said this as a Spirit filled Messiah follower, not as an unsaved pre-Messianic Jew. Therefore, Peter and the early Jewish Fathers of the Body of believers agree that Torah observance is not the fruit of salvation. We add to this the teaching of Yeshua, Rav Shaul, and the Kohen (probably Barnabas) who wrote the Book to the Hebrews: Rom. 3:20; 4:14; 4:15; 5:20; 6:14; 7:1-13; 8:2-3, 1 Cor. 15:56, 2 Cor. 3:7; 3:9; 3:10; 3:12; 3:14-17, Gal. 2:16; 2:19; 2:21; 3:1;3:10; 3:11-12; 3:13; 3:16 & 19, (ref. Matt. 11:12-13, Luke 16:16), Gal. 3:21; 3:23; 4:24; Eph. 2:15, Phlp. 3:4-8; 1 Tim. 1:8 (Torah was made for the unrighteous, not for the righteous.) 1 Tim. 1:9-10; Heb. 7:18-19; 8:7-8; 8:13; 10:1. It is wrong to say that “Torah is done away with”, it is equally wrong to say that “Torah observance is the goal, end, fruit” or otherwise. When using "Torah" as a proper noun we speak in general terms that lack the nuisance of the wider definition. This is why the writers of the HaBrit HaChadashah (NT) often use qualifying terms in relationship to Torah (Instruction). "because through Messiah Yeshua the Torah* of the Spirit of life (Torah of Messiah) has set you free from the Torah* of sin and death. (Result of the failure to keep the unkeepable Torah of Moses)" -Romans 8:2 So called "Messianics" need to stop arguing over the keeping of days and the obeying of laws and return to the Person of Messiah Yeshua in God. No one will stand at the judgement and be able to use Torah observance as a means of redemption. If we claim to be Torah observant we make ourselves to be liars. As I have said, with regard to Torah there is no "try", there is “do” and “do not”. No human being (with the exception of the King Messiah) can keep the Torah perfectly. I do not keep the Torah, rather the Torah perfected of the Spirit of life keeps me in Messiah Yeshua. Those in the so called "Messianic" movement who claim to be Torah observant are lying. They are idolaters of the worst kind because in focusing on Torah they have turned their backs on the Author of it. It is for freedom that Messiah has set us free! *The word Torah must be qualified 12 So speak (laleō[G], davru[H]), and so do (poieō[G]), as those who are to be judged (krino[G]) by the Torah[H]/law (nomos[G], Torah[H]) of freedom, liberty (eleutheria[G], shel cheirut[H]). 13 For judgment (krisis[G], badiyn[H]) devoid of mercy (me eleos[G], eiyn rachamiym[H]) will be shown to one who has shown no mercy (me eleos[G], nahag rachamiym[H]); the mercy (eleos[G], harachamiym[H]) rejoices against, is glorious over, triumphs over, perpetually boasts against (katakauchaomai[G]) the judgment (krisis[G], hadiyn[H]). 14 What does it profit (ophelos[G]), my brothers and sisters, fellow Jews (mou adelphos[G], achay[H]) if someone says he has faith, trust, belief, persuasion (pistis[G], emunah[H]), but he has no works, actions (me ergon[G])? Can faith, trust, belief, persuasion (pistis[G], emunah[H]) save (sōzō[G], lehoshiyo[H]) him? 12 So speak, and so do, as those who are to be judged by the Torah[H]/law of freedom, liberty. 13 For judgment devoid of mercy will be shown to one who has shown no mercy; the mercy rejoices against, is glorious over, triumphs over, perpetually boasts against the judgment. 14 What does it profit, my brothers and sisters, fellow Jews if someone says he has faith, trust, belief, persuasion, but he has no works, actions? Can faith, trust, belief, persuasion save him? Yaakov admonishes his Jewish brothers and sisters who follow Messiah Yeshua to speak and act as those being judged, not by the Torah of Moses but by the Torah of Liberty. The wonderful result of accepting God’s mercy is that we will in turn show mercy to others, thus “Mercy triumphs over judgment” (that is mercy triumphs over a judgment of condemnation). Mercy triumphs in the judgment that brings discipline and freedom, thus we have the Torah of Messiah that brings Liberty. There are those who are uncomfortable with the plain Greek text saying “can faith save him?” They add to it translating “can that faith save him”. There is no need to add “that” to the text. One who is convinced that his faith need not be acted on does not accept the saving faith of Yeshua and therefore cannot be saved by faith. More to the point, faith cannot save, rather the Messiah Yeshua in Whom we place true faith, He is the Saviour. Thus Messiah in us outworks faith through us. We act righteously because we have received the nature of Messiah. Here Yaakov is speaking of a divisive faith, a faith that compartmentalizes life. The action of a pumping heart is the proof that a man is alive, when the heart ceases its action the body is dead. The predisposition of the Holy Spirit Who lives in us, is to help those in need, in order to fail to help the destitute we must first resist the Ruach ha-Kodesh, for a believer this is known as grieving (not blaspheming) the Spirit. The conclusion then is this, isolated faith is dead. In a believer however, the failure to act causes conviction of spirit and therefore revives the body. It is as if the heart has lost its rhythm temporarily for lack of vigour and then the Spirit pulls out the shock panels and gives us a jump start. 15 If a brother (adelphos[G], ach[H]) or sister (adelphē[G], achot[H]) is naked (gumnos[G]) and lacks (leipō[G]) daily (ephēmeros[G]) food, bread (lechem[H]) 16 and any one (tis[G]) of you says to them, “Go (hupagō[G]) in peace, wholeness, wellbeing (eirēnē[G], leshalom[H]), be warmed (thermainō[G]) and be filled (chortazō[G]),” yet you don’t give (didōmi[G]) them the things they need (epitēdeios[G]) for their body (sōma[G]), what use is that (ophelos[G], mah hoaltem[H])? 15 If a brother or sister is naked and lacks daily food, bread 16 and any one of you says to them, “Go in peace, wholeness, wellbeing, be warmed and be filled,” yet you don’t give them the things they need for their body, what use is that? “is naked and lacks daily bread” “Give us today our daily bread” is part of the formula of Tefilat haTalmidim “The Disciples Prayer” taught by Yeshua the King Messiah (Matt. 6:9-13). Here Yaakov reminds his hearers that in relationship through Messiah they are to participate in godly acts of provision. What fool, having prayed “Give us today our daily bread”, then sends his believing brother or sister away without bread for the day? “Go in peace, wholeness, wellbeing, be warmed and be filled,” yet you don’t give them the things they need for their body, what use is that? To wish a fellow believer, in this case a fellow Jewish believer “Peace, wholeness, and wellbeing”, knowing that they are distressed, incomplete, unwell, and having the means to give them peace, wholeness and wellbeing, is an abhorrent act of rebellion against the specific Kingly Torah command “You shall love your neighbour as yourself!” 17 In the same way, faith, trust, belief, persuasion (pistis[G], ha’emunah[H]) also, if it has no works, actions, deeds (ergon[G]) is dead, necrotic (nekros[G], meitah[H]) being alone, separate, apart (kata heautou[G], ). 18 But someone might say, “You have faith (pistis[G], emunah[H]) and I have works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]); show me your faith (pistis[G], emunah[H]) without the works, actions (ergon[G]), and I will show you my faith (pistis[G], emunah[H]) by my works, actions (ergon[G]).” 17 In the same way, faith, trust, belief, persuasion also, if it has no works, actions, deeds is dead, necrotic being alone, separate, apart. 18 But someone might say, “You have faith and I have works, actions; show me your faith without the works, actions and I will show you my faith by my works, actions.” Yaakov is not saying “I will show you my faith by my Torah observance”, a curse on that idea! The works, actions in question are right actions, otherwise known as righteousness. Yaakov is saying “The evidence of my faith is in the right actions that proceed from it”. It is not Torah observance that produces Yaakov’s right actions but faith in Messiah that produces them. This is a foundational doctrine of the Messianic Faith that has been abused by far too many so called “Messianic” teachers who promote the false doctrine of “Torah Observance” in contradiction of the teaching of Yaakov, Yochanan and Rav Shaul. The Hebraic back and forth of Yaakov’s work is a reflection of Yeshua’s teaching style, and is in turn reflected in Rav Shaul’s works. It was and remains a strong rabbinical technique that acts to expose flawed or self-defeating thinking (circular logic). Like a heart that doesn’t pump blood, faith without action is dead. The words, “faith by itself without right action is dead,” are a precursor to the final words of this portion of Yaakov. It is important to note that faith in unity with right action is life. The blood, the heart and the oxygen are all required in order to unify the living body. It’s as if Yaakov were saying “Show me life in a heart that doesn’t beat and I will show you life in my beating heart!” “Really?” Says Yaakov, with incredulity. “You’re able to exhibit faith without acting righteously? Okay, but I will exhibit faith by acting in unity with the Holy Spirit.” Faith, being unseen cannot be seen except in action. Therefore, the one who fails to act proves himself faithless. Faith devoid of right action is not only a corpse, it is a necrotic, stinking corpse. Ironically, faith without the evidence of right action produces a spiritual stench in the nostrils of the faithful. 19 You believe (pisteuō[G]) that the God (ho Theos[G], haElohiym[H]) is one (heis[G], echad[H]) well done (poieō kalōs[G]); the demons (ho daimonion[G], hasheidiym[H]) also believe (pisteuō[G]), and shudder, tremble, stiffen, are horrified (phrissō[G]). 20 Now (de[G]) are you willing to know, act on the knowledge (ginōskō[G]), you vain, empty (kenos[G]) person (anthrōpos[G], iysh[H]), that faith, trust, belief, persuasion (pistis[G], emunah[H]) without works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]) is barren, dead, necrotic (nekros[G], akarah[H])? 19 You believe that the God is one well done; the demons also believe, and shudder, tremble, stiffen, are horrified. 20 Now are you willing to know, act on the knowledge, you vain, empty person, that faith, trust, belief, persuasion without works, actions is barren, dead, necrotic? Many, lacking knowledge of ancient Biblical Jewish practice, and indeed of Jewish practice in general, fail to understand just how harsh these words of Yaakov are, even beyond their apparent abruptness. Yaakov is pulling out the big guns. One can see why prior to this he had instructed his hearers to be quick to listen and slow to anger (1:19-20). Yaakov is quite literally quoting the Shema in the present verse. “You say, ‘Shema (hear, listen, perceive and understand), Oh Israel, the LORD our God, the LORD is Echad (One, a unity).’ Be’seder, okay, good for you, so you recite the Shema three times a day, mazel tov (Congratulations)! The demons know the words of the Shema also, they believe that God is One, and it scares the crap out of them. You see, belief is subject to inclination. If your inclination is evil (yetzer ha-ra) then your belief is redundant. Further to the insult, the Greek kenos (empty, vain) interprets the Hebrew/Aramaic Raka, Reyka used in Matthew 5:22. This is yet another example of how context and motivation affect the interpretation and application of Scripture. Yeshua teaches that no one should call another by the term Raka from a motivation of willing death on them. However, in the context of Yaakov’s writing, describing a foolish person as a fool is a valid application of Biblical doctrine. 21 Was our father (Avinu[H]) Avraham[H] not justified (dikaioō[G]) by works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]) when he bore, lead, offered (anapherō[G]) up his son Yitzchak[H] (Isaac) on the altar (thusiastērion[G], haMizbeach[H])? 22 You see that faith, trust, belief, persuasion (pistis[G], haemunah[H]) together (sunergeō[G]) with his works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]), and as a result of the works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]), faith, trust, belief, persuasion (pistis[G], emunah[H]) was made perfect, fully filled, made whole, well-constructed (teleioō[G], hush’lemah[H]). 21 Was our father Avraham not justified by works, actions when he bore, led, offered up his son Yitzchak (Isaac) on the altar? 22 You see that faith, trust, belief, persuasion together with his works, actions, and as a result of the works, actions, faith, trust, belief, persuasion was made perfect, fully filled, made whole, well-constructed. Yaakov is not saying that Avraham was justified by actions alone but that his right actions were evidence of his faith and thus he was justified. This is affirmed by verse 22. Notice that Avraham’s actions were born of faith. Right action is the fruit of faith, the evidence of healthy roots, and just as a fruit tree is imperfect without fruit, so faith without right action is barren. Yaakov uses the word complete/full/perfect, here in unity with the word One/echad from the previous verses. He is showing that God, Who is One, Completes or makes One, faith and action. “In faith, trust, assurance, belief Avraham, when he was examined, proved, brought up Yitzchak [Isaac], and the one who had received the promises was offering up his only son;” -Hebrews 11:17 (Author’s translation) 23 and the Scripture, TaNaKh (Torah, Prophets, Writings), [Hebrew Bible] (ho graphē[G], hakatuv[H]) was fulfilled (plēroō[G]) which says, “And Avraham believed, agreed with (pisteuō[G], vayamein[H]) God (Theos[G], Elohiym[H]), and it was counted (logizomai[G]) to him as righteousness, charity, practical love (dikaiosunē[G], tzedakah[H]), [Gen. 15:6]” and he was called a friend (philos[G]) of God (Theos[G], Elohiym[H]). 24 You see, perceive (horaō[G]) therefore, now truly (toinun[G]) that a person is justified (dikaioō[G]) by works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]) and not by faith (pistis[G], emunah[H]) alone (monon[G]). 23 and the Scripture, TaNaKh, Hebrew Bible was fulfilled which says, “And Avraham believed, agreed with God, and it was counted to him as righteousness, charity, practical love, [Gen. 15:6]” and he was called a friend of God. 24 You see, perceive therefore, now truly that a person is justified by works, actions and not by faith alone. So, Avraham’s faith/belief/trust, was credited to him as right action. Now we see right action as the recompense/payment/credit/reward of right faith/trust/belief. The declaration of a man’s righteousness is made by those who observe his right action, while the right action itself is the declaration of right faith. 25 In the same way, was Rachav[H] the prostitute (pornē[G]) not justified (dikaioō[G]) by works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]) also when she allowed entry to (hupodechomai[G]) the messengers, angels (aggelos[G], malakhiym[H]) and sent them out by another way? 26 For just as the body (sōma[G], shehaguf[H]) without the spirit (pneuma[G], ruach[H]) is dead (nekros[G], meit[H]), so also faith (pistis[G], emunah[H]) without works, actions (ergon[G], ma’asiym[H]) is dead (nekros[G], meitah[H]). 25 In the same way, was Rachav the prostitute not justified by works, actions also when she allowed entry to the messengers, angels and sent them out by another way? 26 For just as the body without the spirit is dead, so also faith without works, actions is dead. “And Joshua the son of Nun sent out of Shittim two men to spy secretly, saying, Go view the land, even Jericho. And they went, and came into an harlot's house, named Rahab, and lodged there.” -Joshua 2:1 “By faith the harlot Rahab perished not with them that believed not, when she had received the spies with peace.” -Hebrews 11:31 It was Rahab’s faith in the God of Israel that motivated her to act to save her children and protect her family. She rightly believed that God was able to destroy the city of Jericho. Therefore her genuine faith bore the fruit of right action. Finally, “Just as the body without the spirit is dead, so to faith without right action is dead.” The spirit and faith correlate to one another and the body and action are also a pair. From this we can conclude that both these combinations (faith and works as well as spirit and body) become unclean when separated. To a Jew a dead body (according to the Torah) is unclean, so Yaakov is making a startling, even defiling insinuation. “If your faith lacks right action you are spiritually unclean and if your actions lack true faith then your actions are unclean. I know you’ve been living in the Diaspora among Greeks for some time now but don’t be misled by Greek philosophy,” says Yaakov, “they seek to divide and conquer, or have you forgotten that we Jews understand life as a unity, a functioning being of many parts, all interconnected. ‘Shema Yisrael, Adonai, Elohaynu, Adonai echad!’” “the body without the spirit is dead.” This is a known Jewish saying, recorded in Ohel Moed, fol. 15. 1. “Therefore we conclude that a person is justified by faith without the works of the Torah.” -Romans 3:28 When we place this teaching of Yaakov alongside that of Rav Shaul we see that Yaakov is emphasising the right action born of faith as being “works”. He is not saying that Torah observance is the right action but that right action is evidence of the Kingly Torah taught by Messiah, which is at work in the believer. Torah observance is motivated by human effort whereas right action results from relationship, that relationship being offered by God and received by the believer. Thus, Avraham first believed God and subsequently offered up his son Isaac. Note that the Torah was yet to be given to Israel at the point of Avraham’s belief and right action. Therefore, Avraham was not seeking to observe Torah but rather to respond to God in righteousness, thus Avraham’s unified faith in action was credited to him as righteousness. In Messiah Yeshua there is no separation of faith and works. There are faith-works and there is working-faith. When Shaul/Paul says, “You are saved by faith alone, and not by works, that no one might boast,” he is rebuking boasting (which is work without faith). We are better to understand Paul this way, “It is by faith unified that you are saved and not by works (deeds devoid of faith) so that no one should boast about having earned their own right standing with God.” Shaul is definitely not contradicting Yaakov, a man whose authority he both submitted to and respected. On the contrary, Shaul affirms Yaakov’s teaching. Of course this should come as no surprise, given that the Ruach ha-Kodesh inspired the words of both men. I will conclude this way, concerning faith and right action: what God has made one, let no man separate. © 2022 Yaakov Brown We note that the Greek threskos, commonly translated “religious” means to be “a trembling worshipper” and the equivalent Hebrew oveid Elohiym “a servant of God”. How ludicrous it is then to say as many modern Messiah followers do “I’m not religious, I have a personal relationship with God”. This is a statement of hubris, a false choice that pits like things against one another in order to elevate the status of the speaker. It is not religion but vain, defiled religion that is being addressed here. The following verse affirms this by explaining what “Pure and undefiled religion” is. Yaakov 1:16-27 (Author’s convergent translation from Greek, Aramaic and Hebrew)
16 Don’t wander, err, be deceived, my completely loved brothers and sisters. 17 Every good, complete, perfect, full thing given and every perfect gift is from above, descending from the Father of luminaries, lights, with Whom there is no fickleness, transmutation, no state of being in between phases of orbit, or revolving, turning, shadowing. 18 In exercising His will He birthed us in the Word, Essence, Substance, the Truth, so that we would be made a kind of first fruits among His creatures. 19 Wherefore, see, perceive [that which has just been said and that which is about to be said], my completely loved brothers and sisters. Let everyone, individually and collectively be quick to hear, listen, understand, slow to speak, and slow to wrath; 20 for a human being’s wrath does not bring about the righteousness of God, the Judge. 21 Therefore, put aside, lay off, rid yourselves individually and collectively of all filthiness, defilement and the abundance of, surplus (foreskin) of malice, wickedness, evil; and receive with gentle humility the inborn Word, Essence, Substance, which is able to save your soul life, mind, self, heart, core being. 22 For now be made doers, performers of the Word, Essence, Substance and not just hearers who deceive themselves. 23 Because if a certain one is a hearer of the Word, Essence, Substance and not a doer, performer, that person is like a man who looks, considers the face of his nature, his origin in a mirror; 24 for once he has looked at himself and gone away, he immediately forgets, loses from his mind what kind of person he was. 25 But one who bends over, stoops down to look intently into the Torah (law), perfected, complete, whole, the Torah of the freedom, and abides, stays in it, not becoming a hearer who intentionally forgets, puts from his mind, negligent, but is made an intentional doer, a toiler, this person will continue to be blessed, happy in what he does. 26 If a person thinks himself to be religious, a servant of God, yet doesn’t bridle, guide, direct his tongue but deceives his own heart, core being, this person’s religion, service to God is vain, worthless. 27 Pure, clean, clear and undefiled religion, service before the face of the God/Judge and Father is this: to visit the fatherless and widows in their distress, trouble, affliction and to keep one’s soul unspotted by this world. Yaakov 1:16-27 (Line upon line) 16 Don’t wander, err, be deceived (planaō[G], tit’u[H]), my completely loved brothers and sisters (adelphos agapētos[G], achay ahuvay[H]). 17 Every good, complete, perfect, full thing (agathos[G], tovah[H]) given and every perfect gift (dōrēma[G], matanah[H] ) is from above (anōthen[G], haorot[H]), descends (katabainō[G]) from the Father (ho patēr[G], Aviy[H]) of luminaries, lights (phōs[G]), with whom there is no fickleness, transmutation, no state of being in between phases of orbit (parallagē[G]), or revolving, turning (tropē[G]) shadowing (aposkiasma[G], choluf vekol-tzeil shinoy eiyn-imo[H]). 16 Don’t wander, err, be deceived, my completely loved brothers and sisters. 17 Every good, complete, perfect, full thing given and every perfect gift is from above, descending from the Father of luminaries, lights, with whom there is no fickleness, transmutation, no state of being in between phases of orbit, or revolving, turning, shadowing. “Don’t wander, err, be deceived” This is a warning to those who may be tempted (as described in v. 13-15). Wandering was the result of Israel’s decision to sin against God when He commanded Israel to enter the land of promise (Num. 13-14). The writer employees the same turn of phrase here making it a drash (comparative teaching) concerning entry into the Olam Haba “world to come” through the King Messiah (Yeshua: Joshua). In short, the writer is saying, “Don’t do what our ancestors did when they refused to go into the land”. To wander from intimate relationship with the Father is to place one’s self in jeopardy. “My completely loved brothers and sisters” In plain English, “My fellow Jewish believers, dearly loved in God”. “Every good thing” This includes the good inclination yetzer tov, all good comes from God and is in opposition to the temptation that seeds sin and births death (v.13-15). That which is good, complete, perfect, full, comes from El Elyon “the Supreme God”. HaShem the Father God and Creator of all things, including the orbiting lights of the heavens (Sun, moon etc.), which have been worshipped throughout the millennia by pagans, but are nonetheless subject to the God of Israel, He is the Supreme King over all things and is named here as “Father”. For those Jews who are in Messiah God is not only Creator of, and Ruler over all things, but is also Father, Abba (Daddy). Thus, the Spirit of the Son cries “Abba, Father” (Romans 8:15). Unlike the created lights of the heavens God is not subject to being in between phases of (orbit), nor is He revolving around anything or anyone. A light source doesn’t cause shadow. Shadow is caused by an object coming between the recipient of light and the light source. Thus, it is impossible for God to cast shadow (in a figurative sense) because “God is All Existing Light, and in Him there is no darkness”(1 John 1:5). Put concisely, unlike the sun, a created light source, nothing can come between the believer and God. This is why the Scripture says “Even the darkness is as light to You” (Ps. 139:12), meaning “nothing is hidden from You”. This is one of the many ways Scripture explains that “God is the same yesterday, today, and forever” (Ex. 3:14; Ps. 102:27, 103:17; Isa. 41:4, 44:6; Heb. 13:8; Rev. 1:8). Because He is holy and unchanging He is trustworthy. “descending from the Father of luminaries” Using “above” and “below” as a figures for “that which originates from God” verses “that which originates from fallen humanity”, Yaakov reminds his hearers of the transformative difference that receiving birth from above makes. The good that God gives, like His nature, does not waver, it is not indecisive like the action of the one who cannot receive wisdom (as described in v. 6-8). On the contrary, by His loving and gracious will God has given the ultimate gift, the gift that connects us again to Truth. He has imparted Himself, God with us (Imanu-El), ha-D’var Emet “the Word of Truth” (Yeshua) [John 1]. Truth Himself has brought us out of darkness into a place without transition or shadow through the “message of truth”. When we receive Yeshua we are no longer planets orbiting the Creator (the All Existing Light Source), rather, we have been made echad (one) in the Creator. We are not God, but we are united as sons and daughters born of His Spirit through the blood of Messiah. 18 In exercising His will (boulomai[G], vecheftzo[H]) He birthed us (apokueō[G], yalad[H]) in the Word, Essence, Substance (logos[G], bidvar[H]), the truth (alētheia[G], haemet[H]), so that we would be made (einai[G]) a kind of first fruits (aparchē[G], reishiyt bikureiy[H]) among His creatures (ktisma[G], yetzurayv[H]). 18 In exercising His will He birthed us in the Word, Essence, Substance, the Truth, so that we would be made a kind of first fruits among His creatures. There is no need to make the false choice between interpreting “the Word of truth” as referring to Messiah or to the Gospel message. The answer is that “the Word of truth” refers both to Messiah (Hadavar emet) and to His message. Yeshua being the Author and goal of the Gospel message. The Hebrew text reads “The Word, the Truth”. The first century Messianic Jews of both Eretz Yisrael and the Diaspora had been afforded the opportunity to be a first fruits offering (Shavuot[H], Pentecost[G])[Lev. 23:17; Acts 2] as a result of their having been birthed of God in the Word Himself (Yeshua). “16 For I am not ashamed of the good news, true message: it is the power of God for yeshua (salvation) to everyone who has faith, trust; continually to the Jew first and also continually to the Greek. 17 For in it the righteousness (the Righteous One) of God is revealed through faith for faith;” -Rav Shaul’s Letter to the Roman Believers 1:16-17 (Author’s translation) 19 Wherefore (hōste[G], al-kein[H]) see, perceive (eidō[G]) [that which has just been said and that which is about to be said], my completely loved brothers and sisters (adelphos agapētos[G], achay ahuvay[H]). Let everyone, individually and collectively (pas[G], kol-iysh[H]) be quick (tachus[G], mahiyr[H]) to hear, listen, understand (akouō[G], lish’moa[H]), slow (bradus[G], kasheh[H]) to speak (laleō[G], ledaveir[H]), and slow (bradus[G], vekasheh[H]) to wrath (orgē[G], lichos[H]); 20 for a human being’s (anēr[G], adam[H]) wrath (orgē[G], ka’as[H]) does not bring about the righteousness (dikaiosunē[G], tzidkat[H]) of God, the Judge (Theos[G], Elohiym[H]). 19 Wherefore, see, perceive [that which has just been said and that which is about to be said], my completely loved brothers and sisters. Let everyone, individually and collectively be quick to hear, listen, understand, slow to speak, and slow to wrath; 20 for a human being’s wrath does not bring about the righteousness of God, the Judge. “Be quick to hear” This doesn’t mean “be quick to listen to everything and everyone” rather it means “Be quick to listen to and receive that which is from above, from the Father of the luminaries”. Being quick to hear godly things is an idea found in the Talmud Bavliy (Gloss. in T. Bavliy. Megillah, fol. 21. 1. ). Numerous other ancient Jewish commentators teach that if a word is worth one shekel, silence is worth two. Silence is said to be the spice of speech, and the chief of all spices, the hedge of wisdom. The sage Shammay says, “say little, and do much” (Pirke Avot, c. 1. sect. 15. 17. & 3. 13. T. Bavliy. Megillah. fol. 18. 1. Vayikra Rabbah, sect. 16. fol. 158. 3. Midrash Kohelet, fol. 71. 1.). “be silent, and hear” -Talmud Bavliy Sanhedrin, fol. 7. 1. We note that the recipients of this work are admonished to be “slow to wrath”. Wrath is the progeny of anger. Godly wrath is enacted in righteousness as a just response to evil. In this case it is not anger itself, or even wrath itself that the recipients are being warned against but the anger/wrath born of the sin affected nature of human beings. This ungodly wrath is not good because it has not originated from above. Additionally, and as a general principle, it is in our nature to push for our own agenda in life. We often neglect the helpful conversation of others in order to pronounce our own knowledge. We are (in our fallen state) inclined to allow the temptation to promote our own point of view to give birth to the sin of rash words and when confronted in truth we respond in ungodly anger. Because we are filled with the Spirit of God, we must be tempered by the Instruction of God in this present world. In Messiah we are to instruct ourselves with these words and make a habit of choosing firstly to listen then respond with care and if challenged, to repeat the process so as not to allow fallen human anger to birth unrighteousness. “ I will therefore that men pray everywhere, lifting up holy hands, without (ungodly) wrath and doubting.” -Rav shaul 1 Timothy 2:8 KJV 21 Therefore (dio[G], lachein[H]), put aside, lay off, rid yourselves (apotithēmi[G]) individually and collectively of all (pas[G]) filthiness, defilement (rhuparia[G], tinuf[H]) and the abundance (perisseia[G], vetarbut[H]) surplus (foreskin) of malice, wickedness, evil (kakia[G], ra’ah[H]); and receive (dechomai[G], vekab’lu[H]) with gentle humility (prautēs[G], va’anavah[H]) the inborn (emphutos[G]) Word, Essence, Substance (logos[G], et-hadavar[H]), which is able (dunamai[G]) to save (sōzō[G], lehoshiya[H]) your (pl.) soul life, mind, self, heart, core being (psuchē[G], et-naf’shteiychem[H]). 21 Therefore, put aside, lay off, rid yourselves individually and collectively of all filthiness, defilement and the abundance of, surplus (foreskin) of malice, wickedness, evil; and receive with gentle humility the inborn Word, Essence, Substance, which is able to save your soul life, mind, self, heart, core being. The Jewish believer is instructed to intentionally put aside, cast off, strip himself of filthiness and the abundance of grudge holding malice and evil attached to the old way of life which is feed by the yetzer ha-ra (evil inclination, fallen nature). “Surplus of malice” This may be an allusion to the metaphor of the removal of foreskin used by Jeremiah to warn the people of Judah and Jerusalem to dedicate their hearts to God through the removal of their surplus of wickedness (foreskin). “Circumcise yourselves to YHVH, and remove the foreskins of your (collective) heart, core being, you men of Judah and inhabitants of Jerusalem: lest my fury come forth like fire, that burns so that nothing can quench it because of the evil of your doings.” Yermiyahu (Jeremiah) 4:4 The Targum paraphrases this same passage of Jeremiah as the “removal of the wickedness of your hearts”. Messiah in us propels us into action. No one can live a truly righteous existence devoid of Messiah, nor can anyone claiming to have received Messiah fail to act in the power of the Holy Spirit. This is pretext to the teaching that follows concerning the unified relationship of faith and action. Filthiness and wickedness are born of lust and pride, neither of which can receive anything (as explained in v. 6-8) because they compete within us and leave us undecided, we are then unable to choose the good. Humility, the act of recognizing our own spiritual poverty, is the only state in which we are capable of receiving the inborn Word, Essence, Substance (Yeshua), Who is able to save our entire being. This Word of truth is Messiah Himself, the very Essence, Author and Goal of the Torah/Instruction of God. “And that from a child you’ve known the holy Scriptures, which are able to make you wise unto salvation through faith which is in Messiah Yeshua.” -Rav shaul, 2 Timothy 3:15 22 For (de[G]) now be made (ginomai[G]) doers, performers (poiētēs[G], oseiy[H]) of the Word, Essence, Substance (logos[G], ha-davar[H]) and not just hearers (akroatēs[G]) who deceive (paralogizomai[G]) themselves. 23 Because (hoti[G]) if a certain one (tis[G], haiysh[H]) is a hearer (akroatēs[G]) of the Word, Essence, Substance (logos[G], ha-davar[H]) and not a doer, performer (poiētēs[G], oseihu[H]), that person is like a man who looks, considers (katanoeō[G]) the face (prosōpon[G]) of his nature, origin (genesis[G]) in a mirror (esoptron[G]); 22 For now be made doers, performers of the Word, Essence, Substance and not just hearers who deceive themselves. 23 Because if a certain one is a hearer of the Word, Essence, Substance and not a doer, performer, that person is like a man who looks, considers the face of his nature, his origin in a mirror; “Prove yourselves” is a poor translation of the Greek ginomai. In modern English the idea of proving one’s self denotes the work of the individual as the mechanism for proving. This is not what the text says. Rather it says “be made”. By necessity to “be made” requires a maker. In this case it is the “Word” received and the resulting “Salvation” of the previous verse that informs the present text. The Word is the Maker. Yeshua in us makes us “doers of the Word (Himself)”. Therefore, we read “Be made doers of the Word”. We are both from the Word and living examples of the Word in practice. “Being doers of the Word and not hearers only” This statement has been said to be contrary to the writing of Paul/Shaul and perhaps Yochanan/John. It is however consistent with the teachings of both writers and in addition it is likely a platform for their words, given that this book was likely written between 10 and 20 years prior to other New Testament writings. Yaakov is not saying that your actions save you, in fact he has just said prior to this that it is “the humble receiving of the Word/Messiah that saves you.” Yaakov is simply saying: “Don’t return again to the bondage of self-delusion. Let the inborn Word birth right action. Your actions will be the fruit of your new condition.” Only those who do not receive the Word of Truth with humility will find themselves in a situation where their actions prove them devoid of Truth. This is self-deception. Some believe, and I agree, that this letter of Yaakov was a favourite of Yochanan (John) and Rav Shaul (Paul the Apostle) prior to the writing of their works. “For it is not the hearers of the Torah who are justified before God, but the doers of the Torah shall be justified.” -Rav Shaul, Romans 2:13 “Study is not the most important thing, but actions; whoever indulges in too many words brings about sin.” -Rav Shimon, Perkei Avot 1:17 24 for once he has looked at (katanoeō[G]) himself and gone away, he immediately (eutheōs[G]) forgets, loses from his mind (epilanthanomai[G]) what kind (hopoios[G]) of person he was. 25 But one who bends over, stoops down to look intently (parakuptō[G]) into the Torah, law (nomos[G], batorah[H]), perfected, complete, whole (teleios[G], hash’leimah[H]), the Torah of the freedom (ho eleutheria[G], hacheirot[H]), and abides, stays in it (paramenō[G]), not becoming a hearer (akroatēs[G]) who intentionally forgets, puts from his mind, negligent (epilēsmonē[G]) but is made (ginomai[G]) an intentional doer (poiētēs[G], oseh[H]), a toiler (ergon[G]), this person will continue to be blessed, happy (makarios[G], ashreiy[H]) in what he does (poiēsis[G], bema’aseihu[H]). 24 for once he has looked at himself and gone away, he immediately forgets, loses from his mind what kind of person he was. 25 But one who bends over, stoops down to look intently into the Torah (law), perfected, complete, whole, the Torah of the freedom, and abides, stays in it, not becoming a hearer who intentionally forgets, puts from his mind, negligent but is made an intentional doer, a toiler, this person will continue to be blessed, happy in what he does. The mirror analogy is central to our understanding of this teaching. What kind of use of a mirror would cause a person to immediately forget what they looked like? The answer is, a fleeting use, a passing gaze, long enough to determine the basic outline of one’s features and nothing more. This is the kind of use that results in forgetting one’s self. On the other hand Yaakov suggests (as all great Hebrew poets might) that to gaze intently into the Torah completed (the Goal being Yeshua), the Torah of freedom, and to dwell in its reflection, continually responding to what we see, will bring blessing in all we do. The plain meaning compares the fickle nature of human recollection by sight with the failure to act in response to God’s Word. The remez (hint) at deeper meaning speaks to the nature of human beings. The reflection in the mirror is the natural face of the sin affected human being. Who, at his origin, chose to rebel against God. The one who looks at this reflection of himself and realizes that action must take place in order to show himself reborn unto righteousness, who then nonetheless walks away and immediately forgets his need, subsequently fails to act. Thus proving that he has not been reborn Why? Because he has looked at his sin nature in the mirror rather than looking at the perfected Torah (Instruction) of God which points to Yeshua, the One Who is both the means and strength of our faith in action. “one who bends over, stoops down to look intently”. We note that the reflection of the perfected Torah is one that must be “stooped down” to, “bent over” in order to view it. This denotes a reflective surface below or beside the viewer, a body of water perhaps, a mikveh. Additionally, where the one who looks at himself in the mirror is either holding it or viewing it upright in a position of pride, the one who looks into the perfected Torah must humble himself, stoop down, bend over in order to look into it. In short, change does not come about by looking at the reflected sin affected nature but by receiving the Living Word Yeshua and gazing intently into the “perfected Torah”, not the Torah of Moses, much of which will no longer be necessary in the Olam Haba (World to come) [Because there will be no sin and therefore no need for the negative commandments “Thou shalt not…”], but the “perfected” Torah (Instruction), the “Torah (Instruction) of the freedom” (found in Messiah), that is those parts of the word of God (including certain portions of the Torah of Moses) that are eternally present in Messiah Yeshua. This is why Yeshua says: “15 “If you love Me, you will keep My commandments. 16 I will ask the Father, and He will give you another [a]Helper, so that He may be with you forever; 17 the Helper is the Spirit of truth, Whom the world cannot receive, because it does not see Him or know Him; but you know Him because He remains with you and will be in you.” -John 14:15-17 NASB Rav shaul (Paul the Apostle) calls the “perfected Torah” the “Torah of Faith”. “Where is boasting then? It is excluded. By what Torah (Instruction, Law)? The law/Torah of works? Absolutely not, but by the Torah/Law of faith, trust.” -Romans 3:27 Properly qualifying the word Torah is essential in understanding what it means to gaze intently into the Torah of freedom in Messiah. Both the Greek nomos and the Hebrew Torah can mean “law” but do not always refer to the Law of Moses. Nor is the Greek nomos necessarily synonymous with the Torah, “Law of Moses” except when properly qualified. Torah[H] is a feminine noun meaning “Instruction”, whereas nomos[G] is a masculine noun meaning “law”. While instruction may include law it does not by necessity contain law. In the interpretation of the present text, and indeed, the texts of Rav Shaul, those who misuse the word Torah to always refer to the five books of Moses make themselves liars and false teachers. Many in the so called “Gentile Messianic, Hebrew Roots and Hyper Law” movements do this to their detriment. In looking intently it is our eyes that see/hear and the intention of our gaze that either neglects or accepts what we hear/see. When we gaze intently into a reflective surface we see not only our imperfections and flaws (causing us to seek a covering for them) but we also see our inherent value. The Complete Torah of Messiah reveals our sin for the purpose of covering it and shows us our worth so that we will not deceive ourselves into thinking we are worthless. The reflection of God’s Complete Instruction is one into which we should gaze intently until all is complete. Yeshua said, “Not one notation or mark will be removed from the Torah until all is fulfilled.” The reason for this is made clear here in Yaakov’s letter, we need the Torah as instruction in Messiah, it is a guide for those who have the Word (Messiah) born in us. No longer is it seen as the punitive Law of those who merely glance at it, rather for us it has become a reflection of our new nature. It is worth noting that the earlier allusion to the created heavenly lights, which include the sun and the moon which reflects the sun, connects to the analogy of the reflection of the perfected Torah in Messiah. In a figurative sense, just as the moon reflects the sun so too we reflect the all existing Light of God. We await the completion of all things, the day when all that exposes sin will evaporate from the Torah, leaving only that which is good. Messiah Himself the Word will be all that remains of the Torah. In the Olam Haba (World to come) we will return (tishuvah) to the state of Adam and Eve prior to the fall. We will again know only the good. Yetzer ha-tov (the good inclination), is the current indicator of a time yet to come when there will be no need to distinguish between good and evil, because there will be only good. In order for this to happen evil must be eternally encased in itself, this being eternal damnation (not temporary hell)[Rev. 20:14-15]. In the Olam haba we will have no need of a reflective surface that exposes our faults because in Messiah in God we will be without fault. Until then we have the Complete Torah of Truth as our present help and guide. The Complete Torah of Truth is the written Torah revealed in the Living Word Messiah Yeshua our King. We are reminded that we were not saved in order to become law breakers but so that in right relationship with God we might act out of His righteousness and thus be seen to be children of God through Messiah Yeshua our LORD (God with us) and King. 26 If a person (iysh[H]) thinks (yedameh[H]) himself to be religious, a servant of God (thrēskos[G], oveid Elohiym[H]), yet doesn’t bridle, guide, direct (chalinagōgeō[G], sam resen[H]) his tongue (glōssa[G], leshono[H]) but deceives (apataō[G]) his own heart, core being (kardia[G], levavo[H]), this person’s religion, service to God (thrēskeia[G], avodato[H]) is vain, worthless (mataios[G]). 26 If a person thinks himself to be religious, a servant of God, yet doesn’t bridle, guide, direct his tongue but deceives his own heart, core being, this person’s religion, service to God is vain, worthless. “To the chief Musician, to Jeduthun, A Psalm of David. I said, I will take heed to my ways, that I sin not with my tongue: I will keep my mouth with a bridle, while the wicked is before me.” -Psalm 39:1 KJV To “bridle” the tongue is not the same as “binding” the tongue. This is not an admonishment to be silent but rather an instruction to guide one’s words, in the same way a horse is directed by the bridle, bit, and reins. The bridle is pulled over the horses head and a bit placed in the mouth attached to reins that are used by the rider to direct the horse. To bridle one’s tongue means to employ the authority of the head and actively direct what comes out of the mouth. Wicked speech is evidence of a lack of self-control (a fruit of the Spirit)[Gal. 5:22-23]. We note that the Greek threskos, commonly translated “religious” means to be “a trembling worshipper” and the equivalent Hebrew oveid Elohiym “a servant of God”. How ludicrous it is then to say as many modern Messiah followers do “I’m not religious, I have a personal relationship with God”. This is a statement of hubris, a false choice that pits like things against one another in order to elevate the status of the speaker. It is not religion but vain, defiled religion that is being addressed here. The following verse affirms this by explaining what “Pure and undefiled religion” is. By misusing the word religion we become the vain spiritual practitioners we accuse others of being. When we translate the correct meaning of the word religion the statement “I’m not religious, I have a personal relationship with God” becomes “I am not a servant of God, I have a personal relationship with Him”. A glaring contradiction, an example of self-defeating logic, self-destructive thinking. A Messiah follower who walks rightly before God can say with confidence “I am in a relationship with God and because of this I practice pure and undefiled religion.” Consider this, Yeshua was religious, and if it could be said of Him that He was not religious then He would not have been the promised Messiah of Israel. 27 Pure, clean, clear (katharos[G]) and undefiled (amiantos[G]) religion, service (thrēskeia[G], ha’avodah[H]) before the face (para[G], lifneiy[H]) of the God/Judge (Theos[G], haElohiym[H]) and Father (patēr[G], Aviynu[H]) is this: to visit (episkeptomai[G]) the fatherless (orphanos[G]) and widows (chēra[G]) in their distress, trouble, affliction (thlipsis[G]) and to keep one’s soul unspotted (aspilos[G], nafsho[H]) by this world (ho kosmos[G], haolam[H]). 27 Pure, clean, clear and undefiled religion, service before the face of the God/the Judge and Father is this: to visit the fatherless and widows in their distress, trouble, affliction and to keep one’s soul unspotted by this world. Note that God is the Father of the fatherless, so that when we visit the fatherless we are reflecting the Father heart of God, Who places the lonely in families (Ps. 68:6). Three central Jewish spiritual teachings are alluded to in verses 26 and 27: Firstly, ancient Biblical Judaism did not have a word for theology prior to the Hellenization of Israel by the Greeks. This means that Judaism always taught faith in action rather than the use of the mind alone to philosophize over God concepts. A Jew cannot separate godly concepts from godly actions: the centre of the Jew, being the heart, is not to be understood as the heart devoid of the mind, rather it is the intersection of all parts of the being made echad (one). Therefore hypocrisy is anti-Jewish, anti-God and anti-Messiah. One who thinks (that is theologizes, talks of God consciousness but does not birth it) that he is righteous, but doesn’t keep his tongue in check, deludes himself and his religion is worthless. Again, this affirms Yaakov’s previous warning not to allow lust to give way to temptation, sin and death. Our idle words are worthless, on the other hand our worthwhile actions are the very words of life. Secondly, Yaakov reminds us that religion is not the problem, we are. He is reminding Jews in the diaspora to maintain a pure observance of the perfected Torah in Messiah. He is not saying that observance brings salvation (he has already said that humbly receiving the implanted word brings salvation) on the contrary, he is calling the Jewish diaspora to return to their true identity as Jews in Messiah. Many lived in nations that worshipped false deities, practicing abominations against God on a daily basis. Yaakov reminds his fellow Jews of their worth as God’s chosen people. Thirdly, Yaakov asks that his Jewish brothers and sisters keep themselves separate from the pagan practices that surround them. The Torah gives specific instructions for the care of Israel’s widows, her poor, her orphans and the foreigner living among her. Yaakov is calling the Jews of the diaspora back to these guidelines as a starting point for the all-encompassing loving action of the Gospel as defined as perfected Torah. From the beginning God has asked Israel to be separate, called out ones, set apart, which is the very essence of what it means to be Holy. Here Yaakov reiterates this well-known Torah concept, connecting it to the “unspotted” sacrificial Lamb of God, the Mashiyach (Messiah). In doing so he endears himself to both Messianic and non-Messianic Jews alike. Honouring the tradition of ancient Judaism and belief in Messiah, he then goes on to fill it with hope for the future. That hope is born in Mashiyach, the one we had long awaited. We, like Yeshua, are called to be “unspotted” living sacrifices, holy and acceptable to God (Lev. 22:21; Num. 19:2; Romans 12:1; Eph. 5:27; Col. 1:22; 1 Pet. 1:19; ). The first chapter of Yaakov begins a book of unified spiritual-physical reality. We will see throughout this book the three concepts of shamor (observance) v’zakhor, (remembrance) v’halakhah (and action). These concepts are a unity (echad), they are not able to function properly outside of their connected circle of existence. The Word of life (Messiah) in us, reminds (zakhor) us to observe (shamor), in turn our observance (shamor) causes us to remember (zakhor) what God has done, what He is doing, and what He will do. By our observance and our remembering we give birth to action. This is Halakhah, the way we walk. There is no longer room for theology (thinking about God devoid of living in Him), because the life we now live in Messiah is a life beyond theology and its limitations. We are worthy because we have worth. God has set the measure of our value in the life of His Son Yeshua before the foundation of the world. You are loved with an everlasting love. “Therefore, I urge you fellow Jewish brothers and sisters through the mercies, compassion, emotions of the God, that you all present your bodies as a living, breathing sacrifice, holy, pleasing, acceptable to the God, this is your reasonable, logical service (religious practice).” -Rav Shaul (Paul the Apostle), Letter to the Roman Body of Believers 12:1 (Author’s Translation) Copyright 2022 Yaakov Brown Chronological thinking is temporal, but in Messiah there is a transcendent way of being that refuses to be bound by time and space. There is no time in eternity. Time is the prison of the death bound. But we serve the God of the living, the God of Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov... Let’s Begin at the beginning:
Most of us Jews don’t know what you mean when you say “Pentecost”? Nor does our understanding of Shavuot (Pentecost) begin in Acts chapter 2. To begin a race at the half way marker is to misunderstand the purpose, goal and reward of the race. What’s more, for the Messiah following, God honouring, Biblically observant Jew there is no finish line, there are only new beginnings. Understanding the Goal from the Beginning: How can we understand the goal if we don't understand the beginning? Furthermore, how can we understand the beginning if we don't understand that the All Existing Goal [YHVH] is the Creator of all beginning, and that Messiah Yeshua is both the Author and the Goal of the Torah (Rom.10:4)? Chronological thinking is temporal, but in Messiah there is a transcendent way of being that refuses to be bound by time and space. There is no time in eternity. Time is the prison of the death bound. But we serve the God of the living, the God of Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov (Mark 12:26-27; Luke 20:37-38). Yeshua says: “26Now, pay attention, concerning the rising of the dead—haven’t you read in the Book of Moshe (the drawn out, ressurected one), in the account of the burning bush, how YHVH said to him, ‘I am the Elohiym of Avraham (Father of a great people), the Elohiym of Yitzak (He laughs) and the Elohiym of Yaakov (Follower)’? [Ex. 3:6] 27 He is not the Elohiym of the dead, but of the living. You are badly mistaken!”- Mark 12:26-27 (Author’s translation) With these things in mind let’s take a closer look at the festival of Shavuot. Shavuot is a Festival of Many Names: Zeman Mattan Torateinu [Season of the giving of our Torah] (Exodus 19:1-2) Chag Ha-Katzir [The Feast of Harvest] (Exodus 23:14-16) Chag Ha-Shavuot [The Feast of weeks] (Leviticus 23:15-16, Deuteronomy 16:9-17) Yom Ha-Bikkuriym [The Festival Day of First Fruits] (Numbers 28:26) Atzeret shel Pesach [Conclusion of Passover] (Talmud ibid) Pentecost [Pente = 50] (Acts 2:1-40) Let’s take a look at each of the names for Shavuot, their origin and significance. 1.)Season of the Giving of the Torah Zeman Mattan Torateinu 1300 BCE (approx.) * Shemot (Exodus) 19:1-2 “In the third month (Sivan) after the Bnei-Yisrael (Children of Israel) had gone out of the land of Mitzrayim (Egypt: Double distress), that same day they arrived at the wilderness of Sinaiy (Thorny). They travelled from R'phiydiym (Resting places, places of support) came into to the wilderness of Sinaiy (Thorny), and set up camp in the wilderness. Yisrael (Overcomes in God) camped there, right in front of the mountain (Mt Sinai).” *We note that when the festival of Shavuot was given (at Sinai), Israel had neither land nor harvest. Therefore, its significance both precedes and reaches beyond harvest alone, and finds its inception in the giving of the Torah. At the Giving of the Torah there was Fire on the Mountain Shemot (Exodus) 19:18 “Now the entire Mount Sinai was in smoke, because Adonai had descended upon it in fire. The smoke ascended like the smoke of a furnace. The whole mountain quaked greatly.” Shemot (Exodus) 20:18-19 “18 All the people witnessed the thundering and the lightning, and the sound of the shofar, and the mountain smoking. When the people saw it, they trembled and stood far off. 19 So they said to Moses, “You, speak to us, and we will listen, but do not let God speak to us, or we will die.”” At the Giving of the Torah Seventy Elders of Israel were Touched by Fire from the Heavens Jewish tradition teaches that flames of fire descended upon the seventy elders of Israel at Sinai during the giving of the Torah. Bamidbar (Numbers) 11:16-17 TLV ‘Adonai said to Moses, “Bring me 70* of the elders of Israel whom you know to be elders of the people and their leaders. Take them to the Tent of Meeting, so they may stand with you there. 17 Then I will come down and speak with you there, and, I will take some of the Ruach (Spirit) that is on you and will place it on them. They will carry with you the burden of the people, so you will not be carrying it alone”’ *In both Biblical and rabbinical Judaism the number 70 represents the nations (Gen. 10). Thus, the people of Israel, having received the Torah by fire, were tasked to be a light to the nations. At the Giving of the Torah Fiery Light Beam Horns Appeared on the Head of Moses Moses is sometimes depicted with horns, and at other times with light beams emanating from his head following his receipt of the ten commandments (Exodus 34:29-35). The Hebrew karan can be translated as either horns or beams of light. The best understanding of this is found by holding the meaning in the tension, embracing the seemingly divergent concept and accepting that both translations are a convergent whole. Horns symbolize strength, and light the present manifestation of God’s glory. Therefore, Moses reflected God’s strength and glory according to the presence of God’s Spirit upon him. This glory manifest upon Moses’ head as a symbol of God’s authority over Moses, who had been given authority to guide the people of Israel. The traditional Torah text itself is sometimes called the “Fire text” due to the threefold flicks of the pen above certain characters. 2.)Feast of Harvest Chag Ha-Katzir Shemot (Exodus) 23:14-16 “Three times in the year you are to celebrate a festival for Me. You are to observe the Feast of Matzot. For seven days you will eat matzot as I commanded you, at the time appointed in the month Aviv, for that is when you came out from Egypt. No one is to appear before Me empty-handed. Also you are to observe the Feast of Harvest, the first fruits of your labours that you sow in the field, as well as the Feast of the Ingathering at the end of the year, when you gather your crops from the field. 3.)Feast of weeks Chag Ha-Shavuot Vayikra (Leviticus) 23:15-16 “Then you are to count from the day after the Shabbat (Of Passover), from the day that you brought the omer (A measure of barley flour) of the wave offering, seven complete Shabbatot (Sabbaths). Until the day after the seventh Shabbat (7x7+1) you are to count fifty days, and then present a new grain offering to Adonai.” 4.)First Fruits Yom Ha-Bikkuriym Bamidbar (Numbers) 28:26 “On the Day of First-fruits, when you offer to Adonai a new grain offering during the Feast of Weeks, you are to have a sacred assembly. You are to do no laborious work.” The day described here as taking place during Shavuot is to be understood as a unique occasion from the day of first fruits that occurs at the inception of the counting of the omer seven weeks prior to Shavuot. Both days are known by the title Yom Ha-bikkurim despite the fact that they occur seven weeks apart. Two Leavened Loaves Vayikra (Leviticus) 23:17 (TLV) “You are to bring out of your houses two loaves of bread for a wave offering, made of two tenths of an ephah of fine flour. They are to be baked with chameitz (yeast) as first fruits to Adonai.” The Wave Offering of Two Leavened Loaves Vayikra (Leviticus ) 23:17 Yeast may not come into contact with the altar of HaShem because yeast is a physical symbol of the festering presence of sin in the present world. This makes the Shavuot wave offering exceptional. Two loaves are made with yeast and waved before God in gratitude for the harvest and in petition for an abundant future harvest. However, they are not brought near nor are they offered on the altar. Why two loaves, and why are they made with yeast? This is connected to the 70 elders of Sinai. Shavuot celebrates God’s abundant blessing to an undeserving and sinful people, a people tasked with bringing the message of God’s goodness to the nations. Therefore, there are two loaves made with yeast (sin) representing two peoples, Ha-Y’hudiym (the Jews) and Ha-Goyim (the nations). 5.) Completion (Fullness) of Passover Atzeret Shel Pesach Our Rabbis base this on the fact that the day of Shavuot is decided by beginning to count from the conclusion of Passover. Vayikra (Leviticus) 23:15-16 “Then you are to count from the day after the Shabbat (Of Passover), from the day that you brought the omer (A measure of barley flour) of the wave offering, seven complete Shabbatot (Sabbaths). Until the day after the seventh Shabbat (7x7+1) you are to count fifty days, and then present a new grain offering to Adonai.” With respect to Messianic understanding this reflects the fact that the completed work of Yeshua means the filling of the believer with the promised Ruach HaKodesh (Holy Spirit). Therefore, the outpouring and infilling of the Holy Spirit is a type of completion of the work of Passover. 6.) Pentecost 50 (Jubilee) Pentecost is the English transliteration borrowed from the Greek Pentecoste, which is formed from the root Pente meaning 50. The number fifty is symbolic in Biblical Judaism of a season of Jubilee*. This is a season of freedom from all that causes bondage both spiritual and physical. *Ha-Yovel (the Jubilee [50]) is the year that renews the cycle of the regular seventh year of shemitot (Sabbatical years) the Book of Vayikra (Leviticus) [Lev. 25:8-13] decrees of God that Hebrew (Jewish) slaves and prisoners are to be set free, debts are to be forgiven, and as a result of the obedience of the people of Israel to these instructions YHVH the God of Israel will manifest His mercy in a tangible and transcendent way. Traditional Readings for Shavuot: In addition to the Torah prescription for Shavuot: (Ex. 23:16, 34:22; Dt. 16:9-12; Num. 28:26-31; Lev. 23:15-21) Observant Jews also read: Ezekiel 1:1-28; 3:12 Habakkuk 2:20-3:19 Megillat (Scroll) of Ruth The Fullness of Scripture and its Connection to Shavuot: Fire from the Heavens is an Intrinsic Element in the Events of Shavuot Acts 2:1-4 “When the day of Shavuot had come, they were all together in one place. Suddenly there came from heaven a sound like a mighty rushing wind, and it filled the whole house where they were sitting. And tongues like fire spreading out appeared to them and settled on each one of them. They were all filled with the Ruach ha-Kodesh (Holy Spirit) and began to speak in other tongues as the Ruach (Spirit) enabled them to speak out.” Yechezkel (Ezekiel) 1:4 “I looked, and behold, a storm ruach wind (Spirit, breath) came from the north, a great cloud with flashing fire and brightness all around it, and something like a glowing alloy out of the fire.” Chabakuk (Habakkuk) 3:3-5 “God comes from Teman, and the Holy One from Mount Paran. Selah… His majesty covers the heavens, and His praise fills the earth. With brilliance like light, rays emanate from His hand. There His power was hidden. Pestilence goes before Him, a fiery bolt goes forth at His feet.” Yechezkel (Ezekiel) 36:25-27 “Then I will sprinkle abundantly, clean water on you and you will be clean from all your uncleanness and from all your idols. Moreover I will give you a new heart. I will put a new spirit within you. I will remove the stony heart from your body and give you a heart of flesh. I will put My Ruach (Spirit) within you. Then I will cause you to walk in My laws, so you will keep My rulings and do them.” Yermiyahu (Jeremiah) 31:30-33 “Behold, days are coming” —it is a declaration of Adonai— “when I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel and with the house of Judah— 31 not like the covenant I made with their fathers in the day I took them by the hand to bring them out of the land of Egypt. For they broke My covenant, though I was a husband to them.” it is a declaration of Adonai. 32 “But this is the covenant I will make with the house of Israel after those days” —it is a declaration of Adonai— “I will put My Torah within them. Yes, I will write it on their heart. I will be their God and they will be My people. 33 No longer will each teach his neighbour or each his brother, saying: ‘Know Adonai,’ for they will all know Me, from the least of them to the greatest.” it is a declaration of Adonai. “For I will forgive their iniquity, their sin I will remember no more.” So, why so much fire? Fire at Sinai, fire in Jerusalem, fire on the heads of God's chosen people: l Fire is the root אשׁ (Eish) of Man איש (Iysh), breathed into the earth to create humanity l Fire is a reminder of the everlasting nature of the human soul from conception l Fire consumes that which is dead and transforms it into light l Fire warms the righteous and burns the wicked l Fire is a living symbol of resurrection l Fire is intrinsically connected to both the Torah and the Ruach Ha-Kodesh (Holy Spirit) Traditions of Shavuot l Traditional date of the Giving of the Torah at Sinai l Traditional date of King David's burial l An aliyah (Going up) festival (The Second of three: Pesach, Shavuot, Sukkot), called Regaliym (moments, waiting) l Observant Jews study Torah through the night (Liel Shavuot) l Observant Jews read the megillat (Scroll) of Ruth l Observant Jews eat dairy foods l Observant Jews pray the prayer Yitzkor (Remembrance), including Kaddish (mourner’s prayer) in memory of lost loved ones Why eat dairy foods? The Rabbis taught that it is because the Torah is likened to milk and honey (Imrei Noam re. SOS 4:11). The Hebrew word for milk Chalav has a numerical value of 40, the number of days Moses was on the mountain. Further, the gematria of gevina (cheese) is 70, corresponding to the "70 faces of Torah” and the 70 elders of Israel. Why read Ruth? Because the events of megillat the scroll of Ruth* take place at the time of the barley harvest and culminate in the wheat harvest. *The scroll of Ruth speaks of the Kinsman Redeemer Boaz who is a figure for the King Messiah. His name meaning “Coming Strength.” There was a Beginning at Sinai During the Giving of the Torah, and a New Beginning at Mt Zion During the Outpouring and Infilling of the Ruach HaKodesh (Holy Spirit): Acts 2:1-2 Shavuot [CE 33] 2:1 When the day of Shavuot had come, they were all together in one place. 2 Suddenly there came from heaven a sound like a mighty rushing ruach wind, and it filled the whole house where they* were sitting. *“They” were the 120 followers who had been part of Yeshua’s retinue including the twelve (-1) talmidim (disciples), His mother Miriyam, His brothers and other female talmidot (disciples). All these were Jews, ethnic, religious, chosen, empirical (Acts 1:13-15, 26). As at Sinai, so too at Moriah (Mt Zion) Shemot (Exodus) 20:18-19 Shavuot [1300 BCE] “18 All the people witnessed the thundering and the lightning, and the sound of the shofar, and the mountain smoking. When the people saw it, they trembled and stood far off. 19 So they said to Moses, “You, speak to us, and we will listen, but do not let God speak to us, or we will die.”” Acts 2:3-4 Shavuot [33 CE] 2:3 And tongues like fire spreading out appeared to them and settled on each one of them. 4 They were all filled with the Ruach ha-Kodesh and began to speak in other languages as the Ruach enabled them to speak out. Numbers 11:16-17 TLV Shavuot [1300 BCE] ‘Adonai said to Moses, “Bring me 70 of the elders of Israel whom you know to be elders of the people and their leaders. Take them to the Tent of Meeting, so they may stand with you there. 17 Then I will come down and speak with you there, and, I will take some of the Ruach that is on you and will place it on them. They will carry with you the burden of the people, so you will not be carrying it alone”’ At Sinai the Spirit is given so that the burden of the Torah might be mitigated. The Spirit is prophetically promised to Israel, who are to share the Good News of God’s redemptive purpose to all nations. Thus 70, Elders representing the nations. Now at Moriah (in Jerusalem), 120 Jews representing the fullness of God’s promise to Israel (Rom.11:25-29), receive the Ruach Ha-Kodesh (Holy Spirit), that they might share the Good News of Yeshua to all those Jews gathered from throughout the known world. Jews who will believe (3000) and take the Good News back to the nations that they have travelled from to come up to Jerusalem for the aliyah Festival of Shavuot. Thus, the two loaves of challot (yeast bread) of the wave offering, the Jews and the Nations. Acts 2:5-16 Shavuot [33 CE] 5 Now Jewish people were staying in Jerusalem, devout men from every nation under heaven. 6 And when this sound came, the crowd gathered. They were bewildered, because each was hearing them speaking in his own language. 7 And they were amazed and astonished, saying, “All these who are speaking—aren’t they Galileans? 8 How is it that we each hear our own birth language? 9 Parthians and Medes and Elamites and those living in Mesopotamia, Judea and Cappadocia, Pontus and Asia,10 Phrygia and Pamphylia, Egypt and parts of Libya toward Cyrene, and visitors from Rome 11 (both Jewish people and proselytes), Cretans and Arabs—we hear them declaring in our own tongues the mighty deeds of God!” 12 And they were all amazed and perplexed, saying to each other, “What does this mean?” 13 Others, poking fun, were saying, “They are full of sweet new wine!”14 But Peter, standing with the Eleven, raised his voice and addressed them: “Fellow Judeans and all who are staying in Jerusalem, let this be known to you, and pay attention to my words. 15 These men are not drunk, as you suppose—for it’s only the third hour of the day! (9am) 16 But this is what was spoken about through the prophet Joel: Acts 2:17-21 (Yoel [Joel] 2:28-32) 17 ‘And it shall be in the last days,’ says God, ‘that I will pour out My Ruach on all flesh. Your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, your young men shall see visions, and your old men shall dream dreams. 18 Even on My slaves, male and female, I will pour out My Ruach in those days, and they shall prophesy. 19 And I will give wonders in the sky above and signs on the earth beneath-- blood, and fire, and smoky vapor. 20 The sun shall be turned to darkness and the moon to blood before the great and glorious Day of Adonai comes. 21 And it shall be that everyone who calls on the name of Adonai shall be saved.’ Acts 2:22-25 22 “Men of Israel, hear these words! Yeshua ha-Notzri—a Man authenticated to you by God with mighty deeds and wonders and signs God performed through Him in your midst, as you yourselves know— 23 this Yeshua, given over by God’s predetermined plan and foreknowledge, nailed to the cross by the hand of lawless men, you killed. 24 But God raised Him up, releasing Him from the pains of death, since it was impossible for Him to be held by it. 25 For David says about Him, Acts 2:25b-28 (Tehilim [Psalm] 16:8-11) ‘I saw Adonai always before me, for He is at my right hand so that I might not be shaken. 26 Therefore my heart was glad and my tongue rejoiced; moreover, my body also will live in hope, 27 because You will not abandon my soul to Sheol or let Your Holy One see decay. 28 You have made known to me the paths of life; You will fill me with joy in Your presence.’ Acts 2:29-31 29 “Brothers, I can confidently tell you that the patriarch David died and was buried—his tomb is with us to this day. 30 So because he was a prophet and knew God had sworn with an oath to him to seat one of his descendants on his throne, [f] 31 David saw beforehand and spoke of Messiah’s resurrection—that He was not abandoned to Sheol, and His body did not see decay. We note that one of the traditions of Shavuot which those listening were mindful of is the tradition concerning Shavuot being the date of King David's burial. Acts 2:32-35 (Tehilim [Psalm] 110:1) 32 “This Yeshua God raised up—we all are witnesses! 33 Therefore, being exalted to the right hand of God and receiving from the Father the promise of the Ruach ha-Kodesh, He poured out this—what you now see and hear. 34 For David did not ascend into the heavens; yet he himself says, ‘Adonai said to my Lord, “Sit at my right hand, 35 until I make Your enemies a footstool for Your feet.”’ Acts 2:36-47 36 “Therefore let the whole house of Israel know for certain that God has made Him—this Yeshua whom you had crucified—both Lord and Messiah!” 37 Now when they heard this, they were cut to the heart and said to Peter and the rest of the emissaries, “Fellow brethren, what shall we do?” 38 Peter said to them, “Repent, and let each of you be immersed in the name of Messiah Yeshua for the removal of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Ruach ha-Kodesh. 39 For the promise is for you and your children, and for all who are far away—as many as Adonai our God calls to Himself.” 40 With many other words he warned them and kept urging them, saying, “Save yourselves from this twisted generation!” (Deut. 32:5) 41 So those who received his message were immersed, and that day about three thousand souls were added. 42 They were devoting themselves to the teaching of the emissaries and to fellowship, to breaking bread and to prayers. 43 Fear lay upon every soul, and many wonders and signs were happening through the emissaries. 44 And all who believed were together, having everything in common. 45 They began selling their property and possessions and sharing them with all, as any had need. 46 Day by day they continued with one mind, spending time at the Temple and breaking bread from house to house. They were sharing meals with gladness and sincerity of heart, 47 praising God and having favor with all the people. And every day the Lord was adding to their number those being saved. From Sinai (Horeb) to Moriah (Jerusalem): The Gospel in Shavuot Sinai = Thorny Horeb = Desert, dry place Moriah = HaShem (YHVH: Mercy sees, YHVH: Mercy chooses) Jerusalem = Outpouring of Peace In a thorny desert place (In our sinful state) we heard the Word (Torah: Instruction of God) and those who chose to pursue the goal of the Torah (Romans 10:4), having been seen and chosen by God (Mercy), received the outpouring of His peace, the Comforter, the Spirit of the Father and the Son. Copyright 2022 Yaakov Brown As Messiah following Jews we see that the resurrection day of our Messiah corresponds to Yom Habikkurim-if ironically-with the Tz'dukim view. This is ironic because the Tz'dukim did not believe in the resurrection of the dead. A poignant reminder that truth is truth, whether we believe it or not. In the Torah God instructs Israel to count the omer from the day after the Shabbat of Pesach (Passover) for seven sevens, after which the festival of Shavuot (Pentecost) begins.
"You shall count for yourselves -- from the day after the Shabbat, from the day when you bring the Omer of the waving -- seven Shabbats, they shall be complete. Until the day after the seventh sabbath you shall count, fifty days..." -Vayikra/Leviticus 23:15-16 "You shall count for yourselves seven weeks, from when the sickle is first put to the standing crop shall you begin counting seven weeks. Then you will observe the Festival of Shavu'ot for the L-RD, your G-d." -D'varim/Deuteronomy 16:9-10 The purpose of this counting was to give clear direction to the future agricultural society of Israel as to how and when the moed (Holy Festival) of Shavuot (Pentecost) of HaShem was to be kept in relationship to the Pesach/Passover. During second Temple times, the P'rushim (Pharisees) and the Tz'dukim (Sadducees) disagreed on the dating of the beginning of the counting. The P'rushim insisted that the Shabbat referred to, was the High Shabbat of Pesach, whereas the Tz'dukim believed it was the weekly Shabbat of Pesach. Following the destruction of the Temple in 70 CE the P'rushim sect became the reformers of Judaism, taking it from its Temple reliant observances into a rabbinical halakhic form that in turn affected the liturgy of Judaism and also its common observances. Therefore, today we begin the count on the day following the High Shabbat of Pesach. However, as Messiah following Jews we see that the resurrection day of our Messiah corresponds to Yom Habikkurim-if ironically-with the Tz'dukim view. This is ironic because the Tz'dukim did not believe in the resurrection of the dead. A poignant reminder that truth is truth, whether we believe it or not. An omer is a unit of measure. On the second day of Passover, in the days of the Temple, an omer of barley was cut down and brought to the Temple as an offering. This grain offering was referred to as the Omer. Every night, from the second night of Pesach (Passover) to the night before Shavu'ot (Pentecost), we recite a blessing and state the count of the omer in both weeks and days. So on the 13th day, you would say, "Today is thirteen days, which is 1 week and 6 days of the Omer." Follow this link for the Brakhot shel Omer (Blessings of the Omer): http://www.chabad.org/holidays/sefirah/omer-calendar.htm This time of counting and expectant waiting is of additional importance to the follower of Yeshua because as well as the celebration of the harvest at Shavuot and the delight in the remembrance of the giving of the Torah at Sinai, we also anticipate the remembrance of the giving of the Spirit of the living Word, the pouring out of the Ruach Ha-Kodesh (Holy Spirit) upon and within the disciples of Messiah. We count with hopeful and expectant hearts as we continue to pray for that day--spoken of by Shaul in Romans 11-when all Israel (chosen, ethnic, religious, empirical) will be saved. Copyright 2022 Yaakov Brown |
Yaakov BrownFounder of the Beth Melekh International Messiah Following Jewish Community, Archives
December 2024
|